Search Results
Search this site
287 results found with an empty search
- OTSH 89: Handwriting & Beyond with Dr. Beverly Moskowitz, DOT, MS, OTR/L, FAOTA
Click on your preferred podcast player link to listen where you enjoy podcasts Welcome to the show notes for Episode 89 of the OT Schoolhouse Podcast. In this episode of the OT Schoolhouse Podcast, we have a very special guest with decades of experience in helping therapists, teachers, and adults around the world to support students with handwriting difficulties. Dr. Bev is a nationally recognized speaker with 43+ years of experience as an Occupational Therapist. As a school therapist, she serviced more than fifteen school districts, visiting over 60 individual schools. She has experienced the shift of practice in the schools over the years and shares her knowledge with us in this interview. A creative entrepreneur, determined researcher, and tireless professional, she is also the author of The Size Matters Handwriting Program. Currently used in every state and 5 continents, its concept-driven approach to teaching and remediating handwriting has been proven effective at a .001 level of significance in the largest research study ever done on handwriting. I am excited to have Dr. Moskowitz joining us to talk about all things School-Based OT. You can listen to the audio version above or on your preferred podcast player. Or you may watch the interview below. Either way, I hope you enjoy this episode of the OT School House Podcast! Links to Show References: Learn more about Dr. Moskowitz and her programs at RealOTSolutions.com Transcript Download the Transcript or read the episode below! Jayson Davies Hello there, and welcome to the very first episode of 2022. I cannot believe that I am saying that. But welcome to 2022 Thank you so much for taking the time out of your early week or maybe the second week, or maybe you're listening to this a lot later. But thank you for taking the opportunity to listen to this podcast. Today we have a very special guest who in the world of school-based occupational therapy probably needs no introduction, but I'm going to give her one anyway, we have on the wonderful the talented, the evidence-based Dr. Beverly Moskowitz of the Size Matters handwriting program and the realotsolutions.com website. I'm so excited to have Beverly on today. Many of you have probably seen her in the halls of the AOTA conference, or maybe your state associations, she just has so much energy, so much passion for occupational therapy, and also a passion for the research behind occupational therapy. So I'm excited to have her on this day. We are not only going to talk about her size matters handwriting program, but also a future endeavor that she is working on. But we're also going to have Beverley talk a little bit about her experiences as a school-based occupational therapist. She has been a school-based occupational therapist for several decades. And so she's kind of seen our profession evolve over the years back when we didn't even really participate in IEPs and IEPs were very unofficial to where we are today where an IEP is the backbone of every single student that we see for the most part unless we're doing five-oh fours and RTIs or students study teams, SST's or whatnot. So be sure to put that phone away, put it in your pocket, and just enjoy this episode. It is so much fun. This is actually a recording of a live episode that Beverly and I did together on YouTube. And if you'd like to watch the video, the recording of the video that we did, you can do that at otschoolhouse.com/episode 89. Or you can just continue to listen and you will get the audio version of that right here right now. So stay tuned. Enjoy the episode, and I like to welcome to the OT Schoolhouse podcast, Dr. Beverly Moskowitz. Enjoy the episode. Hello, hello, everyone, and welcome to a very special edition of the OT Schoolhouse podcast. Thank you so much for being here this afternoon and evening with us today. I am your host, Jayson Davies. And if you are here, please just type into the chat, let me know that you're here. Maybe type in there where you're from, or if you're an occupational therapist, or an occupational therapy assistant just helps us to feel a little bit more involved and engaged when we see that chat going on. And we really appreciate that. So if you can take a moment to go ahead and let us know that you are on in the chat. We really appreciate that. Awesome. We have Andres here from an occupational therapist from Illinois. Thank you so much for being here. I'm just thanking you for typing into the chat. I'm just making sure we've got everything set up for our questions. Thank you all. We already have 10 likes here have, I believe Around 20 people or so watching live. So we really appreciate you being here this evening, this afternoon with us and we're actually going to go ahead and get started. We have a very special guest today. Her name is Dr. Beverly Moskowitz, and she is an OT a doctor of occupational therapy. She is a fellow of the AOTA Association. She has done the research. And as many of you probably know, she is the creator of the Size Matters handwriting program, and also the owner at realotsolutions.com. So I'm very excited to welcome to our show, Dr. Beverly Moskowitz. So there you see her right there. Before I dive in and say hello to Beverly real quickly. Thank you, Tanya. Thank you, Jennifer. Thank you, Debbie, Aaron. All these showing up really appreciate you being here. So let's go ahead and let's dive right into it. Welcome to the show. Dr. Beverly Moskowitz. How are you doing today? Beverly Moskowitz I'm great. I'm excited to be here too. I have to share with everybody. This is my first podcast. So I'm a little nervous on my end that I speak all the time. But honestly, when I'm in front of a camera or a microphone, sometimes it's like I don't even know English. So I hope that this is coherent and fun for you. I am excited to go forward. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And as I mentioned, you know this is very different. Usually when we record a podcast simply for the OT Schoolhouse podcast. We do it without an audience but today we have a live audience As everyone here from all over the country, and it's just it's going to be an exciting show. If we have some time, in the end, we'll do some Q&A, which will be even more fun. We don't usually get to do that on a podcast on all audio podcasts. So, yeah, I'm excited to get right into this. And, you know, the first thing I wanted to ask you actually is about your early career and how you found your way into pediatrics and working as an occupational therapist with kids in schools. Beverly Moskowitz Well, first, I have to share, I'm doing this for 46 years, I can't even believe that much time went by it goes by in a blink. So I graduated in the 70s. In the 70s, you could practice with a bachelor's degree. So I got a BS from the University of Pennsylvania no longer even has a program anymore. And back then you had two rotations, you did adult rehab you did or rehab and psychiatry if you want to do pediatrics, you had to do an extra three months. I always knew I wanted to work with kids. And so I chose to pursue the third rotation. We call them internships back then. Their fieldwork right now. But I always knew that I wanted to work in peds only this big, to begin with, so bigger than the kids. Jayson Davies That's funny. Yeah. And so what was your first job, actually? Did you end up directly into a school? Or were you in a clinic? Or what did that look like? Beverly Moskowitz Okay, so, first of all, there weren't a whole bunch of jobs out there. Hospitals, or odd children's clinics, their school practice wasn't a thing. So you really had to be created if you want to work with kids. And ultimately, you had lots of little contracts. My first contract was in a residential facility. And no back. This is the 70s that kids were kind of warehouse and I hate to say it, but that was a reality of life. If you had a severe disability you were put into an institution. So I worked in an institution for a few months, I didn't love it. And then I got an opportunity to go to the St. Edmund's home for Crippled Children. And that's what they called it back then they use that language because they wanted to get the donations and the sympathy money. And they needed a department head, I had only been working two months, I became the department head. I was at the department of one. So I worked at St. Edmund's for two years, I will share with you my career just took off. The church was very generous in sending me to every single course that I ever got a flyer for. And I do encourage everybody, if there are new graduates out there amongst you, every time that you can read something, take a course listen to a podcast, apparently they're educational. Do it, do it, I took everything out there. And I really felt like my learning curve had been expedited. And then after that, I got involved with a consulting group. So get back in the 70s, there was an institution called Pennhurst that had all of these disabled adults, and it had been decided that was inhumane. So different agencies were bringing these disabled adults into the community in group homes. I became the coordinating consultant for and I'm talking to you from Philadelphia, right now, Philadelphia and the surrounding counties. I went to all of these group homes and created programs for the staff to do with the people that were living in these homes. And I traveled the entire city I put a lot of mileage on. But again, in terms of could you work in pediatrics, you could work in related developmental disability fields. So I would do that for a few hours. But then I would also work in a preschool center, and then I would do a sheltered workshop. And I would do some other residential facilities or home care like I worked 15 different contracts. I, when I started to work in schools, was still juggling a whole bunch of contracts. But none of it was ever a full-time job. If you got a few hours in a school, that was that day, Tuesday mornings, I'm in this particular school district, then I got one that was an hour and a half. I mean a day and a half of work. So you, you stitched all of your contracts together to make a living. Now, of course, schools have multiple therapists, but I was the only one for around 15 different school districts. I visited more than 60 different schools, sometimes as many as seven in a day. Jayson Davies Wow. Wow, that's a lot. Wow. Yeah. And you know, as you mentioned now it's very different whether you work for a district in itself or even a contractor. You're primarily going to be in the schools. There are some contractors that will still have you maybe come back to the clinic and the Afternoon or something like that. But for the most part, we kind of stick to either clinic-based or school-based, which is very different than what you were doing where you'd have so many different contracts at a time. So yeah, that's pretty crazy. You mentioned that you had to go and get some training. At that point in your career very early in your career, what was concerning to you? Or what did you feel like you needed to learn in order to do your job? And what did you reach out for? Beverly Moskowitz So um, I learned a lot of stuff in school, but I wasn't really sure if I was being effective. I, I've always had the drive to know that my time was worth it. It was worth it to me, it was worth it to the person I was working with. And I made a difference. So there was a lot of back then we were not an evidence-based profession. But because I had this internal drive, I was always testing myself to see if I could make a difference. Was I being effective in school? Was I being effective at home? Did people really enjoy the fact that I had been there? Did I make a difference there? So I was reading, I was learning I was taking courses, I was trying everything, you could play around a lot more than that actually was kind of nice. Now, evidence-based practice is definitely the way to go. But when we had no evidence, you were doing your own experimentation all the time. And I was always creative and always trying things out. And that's kind of how they have already played around back then. Jayson Davies Yeah. Beverly Moskowitz But I Yeah, it was more loosey-goosey. And I had to be resourceful. We didn't have any internet. You know, you had to go to conferences and learn from your colleagues. Jayson Davies Yeah. And you mentioned how and before we got on here, you actually just mentioned how you didn't even have to do paperwork back then. And just helping somebody. Beverly Moskowitz So don't shoot me, anybody. This is what so what was school-based OT like back in the western working in schools in the late 80s, early 90s. And there was no requirement for paperwork. I'm not sure that IEPS had reared its head yet. But all notetaking was a little bit looser. And nobody knew what I was doing. Now I had been recruited. It was very interesting my reputation as somebody that understood why I was there, it was never supposed to be about me, it really is about everybody else. And listen, friends, it's probably like alike attention. I'm standing in front of you, podcasting right now. But I know when I'm in a school, I'm really there to serve. I'm there to serve the teachers and the kids and the parents and make sure everyone gets along. So I knew that and I was recruited by the district in which I lived, which was fantastic as my kids went there. And just the same, I wanted them to invite me back. So I created paperwork, I, I created what I call the summary of Service Report, at the end of the year, I wanted them to know, everything I worked on so that they thought you know, we should have that back. She does all that stuff. Now, of course, we're drowning in paperwork. But when I didn't have to go to any meetings, we had, no, there were no IEPs, there was news data collection, I will tell you, there was no security. So when I was covering all of those schools, I could drive up to the back door run in do my little magic. Of course, I had no office. So you have to do your math in the hallway. And the closet, literally in the closet, on the stage, the cafeteria, you had no budget, you are buying your own stuff. Teachers still buy their own stuff. It's called investment in your in yourself. Lots of changes that you know that over time, some good and not some not so good. Jayson Davies Right? And so do you remember when there was a large shift and when you really started to get invited to IEPs? And they're starting to ask you maybe for progress on goals? I mean, does that even, or did it just kind of gradually happen over time. Beverly Moskowitz So a little bit gradually. But yeah, there was a period of time where this thing called the IEP reared its head. And putting this in perspective, it wasn't clear even to the administrators who were training us on how these things worked. They were always opening up their manuals to try and like get a little bit more clarity on what OT service should be. And, you know, we were a line item related service was a line item next to transportation. That's, you know, where they put related services. So everybody was figuring out but language started to populate the day FAPE free and appropriate public education was not always a thing. Least restrictive environment. So that was interesting. And I had really good intuitions I really felt way back when that you want me in the classroom. You don't want me pulling kids out? How? How am I going to know what you need kids to do? How are you going to know what I did if I can show you? So from the very beginning, even before this collaborative model evolved, before the least restrictive environment was more fleshed out a, as a concept as a strategy. I was pushing into classrooms, and I was learning from them. And that was something that later evolved. But it wasn't always the case that I'll share with you also, there was a period of time, for better or for worse, that the teachers, the therapists, you wrote through what their dream plan was going to be the education plan. And then during the 90s, I forget which President which act it was, but parents got a lot more power. And that's a good thing. It actually is good that parents have a seat. I know that that wasn't always the case, there was a very long period that parents had to accept whatever their school said was the right thing, even if it meant shipping them off their kids off to a different school, not their home schools. So that happened where I was. And then when they started bringing home these kids into our home district, we had to figure out how we're going to accommodate them. So I saw a lot of changes, parents having a voice, bringing in advocates, lots of paperwork, those procedural safeguards. They didn't always use to be a thing. Okay, now, just recycled it. But yeah, a lot of changes. At this point, right. I do think the pendulum might have swung a little bit too far to the side of deferring to parents. And listen, I'm a parent too. But sometimes you want the professionals to weigh in and give you some guidance there. I observed a Facebook discussion today where an advocate had apparently vetoed all the OT's goals. I'm like, Oh, I believe that's overstepping. So, okay, so it has to swing back a little bit. Jayson Davies Yeah. And it's hard to find that balance. But you're right. It used to be a team decision, not a parent decision, not an advocate decision, not an OT decision, a team decision. And so we all have to kind of agree. So yeah, right there with you. Alright, I do want to step into the present. But I have one more thing that I want to talk about or ask you about how things have changed. And that's evaluations. How have you seen evaluations change over time? Beverly Moskowitz So, um, I want to talk about valuations and treatment. Okay, we really didn't have a big repertoire of avails back, then we had some developmentally. And that's what we did. Now, I'm gonna be honest with you, I'm a really good therapist, I have never cured somebody who has an intellectual disability. Okay, so I, I felt all along. Why are you asking me to do developmental vows, the child's always going to not measure up, I get there, so functional, and you really don't need OT services if the teacher can fully include them in all the activities, and they're participatory. So that was back then the evals, the evals have evolved, we have more criterion-referenced, we still have standardized assessments, I get it, you need to have some kind of barometer. So you can measure change. Not a big fan of a lot of standardized assessments, I'll be honest with you, they typically never speak to what I was working on. So I'm more a fan of what we call now performance-based assessments. I think that was a smart move in evaluations, moving away from a deficit-based evaluation process, I don't want to know all the things that kids can't do, I want to know what they can do. And if that's still problematic, that's where I'm starting. So that's been a lovely evolution in our services moving away from the deficit-based to what we call the strength-based assessment, in terms of up treatment, pushing into the classrooms, I think is the right thing to do. Now, I've been in schools where they have these gorgeous OT departments, I was invited to one of those schools with a gorgeous OT department. And I said to them, so I think this is really mixed messaging. Like, I don't think you want me to have a medical model. And when parents see this, they want that pull-out service. You want me to go into your classroom. And in terms of all that stuff that you have, that's in the cabinets that you allowed the previous OT to buy, that's lovely, but I think you want to use that either. You won't be using this stuff that's already in the classroom because isn't that the stuff that kids actually have to use during the course of the day? So I'm very practical and my straight talk appeal to a lot of administrators, as I said, my reputation as somebody who got it was out there and I never looked for job districts always sought me out because they knew that I would do the right thing by the district, by the kids, the teachers, and the parents. Jayson Davies And that's interesting because you know, we do have this clinic model school model. And to kind of go back and forth, you really don't see the education model going into the clinic, but you do see the clinic model going into education a lot. And you're right, I've worked at districts where we do have a, maybe it's one clinic at one of the schools where more of the autism classrooms are based, or there might even be a few motor labs or whatever we might want to call them. And that does, it's moving into the classrooms more, it's moving into the schools more I should say. And so that's, that is a very interesting talk. And we have that talk a lot with all OTs that I talked to about, you know, what's clinic-based? What's educational based? Should we be pulling kids out of a classroom to provide 30 minutes of some sort of sensory type of therapy? And I, as someone asked me earlier, like, Is their research to back some sort of sensory in schools, and there really isn't most sensory research that's out there are three times a week, for an hour for 10 weeks, I've never seen a school-based occupational therapist have three hours a week with a student, that just isn't going to happen. On the flip side, you're saying, well, that kids now miss three hours of education every week, who would agree to that? Beverly Moskowitz So also, Jayson, our charge when we go into schools is to promote function and participation, their research, and if you look up, Helen Pola Tyco, there's a whole bunch of other articles out there, sensory integration, and I got certified way back in the 70s, the original Southern California sensory integration tests, I got certified and all that. But the research on using sensory integration therapy has not shown that it facilitates function. That's a problem. That's what we're supposed to be doing in school, and you're gonna tell me I'm doing all this swinging, it's not promoting that child's ability to actually work within the classroom? No, it's not. Does it impact the quality of life? All that's valuable. But when we're in school, we really have to get down to how can I give that child the movement experiences I read today on Facebook about how do I stop a child from tilting his chair back? Well, don't stop him from fooling. But think of a safer chair, because the child's telling you, he needs that movement. So that's the kind of sensory stuff that we can do in school, we should not be doing sensory integration therapy. Now, Lucy Jane Miller, at the star Institute is doing research on how to better measure the effectiveness of sensory treatment on function. Those are the things that we need to be measuring. Because when you administer, those SIP tests, and you go through all your fancy treatments, we administer those sub-tests, there's no significant difference. Jayson Davies Interesting. Interesting. Yeah, I know, that's going to continue to go on. And I know we need more research because there just hasn't I don't think there's been a sensory-based program that has been studied or researched using any sort of a school-based model. And until we get some sort of research where the sensory model can somehow be integrated into a school model, then I don't even think we can truly compare what could happen at a school versus what can happen in a clinic. There's a lot of research out there. We need more research in both sensory Beverly Moskowitz respectful, Jean Ayres, is it a she's like, whoa, brilliant, we are also indebted to the body of knowledge that she gave our profession. But as, as I read today, hey, listen, Facebook is awesome. And I resisted Facebook. Okay, not as long as I resisted podcasting, but I resisted Facebook. And then I discovered these wonderful discussion groups that OTs are having on Facebook. So there was something about the weighted vest today. And you know, how what's the protocol for a weighted vest is no research supporting weighted vest weighted blankets. Now, that's not to say, we haven't found the right variable to measure exactly. Cause we all know how nice it feels to get a nice hug. You know, when our children are upset how that is what they need. So we need to measure there are some neurochemicals we have to kind of hook up with some lab and make their something but the evidence isn't there right now. It's not there with sensory integration treatment in terms of translating into function, so keep your eye on the board. When you're in school, you are a major problem solver looking for ways to promote function? Jayson Davies Absolutely. Speaking of function, I think one thing that has evolved over the last 20 years is tiered intervention and RTI. And so I would love to know your experiences with RTI, obviously, you've been talking about how you push into the classroom already. So how have you used RTI over the years? Beverly Moskowitz By coming across as pushy? Because I guess I am? I don't know. Jayson Davies No, no, not at all. Not at all. Beverly Moskowitz No, I say that, jokingly, it always struck me as the right thing to do. So way back, even in the 90s, when they were having discussions about kids that were struggling regular ed kids, I would inject myself into the conversation out because I would say, "Listen, it's such a better use of me now to help him to help anybody, then to then wait until he gets you to know, you have to make a referral." Now you commit me to do an evaluation. Now I've got to write score tests and write a report and go to a meeting. "Listen, if you let me come into your classrooms and speak with you now. And, and actually, I bet there are a few other kids who I could hope also, we can intercept these at-risk kids". I have this feeling way back when before RTI ever became an acronym. That's the way I wanted to practice. And apparently, I convinced enough people that that's how I built my practice and my reputation, I was somebody, I am not standing on ceremony, I'm going to help everybody, you can talk to me in the hallway, you can invite me into your classroom. Now, we have, you know, more bureaucracy now. And I get that too. But I always was pushing limits to see how much I would be able to avoid having to get into a lot of red tapes. So I sent you my message, here's what I want to do. I'm never gonna lie, I'm never gonna hide it from you, this is what I want to do. I want you to be okay with it. And they would say, okay, so sounds okay. So if that is something that sounds comfortable to you, if you feel like, you know what, I could see myself doing it, do it level with your administrators, I will share Iran handwriting clubs. And we call them handwriting clubs. They just happen to be facilitated by the OT, but we can call them OT, because if we call it OT, then we wouldn't need to have a referral. I don't want to do referral paperwork. It's not just being honest with you. We call it handwriting club. Jayson Davies It's true. It's true. Beverly Moskowitz Right? By running it by the administrators. Here's what I want to do. And they said, sounds fantastic. And then all those at-risk regular ed kids, who, you know, if you just had a few sessions with them, you tweaked a few things, gave them some adapted writing paper, taught them the rules on letter size, I'll get to that. You can make a difference. And so I was playing a kind of play fast and loose. I was making my own rules up as we went along. They were there were no really strict boundaries. Jayson Davies Yeah. And you know, sometimes I will say that it is better to ask for forgiveness than permission. Sometimes, you know, you go into a classroom, you get something working with one teacher, that one teacher, it's amazing how three other teachers come and ask for your help because you kind of stuck your neck, your neck out there, and got a group going with that one teacher. So I absolutely am right on the same page with you when it comes to RTI. Beverly Moskowitz Absolutely, I think that should be our motto. Jayson Davies Let's do it. Alright, so what have you found to be the most helpful when attempting to collaborate with teachers? We obviously just kind of talked about how you collaborated with the principal, but what about the teachers? Beverly Moskowitz Okay, so you got to be real, you got to connect with them. And you have to recognize they're professionals. They went to school thinking, you know, whether they're new grads, or they've been doing it for a really long time that they would be teaching, not sitting in the hallway themselves collecting data all day. They have so many layers upon layers of mandates. Differentiated Instruction is the right thing to do. Just the same. They are lesson planning for different groups for their classroom every single day. And they have to like juggling their and making sure that everybody is active. If you go into the classrooms, and they perceive that you're about to give them more to do. They're going to say, I'm good, thanks. Okay. And believe it or not, I did that because I have so many ideas to share, and they basically say, Okay, thanks, you know, any, okay, so yes, I have been known to overwhelm people, but I learned that the best use of my time is to listen to them to recognize we are on their turf. It is not about you and me. And I said that earlier, it's you know, listen, I'm getting plenty of attention right now. It really has that mindset. Well, you are there to serve in school, you are on teacher turf, you have to learn what they need to cover. So have those real conversations with them. Tell me about your curriculum. How are you assessing learning? What's your homework look like? How do you set up your assignments? Your room? May I play around? I've been known to Fench way a few rooms because I do that. But I asked permission first. I do before I forgiveness because I am moving furniture. But I also move furniture around I'm going to bring things I bring them gifts. It's a joke. It's not like I'm buying them an outfit or anything. But I will adapt the test for them. Can I try my hand at your test? Because I saw their test. It's visually overwhelming. Maybe I could make it much more linear on an adapted writing paper? Or could I move some desks around so that the child who really needs to be front and center it doesn't have to crane his neck to see the board moving away from the radiator because it makes a whole bunch of noise? That's a gift, you give a teacher. So if you want to have those connections with the teachers, let them know that personally, you come in peace. I say that to them. I'm not a spy. I'm not here to judge, right? I'm here to help. How can I help you? Yeah, I want to learn with you. And honestly, that kind of attitude will go such a long way in getting those teachers to open up. The ones that are overwhelmed. They have a whole new curriculum, they're in a master's program, their kids are sick at home, everybody has a life. They'll share that with you. And you'll say no worries, would you like me to create that test for you or to work in this in this center with you? They will be so grateful. So I don't know being human? Jayson Davies Yeah, you know, and some of my best experiences of school as a school-based OT come from working with the teachers. You know, we have great experiences when we work directly with the students, but you get such reward from working with the teachers as well. And also knowing that your knowledge of one teacher could potentially help 30 kids this year, and then even more kids throughout the lifetime of that teacher once they understand something so absolutely. So I want to dive into the Size Matters handwriting program that you so cleverly created. But I think this question might actually lead you there. I mentioned how I love working with teachers and that can be rewarding. What has been a super rewarding part of being a school-based OT for you? Beverly Moskowitz Wow. Well, what has been so rewarding of the connections, the connections with the teachers, the kids, to have people excited to see you in the hallway, I created a little gizmo we called it the budget, there was a device that attached to it, legs of a desk that kids would bounce on. This is before the bouncy band I had a model that I put in 30 seconds I had installed in their principal with saying the bed I need six more. And that room went on every desk in the classroom and the kids would stop me in the hall and say, Can I have one of those things? And I'm like, Who are you? I don't even know these kids. But I love that they recognize that I brought something into the classroom and they wanted it. I love it. The teachers sought me out they really only wanted my opinion that I had said something done something that stayed with them. And so that feels really good. And there's one story I wanted to share. And I'm sure you all have stories like this right now. But how do I know that I was on the right track? How do I know this inclusion part was going to be working very early in the beginning in the late 80s, early 90s. A parent knew her right she was having her severely cognitively impaired daughter in regular kindergarten cutest little thing, but she had Angel mints anyone have angel has to do with Angel mints you're pretty impaired. But those children were lovely to her daughter. And I sat in a meeting with his parents said for the very first time. She got to go to a birthday party. Her daughter was invited to a birthday party. And she was able to sit with the adults because the kids played with her daughter. And if I tell you that story is like 40 years old now. It still makes me cry. That's the right we're doing the right thing. It's the right thing to do. Jayson Davies Oh, yeah, I've had a pair of brothers with Angel mints and you're right very, they need a lot of support. And so that's so kind to some other students, some other kids were able to come and support. You know, I think it takes a certain type of person, to be an occupational therapist, to be an educator to be anyone that's going to come in and work with kids, especially kids with disabilities. And I think all of us as occupational therapists, working for those schools, we kind of have that heart that it requires, you know, the special education teachers have it too. And so Beverly Moskowitz not our kids, whether they ever grow up to be teachers or OTs, we want our kids to grow up to be kind. Yeah, to be able to see somebody with a disability and not be afraid of them to occlude them to talk to them. Jayson Davies Absolutely. Beverly Moskowitz You make such a difference to that parent. Maybe the child doesn't even know what that parent is most grateful for. Jayson Davies Absolutely. All right. Well, I know a lot of people know you for the size matters handwriting program, this program has helped 1000s if not more, tons of 1000s of kids and adults around the world to understand. So I want to ask you starting what is the size matters handwriting program? Beverly Moskowitz So as I said to you, way back when we could play around a lot. And I was getting all these handwriting referrals. And doing everything I had ever learned should be impactful. I'm working on my core strength by enhancing manipulation skills, perceptual skills, so they had done those assessments and the kids did really poorly. And using the prevailing handwriting program out there. And I'm not making a difference. I'm not nobody is any better. They're still printing the same way. This probably like 25 years ago, I started to play around with variables I thought might have more impact. And that's what I discovered that when I focused on letter size, the kids caught on really quickly to that that was really, you know, touching here. And what started to happen if you were have taken my course I tell this story. The special ed kids became the neatest printers in the school. And you know, it was always hanging there work in the hallway, not go by my classrooms, and it looks so beautiful. And the regular classrooms were horrible. So I asked a first-grade teacher, friend, could I try something in her classroom, I wondered if these ideas would translate. And I gave a 20-minute half-hour lesson in her room in first grade. That's it. Later the day, she flagged me down but you walked out of the room and everybody's printing changed. One parent later in the week, said to me, that the teacher caught up with me and said, a parent called to confess that she scolded her daughter for being so irresponsible, bringing home somebody else's assignment book. I was there once. So I had the sense that I thought I'm onto something. And I started to develop it and play with it a little bit. And then I went back to school for my doctorate. And I wanted to know what everybody is doing about handwriting in the country and in the world. So you're welcome to read my doctoral work. And I stayed connected with Temple University because I wanted to test my premises. And that's when we did and I'll, I'll get into the research, we designed the largest research study ever done on handwriting. And my methods were proven effective change scores were significant at a point, 001 level. That is massive. Jayson Davies Yeah. Yep. Absolutely. Actually, go ahead and explain that research a little bit. How was that put together? We had Beth Pfeiffer on the podcast not too long ago. And she talked about the program is this that the researcher was different research? Beverly Moskowitz So Beth, Beth Pfeiffer, everybody checks her out. She is beyond awesome. She's faculty at Temple University in Philadelphia. So after I finished my doctoral program, I did stay connected with Temple and I said to them, if you ever have a student looking for a study, bring it on. Later to doctoral candidates came forward. And in what turned out to be this first study. Now at this point, I was traveling around the country teaching and I would always say if you're interested in being a site for research, let me know, we had around 678 therapists say, Yeah, I want to participate. Let me share with you when you read the literature and you see the size of a study, be impressed. It doesn't matter how small definitely if it's big, you have to jump through such hoops to get to that point where your school is approved for participating in a research study. You got to write the IRB, which if you've done that, it's a pretty lengthy thing. By the time we finally were ready to launch, the eight schools dwindled to six to five. Ultimately, we had two school districts. That said, three grades, kindergarten first and second. Control and intervention in both grades. Over 200 students, three different standardized or criterion-referenced assessments. We had to our scores We had 15 scores in six different states because there were 1800 assessments to score and they had to sit through training videos and score samples and earn a reliability coefficient of 0.8, to qualify, all of that. I wrote, has anybody ever wants to replicate by study, a Fidelity manual, so exactly what was happening on day 15 In first grade, and Massachusetts, was happening in day 15, in first grade in New York, and so on. It was an eight weeks study, they did it every day. And again, being impressed with research makes it into literature, these people work hard. You need to get in, I needed to get out because you're gonna have to school. So it was a very brief period of time. That study was Beth was the lead investigator on it. Tammy, Mary, and Jillian Ray were also part of that study that got published in the OT Journal of Research in 2015. The second study was the one that you get Cheryl Zylstra. Cheryl was a doctoral candidate temple. And she did the second study with Beth Pfeiffer again, hers was smaller, but they correlated handwriting also with reading. So it kind of reading Facebook, you might think that's my it's like Wikipedia. Every it's Facebook. I don't know is that horrible? But I wonder what some of you are talking about so yeah, there was this advocate who wants technology, no handwriting. And I said, Well, what do they want the kids to learn how to read this. Handwriting supports reading technology does not problem-solving creativity. So anyway, Cheryl's study showed a very strong correlation between handwriting, and letter-sound and letter name recognition. That was that study, we had another study off, and Leigh and Leigh Akasha. And I hope that you're watching, she wanted to look at the self-monitoring component that we're very proud of. One of the unique features of size matters is that kids can score themselves. If they want to score each other, they can score each other do some peer monitoring, there is evidence on the benefit of giving kids that power. So she went to church to see whether there you know how powerful that is. So she looked at our second graders and wanted to ascertain the benefit of the self-monitoring, they rolled dice to determine practice. How silly is that? But we got to defer to it. They roll a five they're gonna make five-star worthy. Yeah, there's no they wrote one. We only have to make one but better Three Star Wars a year, you're making another one. The kids love that. And next thing, you know, kids are like, give me a six. Wait, you know, this game works, right? They love the power. They love the power so there's the buy-in. We had another study, this was thrilling. This was at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. I didn't even know it was happening to I saw it published in a journal I do my agents, they did a comparison of effect sizes of nine different handwriting programs. Some of those maybe I saw that one among your favorites. And they conclude when it came to legibility Size Matters are best. Now they did conclude we're not as good for speed Jayson Davies speed. I was gonna ask you about that. What's your reasoning on that? And do you think it's a problem? Beverly Moskowitz So that was funny. In that very first research study that kids did measurably slower, the intervention group kids were measurably slower when it came to writing. That said, the site managers in both locations said to me, that was so funny. When it came time for the post-testing. The kids were so careful to touch their pencils to the writing lines in all the right places that they were slower. Listen, we're looking for a longitudinal study. Does anybody out there want to do that? I believe. Yeah. So this was only an eight-week study. If we had a semester, the year I think you're gonna see it even out but okay, you have to report. That's what happened. Yeah. And here's my response. If the kids are writing fast, but you can't read it. Who cares? Jayson Davies Yeah. And to that point, what is one of the main things I think teachers say, in a classroom, they, their kids slow down, whether kids running across the room, or if they're going through math problems too fast if they're writing too fast. I mean, to your point, everything we need to slow down in a lot of time for kids, you know, reading to, they're not going to comprehend what they're reading, if they're going through it at the pace of a jackrabbit. They need to slow down and do the same thing with writing and everything else. I agree. Beverly Moskowitz In the beginning, let's get it right, and as you develop that automaticity? Yeah, the speeds gonna come. Jayson Davies Absolutely. Alright, what are the main cornerstones that you would say the Size Matters Handwriting Program is based on, obviously, size, it's in the name. But are there one, two, maybe even three other like Cornerstone blocks of information that you really focus on? Beverly Moskowitz So yeah, letter size is the biggie. But Size Matters is very responsive to the realities in school, you have to empower kids and these kids. First of all, if the kids have been on your caseload for a while, a few years, they're not happy about it. They want to, you know, there's something about always having to go to therapy, it makes them feel like there's something very wrong with them. We want we don't want that messaging, this program works quickly. It's amazing. If you're not using size matters yet, I'm going to suggest it is in your future, because I do believe it's the future, because it works so easily. Once you correct errors in letter size. That's what makes an immediate difference in the consistency, and therefore the readability of the page. And it is so easy to teach because there are only three sizes in the manuscript. So I can't undervalue that when you look at format, every other program is focusing on form, there are 62 of those your uppercase or lowercase numbers. And individually, if you looked at that your kids writing letter one that you could figure out what those letters are. It's in the context of the whole that it's a mess. And that's how you know it's not about form. It's also not about a workbook. So Size Matters is a concept-driven approach, I often say that you can get started right away with your knowledge alone, you don't need any material. Now we haven't here to make your own can make it faster, make it easier to use. But if you don't have anything, you can get started just by teaching the concepts that make it affordable for all those districts that have budgetary issues. And who doesn't? You can get started right away, just using your concepts. I also share with you stuff that you can make, that's the kind of therapist I am. I mean, we have stuff that's beautiful, and you know, nicely finished. But I didn't have stuff when I was figuring this out, I made stuff. And I'm going to share with you how you can make your make stuff to share in your classrooms. It's embeddable across the curriculum, that's another thing that no other program can say. Because it's not about 15 minutes of practice in a workbook a week, that's not going to get you anywhere. You have to have concepts and strategies that are that remind kids to think handwriting letter-size during science, social studies, they're writing word problems in math. And it can be as simple as just having the teacher walk around with dice. When the kids hear the dice, their ears perk up, because they know, at any moment, the teacher could stop by and say, Hey, Beth, a veteran is a star worthy. So in so many ways, it is a realistic program. And I'm not done with the research. We just finished a study up in Florida. That was lovely. They're pursuing publication there that talked about how teachers feel about bringing size matters into their classroom, what the perception is, we had another study that finished in I want to say Norristown, Pennsylvania, with kids on the spectrum. We have another study, listen, there's more and more, I just say bring it on, I am going to be the most heavily researched program out there. That's how confident we are. Jayson Davies That's great. Beverly Moskowitz How well it goes. Jayson Davies that's great. We need more research in the field of occupational therapy. So yes, go for it as much as you can. So you go around the world, or at least around you talked about you might be going around the world soon. But you definitely go around the country and teach others. What is your hope for the occupational therapist sitting at the middle desk in the third row of your training? What is your hope that they're going back to their school? And do Beverly Moskowitz I want them to get excited? As I said, I'm doing this for a long time. 46 years, and I'm still excited. I am odd when I go to conferences, and I hope that all of you join your state organization, join AOTA go to conferences. Our profession continues to evolve. We're so very grounded in the way we approach situations. I said to somebody today, I don't think there's ever a problem that OT can solve. We just haven't figured it out yet. But give it to an OT because we are so creative. There are so many different avenues to go in there. So I want that therapists coming to my conferences to feel my energy to feel excitement about this awesome profession. In that you have spent a lot of time and money becoming a part of the possibilities are endless, but do protect this wonderful profession. Because there are people, professions, I should say, who are jumping on the bandwagon. And we kind of have taken our eye off the ball by not joining our state organizations, people say I don't have to, so I'm going to save the dues. Listen, I call it the cost to do a business, recreation therapists are doing ADLs they are doing handwriting they're doing, you know, they say they own recreation. Actually, recreation was always part of an... So no, Pts are being more functional. They're recognizing that just standing or walking is not nearly as important as when you have to put your bookbag in the locker. So they're being more function-oriented. And the ABA therapists don't get me started. They have somehow moved to the front of the desk, the conference table, and they're telling us how to practice and they are not science-based. They're not evidence-based. How did that happen? Well, how it happened is that OT stop representing, and when you see a practice infringement, and you want to nip it in the bud, the lobbyists, the legislators in your state say well, how many people in your state? Are you representing how many people feel that way? And the sad fact is that only around 10% of practicing OTs are members of their state organization. So they say, Well, how do we know that the other 90% exists is important. That's a point. By contrast, recreation therapists are 90% of those practicing are members of their state organization. Jayson Davies Oh my gosh. Beverly Moskowitz I would word for word from the OT practice framework here in Pennsylvania and drop it into their licensure bill. And amazingly, there was somebody on Capitol Hill in Harrisburg, capital, Pennsylvania, who caught it. And so you can't say that, that's what OTs do. It is happening in your state. So listen, you don't have to be politically active unless you want to be. But you must pay your dues to protect your future. Jayson Davies Yeah, Beverly Moskowitz and then go to the conference be awed by the many ways that your colleagues have taken this body of knowledge and are applying it. That's thrilling. Jayson Davies Absolutely. All right, great. Well, I want to leave a little bit of time for some Q&A, because we do have about 50 to 60 people here with us tonight. But I do want to give you an opportunity to kind of transition because you're working on a new project. Obviously, you have the manuscript to size matters, handwriting program. That works all on uppercase, lowercase manuscript, but I think you're working on something in the future, right? Go ahead and explain that. Beverly Moskowitz So thanks, Jayson. This is a labor of love. For years, people have asked me for a Spanish edition, a cursive edition. Personally, I don't speak Spanish. So that was a big stumbling block right there. I didn't even know how I would attempt that. And in terms of cursive, I wasn't inspired. I didn't know how I was going to make my approach different, better than anybody else's. And then two summers ago, when the country looks like, like what happened, you know, we're like, can't we all just get along? I got it. I got my inspiration. Unlike the manuscript book, which is there's only one workbook and it practices a single letter at a time teachers are instructed, open up their literacy, social studies, pluck out words that are meaningful to your curriculum. That's what you want to write. Unlike a manuscript, cursive is all about connectedness. So I actually needed to identify words for kids to be writing. And, the words I chose to use were words of kindness, participation, inclusion, disability awareness, things that I think are so sorely missing nowadays, what happened to civility, and us learning how to have a polite discourse. So I have an advisory board. And we have built on the Size Matters principles, there's now a size four-letter. There are lots of motor learning opportunities where you practice making the movements of the letters. And then there are narratives and the narratives are written at grade level, second, third grade on these themes of acceptance and awareness and fineness with discussion questions. The words that the kids practice writing are extracted from the narrative. So they're a little contrived, because I've always tried to use the featured letter of the page on it, but the kids practice writing words that are meaningful reading words and having these lovely discussions about how they might include somebody who does Just make it simple. Suppose your arm is in a cast, how are you going to write. So it doesn't have to always be heavy-handed, but it gets the kids thinking about the challenges that are out there. So that's part of the beauty of this book, I will share too. It's illustrated by children. Beyond proud of that my own son did illustrate the cover. So it's dedicated to him. And I can just be a little bit personal here, he has a traumatic brain injury. So he qualifies as an artist in this book, but all of the children are exceptional. And the artwork is exciting, and I'm so so honored at the opportunity to celebrate these talented children. And then that's not all, that's the lowercase pages. I wanted to be authentic when it came to the uppercase pages. And to be authentic, you want to have a proper noun, which is a person place, or thing. I chose places because these are themes that are relevant, every place everywhere in the world. And so the uppercase pages actually have maps, different parts of the US different parts of the world, Europe and Africa and Russia, and China and Southeast Asia. And honest to goodness, I think this book is going to be a keeper because you're gonna love it. You're, I'm planning a vacation, I had, like, oh, well, I got a book as a map of them. It's a beautiful book, we have been working on a year and a half my advisory board, and I had a seven-hour meeting last Friday because they are so dedicated to this book, I believe that you'll love it, you will keep it you'll treasure it. And your kids are going to learn how to write in cursive, and how to be part of a kinder, more humane society. Jayson Davies I love that because I think as occupational therapists, sometimes we forget that, especially in the schools that were part of the education, and the idea that you're putting that geography in there. And you're using principles from the curriculum, and you're and you're throwing that in there. That's so important. So I think that's fantastic. Awesome. Looking forward to Beverly Moskowitz Worthing that the teacher amongst us suggested that we have additional STEM activities, which has now been expanded to steam science, technology, engineering, art, and math. So for those teachers that want to build a curriculum, there's a whole bunch of ways to expand on the lessons here are things to learn about, for instance, the AP age talks about accommodations and adaptations. And I think we talked about Temple Grandin under the steam pages Google her we tell the kids pretty, pretty fascinating lady, so much learning in this book, I'm just so as I said, so proud, so proud. This is a labor of love. I hope that you are interested in seeing it. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And you know, some people are already talking about just about the size matters handwriting program. So I'm going to actually bring up our first question from Jennifer, I can bring that right up here on the screen for us, and says, I've really enjoyed this. Thank you. If I would like to start the size matters in my schools, where should I start? Beverly Moskowitz So, Jennifer, there are a few ways to get started. You want to learn more about it. And to learn we have a so my website is called realotsolutions.com, you can take the three parts self-study webinar series, I am an approved provider of continuing through AOTA so you earn points seven CEUs. That's a self-study, or teaching a two-day live course in February on East Coast time. I should probably know those dates and I don't. But depending on where you are, you could do that in April. I'm teaching a two-day course on West Coast time, two days. Day one is the intro course, it's comparable to the webinar series. If you take the webinar, you can just take day two, day two is a therapist certification course if you would like to be certified as an SMHP therapist, all you want to take the day two course. And I send you, I send you a gift. I'm going to send you your handbooks, your lab materials, scoring kits, a few little extra goodies in there, pre SMHP materials. So that would be a good way to start. Educate yourself. If you want to get a proposal for your school, I'd be honored, I'm happy to craft a proposal. I always say this is the beginning of a conversation. I want to learn more about you. Whenever schools districts adopt size matters, they get a free hour of me I'm going to do training on the use of the materials. If you want a CEU course I'm happy to bring that also to you. But I always want to learn what is your budget what I don't want to tell you to get something if you can't afford this. Don't get it. We'll make it we'll make something that's going to be okay. Hey, maybe next year, you'll buy the MRB, the magnetic rec to square board. But in the meantime, a dental practice scoreboard, it's a big whiteboard that has lines on pink, a yellow-blue marker is very cute. Or you can make lines on your board and use pink, yellow and blue, a dry erase board. Anyway, so I'm going to share with you how you can get started, whether you want to propose, whether you want to pilot it. Another option, pilot studies, I can help you design one of those, I always suggest asking your administrator, that's okay as parents to have that there. Okay, teachers, you want to control in treatment. So you can say that differences and take pictures before and after? Because a picture is worth 10,000 words, I promise you. You're going to say, as I still say, wait, that was the beginning of the session? The end of the same session? Jayson Davies Wow. Yep. All right. This next question kind of leads into where I think you're going anyway. So what are some of your methods for providing push-in services with the Size Matters program? Would you provide instruction to the entire class? Beverly Moskowitz Yeah, yeah. Jayson Davies So how would you pilot that? Or how would you pilot that then for the administrator to see? Beverly Moskowitz So So pilot studies can be as detailed as you want, or as long as you want, or as short as you want. We've done four-week pilot studies, three-month pilot studies, full-year pilot studies. So first, it's going to start with a conversation about what do you envision? What permissions? Do you need parent administrators? And how many classes do you want? How many, you know, grades per classroom Do you want so let's flesh all that out. We talk about what the training is going to be like. And I like to empower you as I want you to be trained and you get me you get to talk to me, I'm happy to talk to you. So shy, I know it's gonna be hard. I'm going to support you make sure that you feel like you know how to launch it. So you want to get bit collects baseline samples, which could be as simple as the kids writing the alphabet, and a grade-level sentence, date it, initial it, so maybe, you know, we keep it a little bit blindly, we don't want to or your number. And so you really don't know who the child is. And then at the end of whatever interval, you decide, you want that pilot period to be the child's gonna write the alphabet, upper and lowercase, and that same grade level sentence and you're going to compare it, I always suggest buying one of those flipbooks, like at Staples Office Depot that has those proposal sheets in it, and you assemble it. When you present that to your administrators, I promise you they're going to go they will. Jayson Davies Yeah, I've seen that happen. I've done something similar. And sure enough, the next year, the principal set aside money in their budget to get a handwriting program. And so definitely it does work. I wanted to go a little bit further on Caitlin's question. She asked about doing this in the classroom, I want to be asked you a question that I don't know everyone's a little bit different. What does it require of you to do with the teacher? Do you think that we can just walk in and do this on our own? Or do we need to plan with the teacher ahead of time, collaborate a little bit before we go in, and do an entire classroom program? Beverly Moskowitz Well, you always want to collaborate with teachers, because I'll go back to where I said they were on their turf. I'm Yes, I'm there to support you. I certainly don't want to be pushy. So first, when I asked, may I come in? Would you like a policy? Would you be receptive to it? And you might have teachers say to you, yes, not this year, I'm overwhelmed, ah, blah, blah, blah, whatever is going on in their life, and they love you. So first get you to know, you have that relationship, that rapport building wasn't that like OT one on one, establish rapport, you want to have that rapport? And you want to ask for teachers, what would be a good time to come in? They may say I am, we are so far behind in our math curriculum that I need to add extra time on that. So listen, life, find out when that block of time is, and ask for some regularity. So if this is the block of time, can I come in every day? Can I come in three days a week? Do I have 20 minutes, you can get a lot done in 20 minutes if you're organized. So there are lots of questions to ask an answer before you launch a pilot study. And that said, I tell you this from experience, had a therapist love, love, love size matters. They have I want to do a research study. And by administrators, my everybody's ready to go and I'm like, I think that this is going a little bit too fast. But she was so enthusiastic. The bottom line was we didn't ask enough questions. And when the study was finishing, it was the end of the school year. And it was field day. Well, who wanted to be in class doing a post-test when it was Field Day. And even when they sat there, they were really distracted. So we didn't realize it was gonna be a vacation overlapping that the time here. Ultimately, all that hard work ended up not being a good study. So Jayson Davies yeah, we always got to look at the calendar. All right, we'll do one last question. This is kind of a question about your course, you already explained this a little bit, but just a little confusion on the difference between the three-part self-study and the two-day course. Beverly Moskowitz Ah, okay. So if you want to become a certified SMHP therapist, that's an intermediate level course, you have to take a qualifying prerequisite an intro course, to be eligible for the certification course. Now, if you've followed me at all, you may know that I have taught our long courses on ot.com, a marvelous site, those do not count as qualifying prerequisites, look at them as like a little preview a little supplement to what you're learning, but it's not sufficient in itself, still, definitely, you know, take them they you get to see you if you want to do that. The three parts of self-study, and that day one course essentially have the same content. Here's the difference. The self-study, self study your, your pacing yourself, you get to backup, if you want to listen to me again, you can watch it a two in the morning, if that's the only time that you're free, you do have to take a post-test. As I said, I am AOTA approved provider. And when you do distance education, there has to be proof that you paid attention that you took the course you just go to movies. So of there are three different post-tests that you have to take, I send you the links to the slideshow, the handout, the post-test link, and the course evaluation link, you have to download the handout. I talked about the lab materials, you don't actually do them. In the live course, it's me in real-time. I'm going to send you the handbooks, I'm going to send you the lab materials because I believe in fun, so we're gonna have fun together doing center time activity, you get to ask questions in real-time, the day one course is six hours versus the three-part webinar, which is seven hours. So there's a supplemental course, if you want that extra stuff that I just couldn't have you sitting there for seven hours, I can't sit there for seven hours either. So there's a little less content, but essentially the same content in the day one course as the self-study. Now we do the lab materials in the day one course, which we use the next day during the certification course. So it's fun. Because you get to play the games, a lot of games that you play in certification. If you took the self-study, you can still play the games, when you're just not gonna have the materials to submit one of your samples. But you're certainly welcome. A little bit of a budgetary issue difference too. So you get to decide this, this works for my budget, this works for my time. And if you can't take two days off in a row, I'm gonna tell you to take the self-study. And then just join me for the live course. Jayson Davies There you go. Beverly Moskowitz Get a certification. Jayson Davies All right. Well, Dr. Beverly Moskowitz, thank you so much for joining us today. It's been a real pleasure. We've been going on for about an hour, almost an hour and 15 minutes, we've had 50 to 60 people here consistently, just loving what you're saying. Thank you. Everyone who has joined us this afternoon. Really appreciate you being here. And I look forward to staying in touch with you, Beverly, and maybe taking that course alongside some of the people that are here today. So maybe. Beverly Moskowitz Listen, this has been hard for me to read the chat and like, look at you all to see that. But I am, you inform me and I would be honored. If you wanted to write to me, bev@realotsolutions.com. I would love to problem-solve with you. Certainly, if its size matters. I'm thrilled about that pick-up anything in school-based practice. So please don't hesitate. I always hope that above all that people feel connected. Sometimes we are so isolated out there. And I want people to know that I am. It would be my pleasure. You honor me by reaching out and allowing me to learn about your life and your practice. Jayson Davies Absolutely. Everyone takes that and uses it because it's very amazing to be able to collaborate with another therapist, just to get a little bit of event really appreciate you offering your assistance there. So thank you, Beverly. Thank you, everyone, for tuning in. Really appreciate you and we'll see you next time on the OT schoolhouse podcast. Take care. Bye. Beverly Moskowitz Bye, everyone. Jayson Davies All right, that was such a fun episode. I'm excited about that. When I'm excited to keep in touch with Dr. Moskowitz, she just has so much going on. Her passion for occupational therapy is off the charts. I love everything that she has to say. And I'm excited to keep in touch with her. Maybe we'll have her back on the podcast again in the future. Thank you. Huge shout out to Beverly for coming on taking the time to do this for us. And I really appreciate you for being here. Whether this was your commute your workout, your ADLs for the day just listening to a podcast, whatever it might have been. Thank you so much for being here and I will see you again on the very next episode of the OT Schoolhouse podcast. Take care. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT Schoolhouse podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now. Head on over to otschoolhouse.com. Until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT Schoolhouse email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT Schoolhouse Podcast
- OTS 88: Changing the Face of School OT Feat. Jaime Spencer, MS, OTR/L
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Welcome to the show notes for Episode 88 of the OT Schoolhouse Podcast. School-based Occupational therapists have been a part of public education since legislation was initially enacted in the 1970’s. Contrary to this, school-based OT practitioners often do not have pathways to educational leadership. OT practitioners are unable to serve as administrators within a school system in 46 states in the United States. In this special episode of the OTS Podcast, we will explore the unique qualities that OT practitioners possess that support leadership roles within a school system. Barriers to advancing into leadership positions (e.g., policy) OT practitioners’ face will be identified, and solutions will be discussed. The Audio in this episode comes from a 2021 presentation prepared for the Occupational Therapy Association of California Annual Conference. It is presented by Jayson Davies, MA, OTR/L, & Jaime Spencer, MS, OTR/L. You can listen to the audio version above or on your preferred podcast player. You may watch the presentation below. Links to Show References: Download the slides for this presentation directly below. CA School-Based OTs Looking for Change (Facebook group) USA School-Based OTs Looking for Change (Facebook Group) Transcript Download the Transcript or read the episode below! Jayson Davies Hey there, and welcome back to another episode of the OT Schoolhouse podcast. This is the final episode of 2021. And I cannot be more excited to have you here with me today. This is episode 88. And like I said, it's the final episode of 2021. I can't wait to come back in 2022 refreshed after a little winter break and come back hitting the ground running again, with the OT Schoolhouse podcast. It's been so much fun over the last few years putting this podcast together, we've had so many great guests, we've shared so many good stories together. And I'm just excited to continue this down the road. But for today in Episode 88, I am actually going to share with you a very special presentation that I and Jaime Spencer, from missjaimeot.com, put together for a recent conference here in California. It was the Occupational Therapy Association of California annual conference. And she and I put this presentation again about why they've put this presentation together about why occupational therapists should be credentialed within the schools. Some people think it's only because it would give us an opportunity to advance our leadership within the school system. But that is not the only benefit. In fact, there are benefits beyond that that will support the students that we work with. And so it's very important that at least again, myself and Jamie believe that we should be credentialed in the schools. Some states have already done this, but not every state. So if you're ready to kind of stick around and hear our reasoning about it, and potentially how to move forward with doing this, I encourage you to stick around and listen in. Jaime comes to us from New York, and obviously, I'm in California, we presented this in California. So it is somewhat California-specific. But she adds in some New York components. And we also tried to make sure that we add in some national components that it doesn't matter what state you're in, you're going to benefit from this as well. If you'd like to see the full visual presentation of this, we actually did record it and you can watch it at otschoolhouse.com/episode88. You're going to hear that same content, it's going to be a little more edited here. But you will see the same content at otchoolhouse.com/episode88. You'll just see all the slides and whatnot. As we are presenting so you can listen here or go watch it over there. Either way works or you can do both whatever complements your learning style. So stick around or head over to otschoolhouse.com/episode88 to hear this presentation that I and Jaime Spencer from Miss Jaime OT did together to promote occupational therapy within the schools. I hope you enjoy this special presentation Jaime Spencer Changing the face of school OT in California. Today we're going to talk about what's going on in the California Department of Education and how it's impacting school-based occupational therapy practitioners. My name is Jaime Spencer and I'm presenting today with my friend Jayson Davies. I've been a school-based occupational therapist for 22 years. I have a bachelor's in occupational therapy and a master's in special ed. I am a passionate advocate for school-based occupational therapists. I have a website and a blog at Miss Jaime OT where I help other therapists and other grownups to help their kids. It's really important to me to advocate for the value of school-based occupational therapy practitioners. I'm also doing research at Toro College of Health Sciences about occupational therapists and advocacy and leadership. Jayson Davies All right, and that brings me to me, my name is Jayson Davies and I am an Occupational Therapist here in Southern California. And I'd like to say that I am a school-based occupational therapist. I've been in the schools for about nine years now ever since I graduated from occupational therapy school at USC in 2012. And I just happened to fall into school-based OT and yeah, I just love being a part of that role. I did get my master's in occupational or occupational therapy at USC, and I am the host of the OT Schoolhouse podcast, where we talk about all things school-based occupational therapy. I'm also an adjunct thesis advisor for Stanford University and a mentor to OT practitioners. Today, we're going to go over three very specific items. We're going to summarize how the structure of California Department of Education systems impacts parity for school-based OTs. We're also going to identify three opportunities for school-based OT practitioners to showcase leadership, and then we're going to talk about how to apply these concepts to advocacy for school-based occupational therapists. So to get started, we have a question for you. If you had the power to change one thing at your school sites, what would it be? What about money? Would you like more pay or maybe a budget for your therapy supplies? That could be one of those things that you might want? Jaime Spencer Definitely. Jayson Davies Would you like to have more collaboration and a sense of belonging on campus to feel like you actually are part of the teachers union maybe or that you feel like you can go into the lunchroom and sit there and talk with everyone and be a part of that and have friends there? I mean, I'm not saying you can't do that. But maybe that's something that you might want. Some people just want to be a part of the Parent-Teacher Association and feel welcome there, that's perfectly fine. Maybe you don't want to be known as the handwriting teacher. Oftentimes, as school-based occupational therapists, we do work on fine motor skills. But sometimes it goes further than that. And we start to get referrals only for handwriting. And we're only known as the handwriting teacher, or the handwriting coach, maybe you want to be more than that. Maybe you want to be a leader on your campus, whether it is an official title of being a leader, or even in a commodity sense, you know, just being a leader, being able to coach the teachers provide professional development for the teachers, that's something that you might want. And then finally, maybe you just want to climb the ladder, and you want more opportunities to increase your pay, but also increase your leadership and your role within your school district. Jaime Spencer So Jayson, in my school, all of the teachers wear red on Thursdays, they're all on the same Union. But I don't get the shirt, because I'm not included in the teachers union. So while all of my colleagues are wonderful, and you know, we have a great rapport, I've been in the building for 22 years, there are a lot of things that I'm excluded from because I'm not in that union. So for example, I'm not included, or I'm not actually forced, or expected to be at their professional development meeting. And, you know, I've heard before leaders will say to me, "Oh, well, you're welcome to attend." Okay, but I'm not being paid to attend, and the teachers are being paid to a time. So I can't, I don't feel that I should be volunteering my time when everybody else is being paid for that time. So I'm a little bit of a stickler about it, because I think that leaders need to recognize that we need to be included in these things. And so I made this faculty picture because I don't have the red shirt. And it's something that is really important to me, I feel excluded at my school. And it's very easy to become cynical or frustrated in situations like that. But you have to ask yourself, rather than getting angry, and really being frustrated by the slow pace of change in things, we have to look at it in a positive light of how can we help? Jayson Davies Absolutely. And if I can just add to that really quickly. You know, in California, we're oftentimes we're considered classified management, certificated, management, whatever it might be. And that kind of puts us in a weird spot, because we don't really have people that work under us that we manage. We work alongside our certified occupational therapy assistants, but we definitely don't manage them. We are not the ones who evaluate our certified OT assistants. But at the same time, we're also not really being managed like a teacher would be. They're not managers, they're teachers. And so as occupational therapists in the schools as a classified or certificated management, we're kind of in this weird spot. So I definitely agree with you, Jaime. Jaime Spencer Yeah, I mean, everybody in this faculty picture, speech, social work, psychologist guidance, they're all in the same unit. So they have all of these similar opportunities that I don't have, and it is frustrating. Jayson Davies Alright, so this is our first objective, and we're going to go over that we're going to summarize how the structure of the California Department of Education system impacts parity for school-based OT. So let's go. The first big question is what is educational credentialing? Well, educational credentialing is exactly what it sounds like those teachers, anyone who I shouldn't say anyone, because obviously, we don't have one. But most people on campus have some sort of education credentialing. And we have another slide that's going to list all those out for you. So I won't get into too much detail yet. I don't want to skip ahead of myself. But you have to have a teaching certificate or teaching credential in order to be a teacher in school. Being categorized as certificated also opens more doors for you as far as moving up to potentially be an administrator or whatnot. And we'll talk about that in a second. So who is educationally credentialed? Here, there are three different types of credentials within the state of California. We have our services credential, our classroom teachers, or just a teacher's credential, and then we have our school administrators. To get that school administrator credential, you actually have to have one of the two other credentials. So under your services credential, you see school counselors, school, social work, school sites, child welfare and attendance, speech pathologists, teachers, librarian, school nurses, clinical rehab services. That Clinical Rehabilitation Services is a really interesting one to me. I don't know how we don't fall into that. It's really funny how things work out. It's kind of like in Hamilton, you know, I want to be in the room where it happens. It's just like, OTs weren't at the table that day that they're discussing who should be a credential provider, I guess. But then under the classroom teachers, this is more what people are familiar with, right? You have your single subject and multiple subject teachers. Single-subject refers to those teachers that work in middle school or high school where they specifically teach English or they specifically teach math or history or whatever that might be multiple subjects, teachers are your general education, elementary school teachers, right? They teach everything the entire day that with the same group of kids, and they teach it all. An education specialist is actually broken down into different levels. So your RSP, your resource specialist teacher, they have an Education Specialist credential for mild to moderate students. And then you have your mild to moderate STC teacher. But then when you get to your severe to mod classification, that's a different credential for that specific population. But it's still an Education Specialist credential. You have Career Technical and Adult Education, as well as adapted physical education teachers, they are also credentialed under that classroom teachers. That moves over to the school administrator's credential. And again, this is a separate credential that tries to word this the best way possible. My wife actually just got this, she's now an assistant principal, but she had to be a teacher first, for about five years before she could even apply to get her school administrator credential. And so she actually had to have that teaching credential. And a fun fact here, actually, because while she was applying for this, you know, I've been to School-Based OT for nine years at the time, I had been a school-based OT for about five years. And just for the fun of it, I was actually asking questions while she was applying. I was asking the college I was like, "Hey, can I can I go through the program with you?" And actually, asked them this? Because they're like, "do you have potential?" Like, "No, but I've worked in the schools for five years, I'm a licensed occupational therapist." And they're like, "No, you don't have a teaching credential." And I wasn't really planning on going through with it. But I just wanted to see what they would say. And if there's any roundabout way to do it, it wasn't the case. Jaime Spencer I actually had the same exact experience. Jayson, I wanted to when I was going back to get my master's, I wanted to get my Master's in School Administration. And when I started applying to all the programs, I couldn't believe when I was getting rejection letters, I was like, I was just shocked. And I wrote a letter to the New York State Education Department. And they wrote me back and said, "You're not considered pedagogical, which basically means you're not a teacher, your all of your time in the school doesn't count." And I even had people say to me, "Well, you're not in the classroom." And I want to say, "Okay, well, the gym teacher is not in the classroom. The social worker is not in the classroom, the psychologist is not in the classroom. But they're all eligible to advance, but not me because I'm an OT." And that, I think, is how this whole advocacy passion of mine started. So these are the people that are not educationally credentialed in California. And it's very, very similar to where I'm from in New York, updates to federal law, the Every Student Succeeds Act, states that OTs and physical therapists should be involved in the multi-tier system supports, RTI programs, and positive behavior support programs. But what the law has recommended hasn't really caught up to what's going on. So we could ask ourselves why. And it's because the decision-makers don't really know how valuable we are, we haven't had the chance to show them because we're very often not at the table. We are now in this category with bus drivers and paraprofessionals, cafeteria workers, and school clerks. And all of those people are crucial to the school running smoothly and keeping our children safe and getting them to and from their education. But these non-instructional staff members, don't work on the child's education, they don't work on the child's educational goals. They're not a part of educating the students and helping them access their curriculum. And I hate to say it, but being in the same category as people who don't need the education to do their job gives us a stigma of inferiority. So we're almost treated as less them which is why probably we're often not in the same unions and not included in the continuing education programs that are provided for what they call teachers. So in California, instructional staff like occupational therapy professionals, physical therapists, BCBAs, and vision therapists, even though we are instructional, we are not considered educationally credentialed. Jayson Davies So Jaime, before we move on, I actually want to ask you a question because in your about me slide you had your master's in special education, right? Jaime Spencer Yes. Jayson Davies So why did you do that? And did that help you at all? Jaime Spencer Well, when I graduated from occupational therapy school, I was like one of the very last classes that were permitted to get a bachelor's. So as soon as I was in the field, everyone else was coming out with a master's degree. And I thought that, in my journey at the school district, I was working that we would eventually be hiring more occupational therapists. So I wanted to have a Master's so that if an opportunity came up, I could be the supervisor and have a supervisory position. And I felt that if new therapists were coming on, and they had more education than me, it might not like automatically be my position. So I just thought, you know, I want to get I love to learn, I want to get my master's, I wanted to get it in school administration, but I was not allowed. So I chose special education because I thought that it would, at least, you know, supplement what I'm doing with the schools. And no, it didn't help me. It gave me a lot of student loans. And I received a teeny tiny stipend from my school district, if I was in the teachers union, my pay increase would have been very substantial. But because I am not in the teachers union, I'm in the CSEA. In New York, we are called the CSEA more civil service employees. And I'm in the same union with the bus drivers and the lunch ladies and administrative assistants. So I got my master's in special ed, but I'm still paying it off, to be honest with you, Jason, and it hasn't done anything for me, which is a shame, because I got my master's in special ed. But I didn't go a little bit further to do the student teaching and become a teacher, because it wouldn't really have helped me I would have had to leave the field of occupational therapy and be a classroom teacher for three years. And then I would be allowed to be an administrator. And I was I said, Absolutely not. I want to be an administrator as an OT, not as a classroom teacher. Jayson Davies Absolutely. Jaime Spencer And that's a position. That's what a lot of us are in that position, unfortunately, Jayson Davies Yeah, I've considered doing the same thing. But I've come to the same conclusion that you ultimately did was that you know, it would take me about eight years to eventually get to the point where I could go and get an administrative credential after starting the initial special education program, I just, and you have to work for free like you're saying, you have to be you when you do your student teaching, you're basically working for free. And yeah, I can't afford that. Jaime Spencer So it's just silly, it's backward. And Federal law says that we should be involved on a school level SS says, OTs and PTs should be involved, just like everybody else, but we're not. And it's because of this categorical exclusion of us from the educational category. Jayson Davies Alright, and that brings us to the next slide, which I think we've kind of gone over. But Jamie, if you want to add a little bit more, go for it. Jaime Spencer Right. So in order to become an administrator, you can either be a pupil personnel provider, which is listed here speech and language counselors, librarians, you could be considered a pupil personnel employee, or you could be considered a classroom teacher, either one of those categories is allowed to take the coursework to get their school building leader certificate, which would be a principal might be an assistant principal, or a chair, person, any kind of administrative position on the first level would be a school building leader. And you have to be a school building leader in order to then go on and get your school district leader certificate, which would be an assistant superintendent or a superintendent position high up. So you can see that all of the people on the left are eligible if they wish to move forward and to progress to a superintendent position. But occupational therapy practitioners and physical therapists are not even on the list. We have no way of really influencing the entire school district with all of the wonderful knowledge that we have, we really do have a unique knowledge base and background and a way of thinking outside the box to help people and we can't use that to influence the school districts. Jayson Davies Yeah, in California, just to clarify, for those watching, I know most of you are in California, there are not two separate certificates for the school building, and then school district leader. It's all just under that administrative credential. But either way, we can't. Can't get it here in California. So Jaime Spencer right and but also in general, you wouldn't go from being a classroom teacher to being the superintendent you need, you know, it's a stepping stone. Jayson Davies Yes. Jaime Spencer Yeah, that experience for sure. Jayson Davies Speaking of stepping stones, we've got a ladder picture for you. Jaime Spencer So this is one of my favorite cartoons. And it just really showcases the career path that's available for occupational therapy practitioners within the school setting. All of the educationally credentialed professionals that we just spoke about have the opportunity to advance themselves if they wish. But if we occupational therapy practitioners desire to move up the career ladder, we really don't have the opportunity, and it's just a shame. They have these opportunities which grant them the ability to create new programs that would benefit the staff, the children, the entire school community. And as they take the coursework to be an administrator or a leader, they move up in salary as well. And today, occupational and physical therapists do not have this opportunity. Because we don't have a teaching certificate, we are not allowed to take the coursework. This means that we are not permitted to become leaders. So the lead administrators in a school district have a lot of important decisions to meet. They meet to discuss the needs of the children, the staff, the whole community, they have to find how to fill weaknesses and fill voids that the district is experiencing. They have to decide about programs, curriculums budgets, the admins might be former teachers, social workers, or psychologists. And they're using their background knowledge and experience to do what's best for the school in their experience and their knowledge background. But right now, there's no occupational therapist at that table. So this is an enormous disservice to the school. And it really impacts therapists in many, many ways. There's no OT to offer solutions that showcase our training and our qualifications. We don't have the opportunity to contribute our opinions or ideas to earn the respect of other administrators and our colleagues. And this impacts the way we are viewed and valued by school administrators. And that means it impacts our parity. In a not-so-subtle way, we are often viewed and treated as inferior to other school professionals. OTs may be contracted instead of being hired directly, they report that they're not included in the professional development that the rest of the staff get, including the safety training, which is definitely a concern when it comes to the kids. We are separated from the rest of the professional staff and it creates a stigma of inferiority. OTs in California are retiring with fewer benefits than the rest of the staff. why? It's because there are no OTs at the leadership table. There's no OT to say, "Oh, don't forget to give the OTs and PTs a room to work in when you're adding on a hallway, maybe we can get them out of the hole or off the stage to do their job. Let's hire our own staff and include them in the collaboration meetings, so they know what's going on. Let's give the therapists time in their schedules to collaborate with the teachers. According to best practice, let's treat the therapist fairly." All of the complaints that OTPs have about inferior inferiority or inequality would be challenged by an OT seated at that table. Jayson Davies So back in wasn't too long ago, 2020. I know they updated every now and then. But this data is directly from the AOTA salary and workforce survey that they did. And they collect this data, you might have been part of this data collection. And they found that 23% of occupational therapy practitioners working in the USA work in school. So that's almost one in four OTs report, working in the schools, along with that 1/4 of occupational therapists also report working a second job. And, you know, that was kind of news to me, but I totally see it. I mean, a lot of OTs, work their school-based OT jobs, six, eight hours a day or whatever it might be. And then they hop over to a clinic, or they stop by a student's house or not a student but a child's house on the way home to provide some early intervention, or on the weekends, they're going into a clinic, or they're providing teletherapy services at another time. It's quite amazing. I know I've done that. I worked in the skilled nursing facility on the weekends. What about you? Jaime Spencer I've never had just one job. And it's actually really funny, Jayson and I presented at a conference last weekend about OT entrepreneurs, and I had all my badges ready. So I have a badge of working in a hospital and being a per diem, and I have a badge of working as a faculty member at a college, and I have a badge of being a contract therapist. And I'm missing two badges because I have the one from my first contract job as well as the one that I wear every day to my real job. But yes, you know, in order to feel stable financially, I needed to always have more than one job. And I think that that's sad because OTs work really hard for their degrees. And they work just as hard as the rest of the education, educational staff. So why don't we have the same opportunities for advancement? It's just not right. Jayson Davies And, you know, that is a perfect segway to maybe that is why 16% of occupational therapists are considering leaving the field of occupational therapy 30, or sorry, leaving the field, but 31% of that 16% I believe it was, are even just thinking about looking for a different field. They're not ready to retire. They're just considering moving out of occupational therapy. And you know, this is reflected in the data from AOTA but I know many of you that are watching this presentation, you're also in the Facebook groups, the school-based OT Facebook group, the resource Facebook group, all those. And I feel like it's once a week I see someone that just says, you know, I'm overwhelmed. I want to get out. What other career can I do with a master's in occupational therapy, they just want to get out. And they don't even want to consider potentially going to another occupational therapy site, you know, going to a hospital, or skilled nursing facility or something like that. They just don't feel like OT is right for them. And that's just really sad to see, you know, we're always trying to lift them up when we see something like that. Jaime Spencer Yeah, it really is a big cause of stress and burnout for people when you've consistently felt like you are not valued, or you're less than it's demeaning, you know, you feel disheartened. And again, for all your hard work and how you go to work every day, and you're you put in everything you've got for those kids, which is great. And you want to but you just want the respect. Jayson Davies Yeah. And I'm going to go over this. But I also want to ask Jaime, her numbers. The median salary in California is 88,000 and 60000, respectively, for certified occupational therapy assistants. So 88, for OTs. 60, for OTAs. Jaime, why don't you share with us in New York, you know about what that split is? Jaime Spencer I'm not 100% positive of it. But I think it was about 75,000, which I know in California and New York, the cost of living here is is very extensive. And the problem for us in New York, and I know it's not exactly the same in California, but we make significantly less than the classroom teachers like, I'll just talk for my own example. I'm very, very lucky that I have a job as an employee within a school district, I'm not contracted. So I do have benefits and retirement and in summers off, and I'm very grateful about that. But what I'm very upset about is that the classroom teacher next to me, who started way after I did make $30,000 more than me. And that's because she's in that other union, where she's able to take courses and bump up herself on the salary scale. And if she wants to be an administrator, she can. But meanwhile, I'm the one providing. I'm actually one of the presenters at the new teacher in-service, I teach about special education. So here I am educating them, and they get credit for it, which gives them more money, but I am not allowed. And it makes me very much feel like a hamster on a wheel. Jayson Davies Yeah, if you've ever seen a teacher salary schedule, it takes up an entire page. Because there are columns, there are rows, and for OT, it tends to be five short rows, or maybe seven. So yeah, definitely some, Jaime Spencer which really means that you're you've hit your top pay at the age of 30. And you've got another 30 or 35 years to go. You know, and we'll think about how much the cat the cost of a home goes up, or the cost of milk or the cost of gas. But our salaries do not go up. In fact, fun facts for you. When I graduated in 1999, the half-hour pay rate when I, my first job I was a contract therapist, was $29 a half-hour. Or you know, one half-hour 30-minute session is $29. Today, 22 years later, it's like $34 a half-hour that the therapist Yes. I mean, it has barely inched up at all. But when I think like my, the price of gas, when I first bought my first car was like nothing, it was like suit $7 to fill my tank. And now it's $30. So just those little things. I mean, that impacts us, why aren't we having a nice big retirement fund so we can buy an extra house? You know, Jayson Davies Exactly. And so we do want to talk about how that those numbers that AOTA revealed? How does that impact the schools? And you know, it impacts the education system, it impacts the future of OT practitioners, it impacts teachers, how we are able to support our teachers. And of course, it impacts our students, our colleagues, and our profession. One of the things that I was thinking about, as Jaime was speaking a moment ago, was because we only have those five tiers, you know, we move up and after five years or seven years, we're already at our max pay. I went through this. And you know what, as soon as I got to that top, what did I start doing, I started looking for other jobs where I can move up. And so what does that mean? That means that I moved to a new position, and that district only has an OT for three or four years, right? And you know what's going to happen, whoever takes my job is going to be there for the five years, get to the top, and they're going to do the same thing because they're going to want to make more money. And so over time, you're going to end up having a new person to fill that position every four to five years. Jaime Spencer When you compare that to a classroom teacher, most of the time I'm gonna say 90% of the time when a classroom teacher gets a job in a district. That's it. They are there until they retire and they those people become their best friends and they're their family that they go through all the hardships and blessings of life with. But for us, we're very often in and out. And it's, it causes a high turnover, which not only impacts our ability to make changes on the system level but also to have a fulfilling job. Everyone wants to have friends at work and the ability to be respected by their colleagues. But if you're not there that long, it's hard to develop that. Jayson Davies Yeah. And it also hurts the students as well, the teachers, because we all know it takes at least a year to kind of start building rapport with people. And then it takes another year to kind of go to the next level and start to build a rapport maybe with your, your administrator, your assistant principals across places, multiply that times, you know, you're at four different school sites, and you're trying to remember 80 Teachers names, and three or four administrators names that right, it takes time. And oftentimes, you know, we get to that point where we can actually make a change. And then we're like, hey, more money over there. Let me go over there. Jaime Spencer Yeah. Jayson Davies And so it impacts it trickles down and impacts the students all the way at the bottom because you're getting a new OT every four to five years, versus having someone consistently with them. Jaime Spencer And investing in someone, when they hire their teachers, they look at this person a little bit like a blank slate, and they train them they give them a mentor. In New York, I'm not sure if it's the same in California. But in New York, a new teacher is assigned an experienced teacher to mentor them. And the experienced teacher gets paid to do it. OTs, I mean often don't have another OT to even talk to much less someone to train them and supervise them. But the school looks at that teacher as a worthwhile investment, because they're going to be there for a long time. So they train them in the topics that are important so that they just are better and better and better highly qualified to teach the kids. Jayson Davies That's a very important point, actually, because teachers have to go through a program, I don't know if it's still called, I think they changed the name, but it used to be called Bitsa. And that's exactly what you were just referring to where they have to have a mentor. And I believe it's a year year and a half long, where they have to have a mentor. And they still have to do basically coursework. And they have to learn how to manage their classroom, while in the classroom, they have to do this program in order to clear their credential. And if they don't clear their credential, then they just went to school for two and a half years, or nothing. And so you have to go through that program where you clear your credential. Even administrators have to do that as well, once they get an administrative credential, they have to then clear that credential by working and going through a program while working. We don't have that as OTs, like Jaime was saying, you're lucky if you work in a district that has 5,6,7 OTs, and you have the opportunity to maybe go shadow them for your first day or two, before being thrown in all on your own at a school site, or for school sites. So absolutely. Jaime Spencer And with this high turnover, like you were saying it takes a long time to build a rapport and with all of the different buildings to see what kind of changes would really benefit the school district. But if you're not there for very long, if you haven't established respect and a rapport with the administrators, you can't make changes at the system's level, you can't make changes that would have an impact and benefit the entire school district because no one maybe knows who you are, or the big waves don't know who you are. And they haven't had the opportunity to value occupational therapy and our amazing input. They really don't know what it is that they're missing. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And so this brings us to why now is the time for a change. Because there is a teacher shortage, there is an administrator shortage, and occupational therapists could help fill that void. And it's 2021. And 2019 is that resource that you see there under the teacher shortage, California State Teachers Retirement System, or CALSTERS, report a 26% increase in the number of teacher retirements in the second half of 2020. Compared with that same period in 2019. Obviously, 2020 was a very interesting year with COVID. And we know that COVID forced out a lot of teachers and forced out my mother-in-law. For some a lot of teachers, they just said, "Hey, I don't want to deal with technology. I don't have data for OTs, but I would imagine that there were some OTs that probably did the same thing. Because zoom was hard to navigate. Google Maps was hard to navigate. It was definitely hard to navigate when districts couldn't make up their mind of what platform they wanted us to use." And so I'm sure people did leave both teachers and occupational therapists, the administrator shortage, expected teaching staff shortage will increase the lack of administrators in the future. So because there is a chief teacher shortage, there will be an administrator shortage. Jaime Spencer Right because the pool of candidates is getting smaller and smaller. So if they were to allow occupational therapy practitioners and physical therapists to be in that category, they're expanding that pool. Another thing about why now is the time for change is the culture, there's a very big focus on equality and parity and treating, giving everybody equal opportunities not to be opportunistic. But we can kind of capitalize on that and show it's really almost discrimination discriminatory practices that we are now excluded. And maybe years and years ago before the laws evolved to treat us as equal. Maybe it was appropriate that we were kind of considered medical and we were in a different category. But now under the, Every Student Succeeds Act, we are educators and should be treated as such, therefore, we deserve parity. So parity basically means fairness, justice, being equitable, not being discriminated against not being treated as less than, and the words that you can use to go opposite, it would be bias prejudice, if you don't have parity, someone else has partiality. You are not having equity, and it's not okay. This cartoon is one of my favorites. So you see, the Occupational Therapy practitioner and the physical therapist are trying to get on the elevator and everybody else on that elevator is going up to the sixth floor, up up up to become an administrator, but OT and PT are not welcome. This is definitely not equity, this is not parity. All of the other school professionals are able to become leaders if they wish, if they desire, not that they have to, but they may. This furthers their career, their pay, and their ability to have an impact, they are able to showcase their skills in a way that impacts the whole school district. But OTs and PTs are excluded. So when we talk about discrimination, there is a history of discrimination in education. Back in the day, racial segregation of children in public schools was commonly accepted. Children with disabilities were not receiving the free and appropriate education. And children with disabilities were segregated. They were they, you know, there was no least restrictive environment, they were put totally in other schools, they didn't get to the mainstream with typically developing children at all. And there were limited funds, resources, and opportunities for females to play sports. So these are all instances of discrimination that were very, very common in the past, of course. So some of the discriminatory educational practices that need to be abolished now are that the California Department of Education does not consider school occupational physical therapists to be teachers or to be considered pedagogical, we are prohibited from taking the coursework to become a leader. So back in the day, it would be crazy to consider that. So nowadays, I'm sorry, nowadays, it would be crazy to consider that children with disabilities or children who are considered minorities would be separate. That would be, you know, out of the unbelievable. Okay. Campbell, it's unbelievable that that used to be commonly accepted. And that's how it was, we are hoping that it's going to be considered unbelievable, that OTs and PTs were once not allowed to be leaders. Jayson Davies And as I mentioned earlier, you know, we just want to see that the table, we want to be in the room where it happens. And AOTA’s 2025 vision states that we envision that occupational therapy is a powerful, widely recognized science-driven, and evidence-based profession with a globally connected and diverse workforce. Meeting society's occupational needs, this is from surely Chris Holm. And as part of that whole vision, that 2025 vision from AOTA and just shows how much that we have the ability to be impactful. All we need to do is step up to the plate or be allowed to step up to the plate. And so we need to advocate for ourselves. And that's what we're going to talk about here as we move forward. But we need to advocate for ourselves so that we can earn that spot at the table. Well, I mean, I wouldn't say we've already earned it. But now we have to actually get it Jaime Spencer To actually and we have to, we have to push for it, ask for it and take it instead of you know, just holding back. There was an amazing TED Talk by the CEO of Facebook. I can't remember her name, but I like, love her. And she did a whole podcast about taking a seat at the table and advancing yourself in your career. And it was just so inspiring. And it really made that saying, stick in my head, take a seat at the table. We have to we do deserve it and it's important. Jayson Davies Absolutely. So some of you may already know about this letter, some of you. I see most of you probably have never seen this in your life or know about it. But AOTA drafted up this letter back in 2017 talking about why OTs should be able to have a seat at the table why OTs should be able to take the coursework to become an administrator and it outlines some great areas such as you know we have the knowledge and skills and mental health positions to address personal issues, to support parents and to promote social-emotional learning that we have the knowledge and the training to, in transitioning, so helping people transition and improve graduation rates, to improve attendance to reduce dropout rates. So this letter was actually sent out to every single Department of Education in every single state. And AOTA did not hear back from any of the states related or regarding this letter. And so who knows where it ended up probably in a shredder somewhere, but this is something that we can have an impact on, as well. Jaime Spencer It just goes to show the lack of respect, I mean, to not answer a state association is a big deal. Jayson Davies Yeah. And I agree. And the other thing about this too, is, correct me if I'm wrong, Jaime, does New York, have OT/PT practice guidelines for therapists in the schools right now? Jaime Spencer We are currently developing one. Jayson Davies Okay, well, here in California, we have one, but it's from 2012, I believe. So it's very old. But it's actually for 2012. I think it was pretty progressive to the point that it still holds up pretty well today, okay. And I had an experience where I brought that practice guideline to my supervisor, and I highlighted something and I showed it to him, I can't remember exactly what it was today. But they're saying, well, is that from CDE? California Department of Education as a part of the ed code, education code in California. No, but it's practice guidelines that were published by the California Department of Education. Right. And it holds no weight, though, because they're guidelines, they're not laws. And basically, it's not IDEA, it's not California law, it's just guidelines. And so while it talks about moving to that workload model, while it talks about participating in RTI and Multi-Tiered Systems of Supports, it's not something that is required. Alright. So the next phase of our presentation here is to list three unique opportunities for school-based OT practitioners to showcase leadership. So what makes a leader? I think we've talked a lot about this already. So I'll just list a few here. You know, we make decisions. We already do that we're role models, we keep data, we set goals, we're effective, we attract personnel, we take action, we're organized, we're responsible, and we are especially dedicated, at least if you asked me. So, Jaime Spencer I agree. Jayson Davies How can you become a leader, there are two different types of leadership, you have informal leadership, and then you have formal leadership. I think many of us already take action in this informal leadership, we volunteer, especially hours every day that we still have to work, right? Personal personality, we get out there and we help other people. Maybe you're a social influencer, maybe you actually know a lot, and people come to you. And so you actually are able to direct some of those teachers, even though you're not officially their supervisor, they may come to you for advice. I know I've had that experience in the past. And you are probably pretty clear on your vision, whether or not you are, I don't want to throw out any specific examples. But you likely believe in something like an occupational therapist, whether it's neurodiversity, sensory integration, something, whatever area that you really believe in, you have a clearer vision on that. And you have done the research, you know, that it can help your students and you have a clearer vision of how you can get there. So you are an informal leader, leader. Now, formal leadership is what we've been kind of talking about, for the last 20 minutes or so having that that official job title of being an assistant principal being a principal being something higher than that, and that is where we can not get at this point. Jaime Spencer Right. If you're not a formal leader, you don't have the opportunity to put big changes into place, you can't set up new programs or put new systems in place that would benefit everybody that has an OT, twist, or an OT feel, you, you can make suggestions, but your boss might take them, but they would get the credit for putting them into place, you know. So that brings us to another problem. OTs are, I mean, I don't know any OT that's not totally busy and kind of like running all around everywhere, usually, in multiple buildings, you know, we need to show our value. And in order to do that, we've got to be able to volunteer for school-wide initiatives beyond committees influence other people who aren't in our OT bubble, about our value, but we really don't have time. We are we're not often provided the time to be on these committees. We don't get paid for that extra stuff like teachers might. But because of that, we can't really show our influence. We often have second jobs as Jayson said before. And because we can't show our influence we kind of maybe zoom into a building and see our kids and zoom to the next building. And because of that, we might not be valued within the school system. So it's kind of like a hamster on a wheel. Like I said before, which problem came first the chicken or the egg. In order for us to show our value, we've got a put out a little more. And I was in I think it actually was with you, Jayson, where we did a presentation during COVID. And the other guest presenter said, you know, now is the time for OTs to step up, they need to give more. And I felt like, I don't know any OTs who have any more to give, I mean, we're already stretched so thin. I know, so many OTs who don't eat lunch, they, you know, they wait until 3:35, when that bell rings so they can run to the bathroom. And you know, there's no time for the extra stuff of coming up with a new program or sharing a great idea with your principal and helping put it into place from start to finish. We just don't have that extra time. But when you do have the extra time, here's the thing I say, you know, if you can, that's awesome. But I don't think it should be expected because we are already stretched so thin. But I've found that if I create one resource and share it multiple times in multiple ways, I'm able to reach more and more people to try to have an impact. So I've provided continuing education at you know, the staff meetings, I volunteered for the flexible seating committee, and it wasn't a giant commitment. But I did do it because I felt like goodness, if OT is not on the flexible seating committee. I mean, I don't know who should be, you know, you can join committees, you can put together a presentation that would be appropriate to be addressed at the PTA, or addressed at a faculty meeting, just to give everybody the influence. We are not handwriting teachers, we treat the entire child. And it's important to influence. Everybody else is thinking about occupational therapy in general, we need to be our own advocates. And we can influence the general I mean, the administrators as well as the staff to let them know that, you know, it's not just about handwriting, Jaime is the one who knows about strength. And Jaime is the one who knows about vision, and sensory strategies, and all these other things that my kids need help with. And I'm not equipped with but OT is, so as much as you can do, that's great. I mean, every little bit helps, I just find that we're often kind of expected to give this extra stuff for free. While teachers may be, it might be a part of their job. One thing that I have found really helpful is I've printed out handouts from like my own blog, or the Inspire Treehouse or you Jayson that I thought teachers would really benefit from and I make a bulletin board and I just put little folders on the bulletin board with the handouts in there. And it would be like "Do your students struggle with hamstring with a handout of activities", and the teacher consented home? And it says from occupational therapy on it is important that we kind of take ownership of those things that we do because it's, you know, hard to find the time to do that. So as we said, we need to make our own seat at the table, we've got to ask for the things we need. I've had OTs complain to me like I don't even have any pencil grips. I don't even have paper, I have to buy everything for myself. And I said, you know, I was in that position when I first got hired. But years later, I kind of learned you know, my principal doesn't even know that I don't have those things. So if I make a meeting, and I introduce myself, and I advocate not only just for me, "Hi, I'm Jaime Spencer, I'm your occupational therapist. I'm working with these students. I was wondering if you possibly had any extra budget for me to invest in pencil grips because it's already October. And I've given all of mine out." I've never had a principal say no to something like that. And I know sometimes people may work for a third party. And that third party might say, you know, don't ask for anything, you're an independent employee, you have to provide everything yourself. But it's not really always the case. And very often there is a little bit of extra money like even the PTA can provide money for things like extra handouts or seat cushions or you know, whatever it is that you need. It is important to make it known that you need it and why you need it. Because there are people who can help you and you only need one, you only need one person who's like, "Yeah, that's really important. I'll get you your seat cushions no problem." Another easy way to promote OT without having to do any work is to distribute the AOTA factsheets, they have a lot of great handouts that are really helpful, that talk about backpack safety, or what the role of OT is within a school setting. I've handed that one out at a few special ed meetings because I've had parents that said OTs just handwriting and I'm like with my factsheet well actually, according to the American Occupational Therapy Association, we treat the entire child so all you have to do is kind of print out or assemble those resources that you can use again and again. And your work is done. But you still have the opportunity to reach so many people, you can promote occupational therapy month. And you don't have to do a lot of work to do that you can find things that other people have promoted. And even on social media, you can just repost something, or share a cute cartoon or a cute handout, I very often leave things on my faculty room tables. One year, I did a whole display of different kinds of adapted scissors, and I labeled them and I put little examples of why certain students would need certain things. And when I was eating my lunch in that faculty room, not one teacher came in and didn't have to stop and take a peek. And they're like, these are cool scissors. I've never seen these, what is this about? And there's my chance while I'm eating my sandwich to be like, "Oh, well, for kids with weak hamstrings, sometimes they need special scissors that have a spring, and then it helps with their motor memory of the position that they need to do with their hands. But it takes away some of that hard work." You can also offer it to present to your PTA if you don't mind public speaking, I know a lot of people don't like it, some people love it. Another great thing is to show new research articles to your school administrators. So my administrator and it's important to know your administrators and what their I don't want to say their pain points, but what their bet what they value. And if you know that your administrator values, the newest evidence-based practice, or the newest research in certain areas, it's a great way to get your end to bring an article about that says, Look, you know, there was a recent article that showed that weighted vests are helpful for children with ADHD, but it's not a cure-all. So let's have a little conversation with all the teachers who are asking for weighted vests and make sure that they understand how a weighted vest is used and what it's really for, and that it's not, you know, the end all and be all of the things. And my administrator was like, "Woohoo, we don't have to buy another 30 weighted vests this year." You know, just to bring that forward and to show research says, I mean, my administrator love that phrase, research says that this is what's going on. And she's like, "Okay, give it to me, give me the article. All right." And that's an easy thing to do. I just have to photocopy something and have it with me, to bring it to the meeting. Jayson Davies Yeah, I could not agree more with that. I mean, it only takes one person to make a change or to get started, at least in making that change. So if you have your administrator on your side, you've got a good team member. Jaime Spencer Definitely. So there are a ton of occupational therapy practitioners who work in the California School System, and most of them want parity and to be valued and to be equal to everybody else. But we can't just wait for someone to do it. So many people have said to me, why hasn't this changed? Why aren't we just included? And it's because we all need to step up, we all need to take part. If you just sit back and lay low, you're gonna stay low, you've got to speak up and stand up and help with the I don't want to say the fight, but the journey and the evolvement of occupational therapy, we really all have a responsibility, not just for ourselves, but for the future generations of practitioners, as well as for the kids, the kids are missing out on all the OT superpowers that we have to offer, if think about the difference of what your school district would look like if your superintendent was an occupational therapist. I mean, I think the trickle-down effect would just be unbelievable. So we have to look at the difference. Are you apathetic? Or are you an advocate, apathy is a lack of concern. If you're not doing anything or saying anything if you're not talking about it, you're not motivated, then you have apathy. Or you could be an advocate, which would mean you know, your rights, you speak up for what you deserve. You speak up for yourself, you know your value, you ask for what you need, and you ask for what you want. If you're not doing anything, and you're not saying anything, then your behavior, Minix and apathetic person. There are many, many ways to showcase your opinion, beliefs, and your values as an OTP. But it all starts with one decision. Will you take action? And at the conference last weekend, Jayson, one of the therapists said to me, you know, I know that you're a very outspoken advocate for occupational therapy, and I just wondered if you ever had any backlash? Did you ever get in trouble for being outspoken? And I'll be very honest, I haven't. I've never, you know when you look at other track other things where people stuck up for themselves, I mean, it's only what's right. What I'm stating is a fact I'm not giving equal things to everyone else, and I do what they do. And you know, I'm actually giving black and white facts when I present to my administrators or if I go to someone asking for more I'm always professional, I'm always confident and I make sure I know my stuff, I'm not going to go in there and say, oh, I need, you know, because I know exactly what I need. And I'll give specific reasons why. And, in general, I mean, I really, I've not ever had anything and I can understand being afraid of, you know, they might not give me my job back, or oh, what's going to happen to me, but then I think of like the bigger picture, think of all the people who stuck their neck out for change, think of the “me too movement”, all those women who spoke up and made so many changes in Hollywood, like, and that's such a different thing. But when you look at the big picture, you're going to be okay, there are OT jobs all over the place. Worst case scenario, if you were to lose your job, you've no one can ever take your education away from you. And the chances of it happening are, you know, minute, and I know it's always in the back of everybody's mind, like, what happens if I stand up for myself? You know, what if, but what if people listen? What if your reason why your school district makes a change? You have to look at both ways. Jayson Davies Yeah, I absolutely agree. In fact, typically advocating for myself, leads to that admin coming to me more, versus the other way around, even though at the moment, they might be like, "Why is Jayson talking about this," it definitely actually lead them to know that I know more, and that I have more to offer, and that the next time they have a question about something, instead of trying to fake it till they make it, they come to me, and they asked me, "Hey, Jayson, what do you know about research? Or what do you know about this?" And so don't be afraid to speak up. Jaime Spencer It's important, and it's part of knowing your worth and knowing your value. They don't know what they're missing, you know, if you do keep quiet, and you don't offer all these wonderful things that you have, everybody's missing out on it. Everybody's missing out on your magic. Jayson Davies Yeah. And you know, we haven't explicitly said this, I think I think it's kind of been described a little bit. But a lot of times we work for people that have no idea what we do. Our Special Education Coordinator, our special education director, whoever oversees you, oftentimes has no idea what you do, they know that you do great work, they see you potentially, maybe in some IEPs, they come they observe you once every three years, or whatever, whenever they get around to it to evaluate you. But even when they evaluate you, they don't know what they're evaluating. Because part of that is we haven't told them, and we have to let them know. Jaime Spencer Yes, I, to be honest with you, in my 22 years, I've never been evaluated. I shouldn't say I've never been evaluated, I've never been observed. I get like you know, a checklist, like Yes, she does her work. But no one I would love for someone to come observe me. And a lot of people don't feel that way. And I get it. But I do make sure. And even the little ways of letting the people in your school know what it is that you do I make an effort. So if I'm, you know, working with a child in the hallway, and we're using the scooter to get back to class, and you know, inevitably somebody is like, Oh, that looks like so much fun. I max my turn, you know, like just being cute. I am always like, Yeah, and look how strong he's getting his arms are our look at those muscles. You know, like, I'm making sure that that grownup knows that we're not, we're not just playing here like we are working on important things. And it's a very easy way to do it. You can do that and go home and be like, I advocated for OT today. You know, you want people to know, we are not just handwriting teachers. Jayson Davies Absolutely. So we have about 15 minutes left, which is going to bring us right to our final section today. And Miss Jaime, she just asked you a question. I called you Miss Jaime. Miss Jaime OT, I can't get it out of my head. She asked you a question a moment ago, she asked are going to take action. And in this section, we want to show you how you can take action, we want to apply these concepts of advocacy or school-based OT leadership at the local and state level. And we want you to take action on this, we're going to show you how. The first thing that we need to do is communicate the need for change. This has a ripple effect. And we've already discussed a little bit you know, it only takes one person and it doesn't necessarily even need to start with your administrator level. I know that's what we talked about a few minutes ago. But it can really start by sharing that one thing with one teacher with who you already have a rapport. And then that teacher might share it with their co-teacher maybe you helped one second grade teacher and the next thing you know all three second grade teachers are coming to you asking for your support. It really only starts with one that's happened to me on multiple occasions. I go to a new school. I provide it can be as simple as a pencil grip to a kindergartener teacher. And a week later, I'm getting an email saying hey, can you come and share with us some techniques during our PLC our learning community time on Wednesday afternoon, we really have some students that are having difficulty with this and this and this and we would love your take on different things. You know Jaime alluded to some of the big changes that have happened recently, you know, the “me too movement”, the Black Lives Matters, movements, all of these we wouldn't know about today unless something started somewhere, you know, it only took one person to really start that movement, and then look how it has grown today. So how can you start that ripple, get involved, communicate with their state and local associations and leaders, it is awesome that you are here right now, you are at an Occupational Therapy Association for California conference? And you chose this specific presentation to go to, which means I already know you're a natural-born leader. So you're in the right spot. Now we need to communicate, we need to go beyond this, we need to communicate with OTAC, which OTAC to be fair, has done so much the last few years, and it hasn't been easy for them. So they need our help. Join the go-to OT OTAC initiative. This is something that was actually started by my friend, Sabrina McNally. And she has just gotten done so much for our profession. And she is now actually the state RA for AOTA which means she is a person that we can talk to. And she's going to take that information over to AOTA and let them know, hey, California needs help with this. So reach out to your RAs, the go-to OT initiative, I want to share that with you really quickly is basically there is a lot of occupational therapist in California. One in four, as we mentioned earlier, is our school-based OT so I don't know the numbers, my license number is 13,000. So I'm assuming there's probably about 15, active, maybe 15,000, active school-based or not school-based but OTs, there are not that many California legislators. So every single one of us should be able to find a legislator, state assembly member that we can have contact with, whether it's an email a phone call, meeting up with them, and tweeting at them Instagramming at them, let them know who you are and what you do. It can be that simple. It's just letting them know who you are. You don't have to have lunch with them. If you want to, by all means, go for it. But it doesn't have to go that far. You can just reach out even voting and understanding who you're voting for is a is advocacy, email your state OT legislative chair and RA. I mentioned RA Sabrina, we have another RA. I don't think I have his name on me right now. But we actually have two RAs in the state of California. And their information can be found on AOTA and I think Miss Jaime might actually have the RA information in a Facebook group called the California School-Based OTs for change, right. Jaime Spencer California school-based OTs looking for Facebook advocacy group, and Jayson and I are the administrators of the group. And we have been for years, it's been a little slow in there. But we created the group just to have a collective place for California-based occupational therapy practitioners to discuss advocacy, what we can do what's going on. And we have some resources in there for you as well, that we'll be talking about. Jayson Davies Yes, and obviously, you're here. So you're already supporting OTAC. Be sure to also support AOTA and I will see you in the Facebook group. Now, here's the reason why it's so important to be willing and open to talk. Because the California Department of Education is a messy spiderweb of people, and you never know who you might actually be talking to. You might be at a cocktail party for your friend's wedding. And you might be standing next to I don't know, the Tony Thurman, do you know the state superintendent of public education? Who knows you never know who you're going to be talking to? And so speak up, let people know who you are and what you do. Jaime Spencer And then Tony says, "Oh, my goodness, my son had OTA. That's amazing. I didn't know that you guys weren't treated equally to OTs and PTs." Jayson Davies Yeah. Yeah. Don't just say you're a teacher. Don't just say you work with students with special education. Let them know what you actually do what your title is, and, and share that with the world. You know, get it out there. Jaime Spencer Or I sometimes will have friends introduce me to someone else and be like, "Oh, she's a teacher?" And I'm like, "no, no, I'm an occupational therapist. And I work with chill, you know, blah, blah, blah," my little elevator speech is short but sweet, but I make sure they know exactly what I do. And I do often say, you know, I'll go into the whole like a hospital setting. The physical therapist works on this and you know, and we'll do the whole thing like a physical therapist might help you to walk down the street, but if you're not wearing your pants, you're in big trouble. OTs are really important in the school district. Jayson Davies Yeah, I really like to describe what I do. I like to ask people a question. You know, let me describe what you do. What is one of your favorite activities that you do? And then they tell me whatever it might be, and then I say, you know, God forbid what happened if you make maybe had a stroke or something and you couldn't do those things that you loved. And this is how an occupational therapist could help you. And you know, it kind of hits home with them, they remember it. And maybe the next time they're out doing whatever their favorite activity is golfing, they think about that OT, who said, "Oh, man, he said he could really help me with my shoulder, whatever might be, you know." And so what the know and who knows, maybe that guy's golfing with Tony Thurman, I don't know. But it can all start with one little ripple and it can grow from there. So Jaime put this little chip on here with I love and she actually had to ask me, I don't know. Maybe she thought I was too young when I saw this. Like, do you know what this is from? I was like, Santa Claus. I couldn't think of the movie. But we got Jaime Spencer cuz I'm a total movie buff. Like, I remember lines from movies. I remember. I'll see movie ones. And I'm like, Oh, yeah. So I refer to movies a lot. But like, my best friend doesn't know anything. And I'll be like, Are you kidding me? You and I have watched that movie together at times. You don't know it? And she's like, what? So I try not to assume that people know a movie. Jayson Davies Yeah. So this is from the miracle on 34th Street. Actually, I think this is the original one. Which I know people always like, No, I don't want to watch the one in color. I don't want to watch the one from whatever you want the original. Yes, yes. So never underestimate the power of a letter or the power of 20,000 letters. OTAC regularly sends out emails and they say hey, can you please send this letter, oftentimes, they give you a template, or they even actually, sometimes it's just a Google form, and you fill out the Google Form, and it magically sends a letter to whoever it might be. That's important in that in that system. But this is who you can send that letter to the California Department of Education, you can send it to even your union if you're part of the Union. You know, unfortunately, with unions, we tend to be if you're part of a union, you are one person in a union of like hundreds. And so sometimes the OTs don't get heard. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't stop trying. In fact, if you can send a monthly email to your union member and just say, "Hey, this is what I do. This is how I help the kid this week," you know, let them know, let Otac know and ask for more. Yes, yes, ask for more. Let OTAC know, they are really trying to change the law in California, it's a messy process that we have to go through in order to get that credential, it really isn't going to be straight up with you. It is a messy process. With a lot of players involved. The unions are involved, the California Department of Education is involved. The State Board of licensing is involved, how much education we have that plays into it, there's so much that goes into that. But we have to let them know that we're interested. And so sending those letters to OTAC, sending them to your AOTA RAs, as we already mentioned earlier, and then the go-to OT advocacy talking to your state assembly members. Even if we get a legislation bill in place. If our state assembly members have no idea what it is, then they're likely not going to vote for it. So we need to let them know, "Hey, we have something coming up." And I really hope that if nothing else, you remember the name of occupational therapy, because we have a bill coming up, it's going to be about occupational therapy, and how we can support our students in schools. Even if it's that something that simple, you can do it. Jaime and I were setting up something to help you out here, we're going to put a template up in this California school-based OTs looking for change Facebook group is going to be kind of a plug and play letter for you that you can send out, you might want to edit it or update it a little bit to be a little more specific to you. But this is going to be a letter that you can send out to your union member, your union rep, or your even your boss. I mean, just send it out to people and let them know who you are what you do. And by the way, it is important for you to have the ability to be an administrator. Jaime, do you want to add to that? Jaime Spencer Yes. So I think in this day and age, people email a lot. And I don't know about you, Jayson, I know you're in the same boat where you work as a school-based OT and you have a business on the side. So my emails are jam-packed millions of emails and I'm like, "oh, goodness, I just can't even start addressing all of them." But when I receive something in the mail, when I receive a letter from someone that's different, I don't get a lot of handwritten mail or typed mail that's sent specifically to me. So I always make sure to read it. And that is something that I really think is important here. So we did create a template, we're going to post it in the California group, it's going to be under Files. So when you join the group, unless you already are in there. Just go to files and it's going to be there for you and you can plug in the important people that you want to address but we do have the meat and potatoes of it there for you. So you don't have to come up with like well what do I ask for? How do I ask It's there for you. Just put in your name where you're from, and anything extra that you want to add is great. And put a stamp on it and address it and mail it out because that is something that's going to be opened and read more thoroughly than just another email in the box. So if you, I just said I was a total movie buff, if you guys remember Shawshank Redemption, one of the best movies ever. And he prayed he wanted more money for the jail library. And he asked his boss, can I please write a letter to get more money and the boss was like you I mean, I don't care. Go ahead. But you know, no one's gonna do anything about it. So he wrote a letter a week. And he ended up getting it because the person who was in charge of it said off with these letters and gave him a nice big check. And he ended up outfitting an entire library for his jail, it just goes to show, if we keep doing it, keep advocating keep sending the letters, you can go to this file and print out 10 copies, and sign them all up and mail them once a week, for the next 10 weeks. And that makes a big difference. If the person didn't know anything about it or knew a little bit about it, they're going to be a lot more aware after they receive 10 letters about it. And if you and the person sitting next to you, does it, then that's 20 letters that they end up receiving, we want to be like a little bee buzzing in their ears that's constantly. I don't want to say annoying, but reminding them of this very, very important need that must be addressed. Jayson Davies So Jamie, how long does it take to move a mountain? Jaime Spencer It takes a long time and it takes a lot of people but it can get done. I can't even begin to tell you the amount of time and work and effort that so many wonderful occupational therapists before us have done Jayson, people like Jan Hollenback and Patti Labrador, and Serena Zeiler. They have written articles, Joan's going Kirsch, there's so much that people have already done that we can build upon, we can take their work and show it to other people or email articles, we need to spread out this information. And we need to make it widely known. Again, with things like me too movement, one person started but little by little it's snowballed. More and more people were talking about it more and more people were saying, "Yeah, I'm not treated fairly. either. I'm this, I'm that." And I'm not remotely trying to compare this to the Mewtwo movement, but just that kind of sticking up for yourself, having those guts to just say, You know what, I'm not going to put my head down anymore, I'm not going to just ignore it and keep working every day. Because in five years, either they'll be changed, or there won't. But if you help, you're much better off. You know, if everyone does something, the time is gonna pass no matter what. But if we do something every day or every week to help it, they'll be a different mountain in five years to address. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And that brings us to our final slide where we get to say thank you so much. And we have our emails here for you. Feel free to email Jaime, feel free to email me our emails are there for you CC as both or whatever you want to do. But let us know we want to help you. We want to answer your question. Please do reach out. And don't forget to sign up for, see a school-based OTs looking for a change Facebook group, you might even find a replay of this video there at some point. So, Jaime Spencer if you're looking for more resources and more information, Jayson has a lot of great podcasts about advocacy. Jayson, I loved the one you did about how important it is to join your membership. Jayson Davies Thanks. Yes with Sarah. Jaime Spencer Yes. I mean, that was really great. And I have some posts on my website as well missjaimeot.com, about advocacy, about sticking up for yourself about how I wish I had the red shirt. Just to start if you're if this is new to you, and this topic is something that you want to learn more about. This is a great way to educate yourself. Jayson and I both have a lot of resources on our websites for you to kind of start that educational journey. Jayson Davies And sorry, one more thing, if you are not in California, but you happen to be here know that Jaime has like a Facebook group for just about I don't know if you have every state but she also has the USA right? Jaime Spencer Yes. So I have the USA school-based OTs looking for Change Group, which is all like anybody if you join California, Please also join the USA. But we've had multiple people, people like you, Jayson who said who stand up and say, I want to do something specific for my state that has branched off and made subgroups. So we have New York, New Jersey, Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, Connecticut, California, Florida, Pennsylvania, I think, Ohio, Illinois, they have all they all have their own groups. Now there's not always a ton going on in these groups, but they were collecting our people. And we're gathering our crowds so that we can move on things together when it's time. Jayson Davies Perfect. All right. So thank you so much for being here. And we'll see in a moment. Jaime Spencer Thank you, everybody. Jayson Davies Alright, and that is going to wrap up the OT Schoolhouse podcast for 2021. Thank you so much for being here. And a big shout out to Jaime Spencer of missjaimeot.com. For really putting the bulk of this presentation together, she has done this in many states now, or at least a few. And she really helped me to just kind of add in the California-specific content. But as I mentioned in the intro, this is very specific to any state. Yes, some lingo may change, there might be a different education board that you have to reach out to. But we should all be working to get credentialed as occupational therapists within the schools. So one more time, thank you so much to Jaime Spencer, for helping me put this together. And thank you for listening to this episode and every other episode of the OT Schoolhouse podcast. I look forward to coming back in 2022 strong. And actually, I want to share your stories in 2022. So if you're still listening to the very end of this podcast, thank you, but also reach out to me and let me know what worked for you in 2021. I want to share those stories in 2022 about how you thrived through a difficult time. So reach out to me email me at jayson@otschoolhouse.com and let me know what went well and 2021. Who knows maybe you'll be on the OT Schoolhouse podcast sharing your big accomplishments. Alright, everyone, take care to have a great winter break and I will see you and 2022. Bye now. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT Schoolhouse podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now. Head on over to otschoolhouse.com. Until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 87: Fostering Safe & Regulating Environments in the Classroom with Dr. Jamie Chaves, OTD, OTR/L
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Welcome to the show notes for Episode 87 of the OT Schoolhouse Podcast. School-based occupational therapists wear many hats. Sometimes we treat students individually and other times we have to train the teachers in ways they can support students in the classroom. Today, we are focusing on supporting teachers in fostering safe and regulating environments in the classroom for students with sensory differences. Joining me today to discuss this topic is Dr. Jamie Chaves, OTD, OTR/L, SWC. Dr. Chaves is a pediatric occupational therapist and is also the OT Division Leader at the Center For Connection. Along with co-author, Ashley Taylor, Psy.D., Dr. Chaves has written two books to support therapists and educators working with students who have sensory differences. You can find both books on Amazon. They are titled “The Why Behind Behaviors” and “Creating Sensory Smart Classrooms” *Affiliate links included help the OT School House to earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Links to Show References: Book on Amazon: The Why Behind Behaviors Book on Amazon: Creating Sensory Smart Classrooms Jamie’s Personal Website Instagram: TheWhyBehindBehaviors Transcript Download the Transcript or read the episode below! Jayson Davies Hey, everyone, welcome to the OT Schoolhouse podcast. Thank you for being here really appreciate you being here to listen to this episode of the OT Schoolhouse podcast. And for just being a part of the OT Schoolhouse community. I can't believe that we are almost to the end of 2021. 2020 and 2021 have just gone by so quickly and well, things are changing so much right now within the world. We've got so much going on. And I am just so happy that you have decided to spend a part of your day with me and Dr. Jamie Chaves, who we are having on the podcast today. Dr. Jamie Chaves is a doctor of occupational therapy. She is also a licensed occupational therapist and she actually has a few different roles. So I want to share those with you. She works at the Center for Connection in Pasadena, California. And she is also the author of two books with her colleague, Ashley Taylor, who we will talk about a little bit later as well. The two books that she has written or co-written with Ashley are Creating Sensory Smart Classrooms and The WHY Behind Behaviors. We're actually going to dive into both of those books a little bit today, or at least the contents of those. This is definitely not a sales pitch for the books. But there is a lot of great information from those books that come out in this podcast episode. This interview with Jamie is such a great interviewer, you're going to learn so much about sensory processing, sensory integration, and really fostering safe environments within the classroom. And I cannot wait for you to hear it. So go ahead, put those phones in your pocket. Turn the speakers, put those headphones in to start your jog or your workout, whatever you're doing, driving, and enjoy this episode with myself and Dr. Jamie Chaves. Hey, Jamie, welcome to the OT Schoolhouse podcast. How are you doing this morning? Dr. Jamie Chaves I'm doing really well. Thank you. Thanks for having me. Jayson Davies Yeah, definitely. I'm excited you have a book out, actually, you have two books out. We're talking about one today creating sensory smart classrooms. And that was written by yourself as well as Ashley Taylor. And I do want to allow you to give a moment to give a shout-out to Ashley and talk a little bit about her as well. But first, I want to ask you about your career as an occupational therapist and just share a little bit of background about yourself. Dr. Jamie Chaves Sure, I've been an occupational therapist for nine years now. And I kind of stumbled upon the profession when I was in undergrad and just fell more and more in love with it as I went through grad school, which is always a good thing. I wasn't backpedaling. And I've always been really passionate about children. And one of the areas of research I spent a lot of time on in grad school was children and orphanage-like settings. And as I was doing that research, so much was coming up about sensory and motor development and how those things are impacted in orphanages and foster homes and when a child is adopted, and so that got me down the rabbit hole of sensory processing and sensory integration. And my first job was in a clinic with kids of varying developmental needs. And there were a lot of sensory-motor needs. And so I just continued to learn more and more about it. And that's my area of specialty now is sensory integration. Jayson Davies Awesome. And so you actually do have your doctorate in OT, what was that experience? Like? Did you focus specifically on kids in the orphanage? Is that kind of where you went or sensory integration or what? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yes, my doctoral project was all on looking at the occupation and the occupational performance factors in orphanage-like settings, and I actually did my four-month apprenticeship at an orphanage in Romania. Jayson Davies Oh, wow. Dr. Jamie Chaves And work with caregivers who were at that orphanage. Jayson Davies Wow, that must have been an amazing definitely outside-of-the-box experience. Dr. Jamie Chaves It was one of the most challenging things I've done and also one of the richest learning experiences I've had as well. Jayson Davies And in Romania, then is occupational therapy, even really a thing out there. I know as far as I don't know, I talk to people outside of the country, and like occupational therapy isn't even a profession in some countries. So in Romania, is it a profession, is it something is it similar but called something different? Or? Yeah, Dr. Jamie Chaves There is a profession called occupational therapy, and it shares the same name. But I would say they're about 50 years behind where the United States is. So they're still doing a lot of those like craft-based, leather-based, like leatherworking. Yeah, like a lot of those types of occupational therapy, tactics, and they aren't really a well-recognized profession. And you don't really have to have a degree to get into the profession. It's more of like an associate's degree level. At least it was 10 years ago, I'm not exactly sure how it's progressed. Since then, I haven't really kept up to date on that. And pediatric occupational therapy was pretty much non-existent. It was all working with adults with mental and developmental disabilities. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Okay, that was gonna be my next question. Because historically, you know, occupational therapy in America really seems like it developed based upon a rehabilitative model. You know, after World War One, it was really working with armed services, right, or people that were coming back and were injured in OT was helping them to rehabilitate and get back to, "normal life". So I was wondering how that would look like in Romania. So it's mostly mental health and a little bit of rehabilitation. Dr. Jamie Chaves Yes. And it's very much. It's not an integrative thing. It's not trying to integrate people back into society or back into their families. It's like these. They're basically outcasts. And they, there's these occupational therapists who are working with these people who are who would otherwise be unsupported and not really seen as contributors to society or participants in society. Jayson Davies Yeah, very different. Dr. Jamie Chaves Yes. Jayson Davies Well, thank you for sharing that. So you said that was about 10 years ago, you've been working really, primarily with a pediatric population. And so where are you now then? Dr. Jamie Chaves I'm at the Center for Connection in Pasadena, California. The executive director is Dr. Tina Payne Bryson, who's the author, co-author of the whole brainchild and no Jama discipline, and they have several more books out as well. And she really, she has her Ph.D. in social work. And she really saw how what they were doing in mental health wasn't the whole picture. And there were missing pieces of the puzzle. So she started putting together a team that was more integrative and could put all the pieces together. And she saw occupational therapy as one of the biggest pieces of missing pieces of the puzzle. So she asked me to come on board, and I helped start the OT department there. And I'm at home full time with my two toddlers right now. So I'm not in the clinic full time and haven't been for the past two and a half years. But I'm hoping to get back there in the next couple of years. Jayson Davies Awesome. Yeah, I've heard great things about the center. And you know, we've had Olivia Martinez-Hauge on the show, and she also is a part of that center. And it's just amazing how someone who is not an occupational therapist who started this center really sees the value that occupational therapists can provide for all the people that that come into that center. So it's quite amazing that a social worker, by trade by training, is so invested in occupational therapy and sees our value. So that's just really cool. I really appreciate that. All right, so let's go ahead and dive into our real topic. For today. It was great doing a little introduction. But I want to know and you have written a book about this, along with your colleague, Ashley Taylor, but we want to know about how to support teachers with sensory regulation, self-regulation, and fostering safe regulating environments for students with varying sensory needs. So I think a great place to start would be to start with the current problem. What are you seeing in classrooms that led you to focus on supporting teachers within with regulating environments? Dr. Jamie Chaves Well, one of the things is that I've seen how empowered teachers feel, even when they just have this information. So many teachers don't get information. I mean, it's not taught in their classes in school, and so they don't get information about what does it mean to be regulated in order to learn and what is sensory processing? And what does it mean to feel safe in your environment? So empowering teachers to be able to ask different questions and see behaviors in a different light, and also empowering teachers to examine themselves and how they might not feel safe or regulated, or have their sensory needs met in the classroom, either, and how can they examine that to say, hey, I need to find support in this area, so I can support my students better. And also just seeing how empowered students feel when teachers are actually hearing them and responding to their needs for being regulated, or their sensory needs, which are also needs for being regulated. But yeah, I've just seen the trickle-down effect and how students participate more and feel more engaged in the learning process. Jayson Davies Gotcha. And so when you develop this book before it was a book, were you providing training to teachers in some capacity. Dr. Jamie Chaves That's basically what this book came out of, I had started doing some training a handful of years ago for teachers, just during lunch hours. And then it evolved into a 10-hour course, that I put together on sensory processing. And I thought, hey, this could be a book if put this down on paper. And so that's what we did. Jayson Davies Wow, that's amazing. So it really just started with a little lunchtime, you know, conversations with the teachers. And it's amazing what that can turn into. I know right now, you know, it's a big focus for occupational therapy within the schools, to not just see students individually in a pull-up model, you know, the more that we educate teachers on things that they can do within the classroom, the more that those teachers can then implement, just like what you're trying to do with his book. And I often like to say, you know, I could spend 30 minutes helping one student and a pullout session, or I could spend 30 minutes, I shouldn't say, or it's more of an and, and I can spend 30 minutes working with a teacher, and that teacher can then support. However many kids are in their classroom for the entire week, for the entire year. And then for the kids that they have next year and the kids that they have the year after that in the year after that. So knowledge is so powerful. And so I just love that you're spreading your knowledge and not keeping it all into yourself and only using it during your one on one sessions. Right. It's great that we're able to actually share that knowledge. That's so cool. So what have you found in regards to common misconceptions that teachers often have about sensory and regulating environments? I'm sure that when you're providing those training to them, you might get some pushback or just questions. And what are some of those questions or misconceptions you often hear? Dr. Jamie Chaves I think one of the things that frustrations that teachers face, and it's not just teachers, its parents, it's also therapists is that the sensory strategies, or the regulation strategies, the co-regulation strategies, they should work all the time, every time, and it's just not true. We change from day to day, we change from hour to hour, and what works one time might not work the next time. But that doesn't mean that it's not going to work again, or that it's a failed strategy. And so having multiple tools in your tool belt is something that's really important. And going along with that setbacks are normal, like, we don't progress, none of us progress. But we certainly don't develop or learn in a linear fashion. It's kind of two or three steps forward, and then maybe one or two steps back. And it's this push-pull process. And that's true of meeting kids' regulatory needs in the classroom as well. I think also, what I've seen, and we'll talk about some more of the sensory nook suggestions, but I've seen a lot of classes where teachers have self or CO regulation strategies or sensory strategies in the classroom. And they allow the child five minutes or 10 minutes or three minutes or whatever the time limit is. And I think there's a big misconception that regulation should happen within a confined period of time. And it could be that one day a child needs three minutes to step away, or the next day they might need 10 or 25. And I think it's important to not put those time limitations because ultimately it is going to negatively impact how they're participating or how engaged they are. And if you just allow them that extra 10 or 15 minutes, even if it seems like a waste of time to you are a waste of class or a waste of instruction. Are they missing out on a big piece? Ultimately, they're going to feel safer and more regulated in the classroom. So the next time they do come in, they are at a better place to be more focused and engaged, rather than feeling like, "Oh, man, if I get dysregulated, I only get five minutes. And if I'm not regulated again in five minutes, what's going to happen? I have to pull it together." So yeah, I would say those are some of them. Jayson Davies That's exactly what I see, too. And going to the next step, because I see this as well as you know, sensory processing sensory integration. It's a difficult concept to understand. And so I wanted to ask you, like, what is kind of your go-to blurb? You know, when you're explaining very quickly to a teacher, what sensory processing is, what sensory integration is, and how it will impact the students that they work with? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, my line is really sensory processing is how we make sense of our own bodies, how we make sense of what's happening in the environment, and how we relate to other people. And this all sets the foundation for our regulation, and regulation is the foundation for being engaged and being able to access your higher-level cognitive skills, which are what you typically are doing in the classroom. Jayson Davies Great. And that actually leads right into my next question, because you and I, haven't been in the traditional classroom and a few years, nine years, it sounds like we're both been practicing occupational therapists. And so we haven't taken an anatomy class or physio class in a while. But in your book, near the beginning chapter, I know you guys kind of dive into the anatomy a little bit, and more so about how the amygdala and how the oh gosh, the hypothalamus, and how they all work a little bit to create a response, whether it be the parasympathetic or sympathetic nervous system. And so if you wouldn't mind just kind of explaining that route that a sensory stimuli kind of goes up through the brain a little bit and where that sympathetic or parasympathetic nervous system kicks in of it. Dr. Jamie Chaves So when we talk about the system, particularly involved with the amygdala, we're talking about sensory modulation, which is one of the three branches of sensory integration. And sensory modulation is really important for our sense of regulation and determining what is safe and unsafe in our environment. So when we have some sort of sensory stimulus come in, all of the sensory systems passed through the thalamus, except one, I think it's olfactory, maybe it's either the olfactory, or gustatory, doesn't pass through the thalamus, which is then passed to the amygdala, the amygdala is really the center that determines what is safe and unsafe, because should I be fearful of this or not fearful of this, and if the amygdala is saying, "Hey, you should be fearful of this. That's really what triggers your fight flight or freeze response." If the amygdala says, "Hey, this is safe, you don't need to worry, you've already paid attention to it, and it's not a big deal", then the parasympathetic nervous system kicks in and says, "Hey, you can call him back down and you can carry on with your life." And the example that I like to give is, if you're in a cafe and you hear a dog barking, for example, you are likely, if you have a typically functioning auditory system, you're going to respond to that dog and you're going to turn and attend to it and your amygdala, your brain is going to be like, "Hey, whoa, I need like, that was a really loud sound. And I need to assess is this something I need to pay more attention to and act on? Or is it something where I can just remain calm and go back to reading my book?" And so most of us would turn and see like, oh, okay, the dogs on a leash and the owners got the dog under control. I don't have to be worried. The next time the dog barks because our brain hopes to habituate to the responses. Our brain isn't activated in the same way. Because our brain already knows I'm in a safe context. That dog isn't a threat to me. And we don't have to be constantly triggered. But kids who do have difficulty processing auditory input if they are overstimulated, would turn every single time and have that same sympathetic response of "oh, oh my gosh, that dogs barking again. Whoa, do an" If they couldn't focus on reading their book, they'd get a half a page read and a half an hour where we could finish a whole chapter because our, our system is regulated, and we can engage in something else. Jayson Davies Yeah, and the brain really is amazing, I don't know, organism, I guess, you know, it's quite amazing what it can do, and how it uses past experiences to also help us regulate because, you know, the brain would not be very functional if every time we got a new sensory stimulus, we weren't able to relate it to something that we had heard or seen or smelled in the past. And so it's amazing how it can work so quickly, and how it can recall all those past experiences so quickly. But like you're mentioning, if the brain can't do that, then you're going to have that same experience over and over again, where it's trying to figure out, am I in a safe environment. And if it doesn't have any past experiences to reference to, you're going to kind of go through that flight, fight, flight or freeze every single time as opposed to already having a reference point. And knowing Yes, I'm in that safe spot. So Wow, pretty, it's pretty crazy how the brain works, I got to give it that one of the words that you have really keyed on is safe. And you mentioned that students have to feel safe in their classrooms to feel safe in the cafeteria. What do you mean by safe in relation to a student's classroom setting? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, so really, when I'm talking about safety, and well, Ashley and I are talking about safety, particularly in our books, we're talking about nervous system regulation. And going back to the amygdala, is the amygdala feeling safe and calm, is the nervous system imbalance where the sympathetic nervous system isn't taking over for the brain, and the student can feel like, they can just operate as usual through life, which is what most of us do, where we are in a calm, alert state. That's really what safety is for our nervous system. And it's really rooted in the positive, trusting relationships that we have through co-regulation. It's based on a sense of control over your own body over the environment, you know, what to anticipate out of your body, you know, what to anticipate out of the environment, and you can trust in those things. And you can trust the people who are also around you. Jayson Davies Yeah. And so then how do you teach teachers a way for them to facilitate that safety? Is there a specific strategy or set of strategies that you're able to help them with? Dr. Jamie Chaves I think the first thing is teachers' understanding, we call it the teacher-student response cycle. And teacher's understanding, how their responses and how their own regulation can impact a student's regulation. And thus, a student's response is really a foundational point, because that's how we can get to a co-regulation state, that if a student is feeling really frustrated about doing something and throws a book across the room, and the teacher comes up and says, "Hey, you can't do that you need to go pick up that book right now", then that might trigger the student even more, and then their behavior is going to be reflective of that. But if the teacher can get into a better state of regulation, himself, approach the child and say, "Hey, it sounds like you're getting really frustrated. Let's try to figure out what we can do differently here." The teachers in a regulated state, the student is going to match that regulation, and then they can move forward with the problem-solving stage, and it might not happen that fluidly. But that's the general concept of it. Because co-regulation is really the foundation of self-regulation. And you have to have that established first. And there are so many self-regulation strategies out there. But really, it's co-regulation strategies, shared moments of joy, seeing songs together, taking pictures together, talking about what happened over the weekend together. I think those can be really powerful co-regulation experiences between teachers and students. Jayson Davies Yeah, that leads into another question that I have then, based upon your response, you know, you mentioned co-regulation, and I think that really is an occupational therapy term. I think that or maybe not Occupational Therapy specific but more of mental health, medical term per se. And I don't think it's a term that teachers would really associate with. And I don't know if they have a term for that. Maybe it's school culture, potentially. But how can an occupational therapist working in a school help teachers to understand that term co-regulation? Do you think that trainings are the best way? Or do you think potentially getting into the classroom and maybe modeling it? How can an OT who's working in a school help teachers to understand the concept of co-regulation? Dr. Jamie Chaves I think it's both ends. I think understanding the underlying concepts around it, and how the nervous system works, and how self-regulation does develop out of co-regulation. What are the zones of regulation, all of that terminology is a really important foundation. But then seeing done and in action is also just such a powerful method of learning. I just wrote a blog post about multi-sensory learning. And that's what that is, I mean, you're like experiencing, it's more of this kinesthetic experience. And then you can step in and or the teacher can step in and say, Okay, let me take over from here and see how I can do it, and model it for the student in the same way that you are modeling it for that teacher. But yeah, I think I mean, it's a process and I, as a parent too like, I use co-regulation so much as a parent. And it's a process, I know all of the things, and I've seen it modeled before, and I've done it myself before. And it still is, it just takes practice. And so just encouraging teachers to start somewhere and start with something and build off of that, knowing that it's never too late to change. And you don't have to be afraid to do things differently and think differently because it is kind of countercultural to what a lot of the behavioral strategies are out there. Jayson Davies Exactly. Yeah. And that's where I was gonna go with the next question, a little off-script. But talking about that behavioral change, you know, so much for the last 100 years, or more, I don't know, schools have been so focused on behavior. And we think how much progress public education has made, you know, you can't walk around and hit a kid sand with a ruler any more, like you used to be able to do back in the 40s, or whatever it was, but there is still a very much a behavioral approach from teachers. And it can be difficult to change that mindset. And I think by bringing in that co-regulation idea, you are in a roundabout way, changing the shift from behavior to regulation. And so I think that's an important context. You know, we moved from potentially having clip charts to being more in tune with the child and meeting them where they are. And so I don't even know if this is leading to a question, honestly. But I know that's a big shift right now. But it is also a very difficult shift for teachers because that is what they learn. And, you know, Dr. Jamie Chaves and it's not just teachers, Jayson Davies True Dr. Jamie Chaves it's parents, it's, I mean, it's society culture as a whole. I mean, I don't, it's kind of a trickle-down effect. And I don't want to totally call them out. But pediatricians like that's how they're guiding parents in behavioral-based strategies because they're not getting this information in school. But they're the ones that parents pass through when their kids are toddlers, and they're first acting out. And a lot of teachers are parents. And so they've gotten that information from the pediatrician. And they've used that as parents, and then they're enacting it in their classroom because, and it's like this huge cultural shift of like, we need to educate so many people on this shit like, it's the pediatricians, as well as all of us therapists and teachers and parents. And but yeah, I mean, it is a really hard shift when it has been so embedded in our culture that, well, if a child keeps doing this, they're going to learn that that's okay. Well, if you keep attending to a child's regulation needs, then they're not going to keep doing it because they are going to feel safe and they are going to feel like they have their needs met and that you can problem-solve together and find a different pathway forward. Jayson Davies Yeah, and or Earlier you talked about and this ties right into it, I wanted to talk about it when you mentioned it earlier, you talked about how sometimes a teacher or even a therapist or parent, we say you have five minutes to go get regulated? And well, there's a problem in the whole sense with that, because you're saying, I'm going to use a behavioral approach for an hour, and then now go get regulated in five minutes. Versus what if we turn that into instead of a behavioral approach for an hour, five minutes for regulation? What if we spent that entire hour with the regulation approach and co-regulating with the students and saying, all right, yes, you're frustrated at the minute, number one. But let's start there with co-regulation, not wait 60 minutes later, to let you have a break and potentially go get regulated. And so changing that mindset, we can't just change that mindset for five minutes a day or five minutes every hour, there really needs to be a whole paradigm, you know, full-day, every minute of everyday shift. And so I think that's very important. And that's awesome, that, that you're working on that shift with so many other people, too. Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, and it's a shift from what we typically do as like rewards punishment, even in terms of like, oh, well, I know, playing outside is really regulating for you, or I know this, the sensory nook is really regulating for you. So finish these finish writing these two sentences, and then you can go to the sensory nook and calm down, like, no, go to the sensory nook, and calm down, and then come back and finish writing these two sentences. And it'll go faster, the child will be in a better cognitive state because they won't be so triggered in their lower levels of the brain that they can access those higher levels of the brain. And that writing experience will be wired more positively in their brain rather than negatively. And, yeah, I mean, we want to, we want to hurry things along and say just write these two sentences, and then you can go off and do your thing. But really, it's the opposite that we need to be focused on. And like you're saying, it could be that the child spends 20 minutes and that sensory nook rather than 20 minutes at the desk, struggling to write those two sentences. Jayson Davies Yeah, and I want to talk more about the environment in the note, but based upon what you're just saying, one of the things that OTs I don't think have been the best at and our counterpart with behavior lists are really good at is documenting, and documenting how things are working. And they sit there with a notepad, and they marked down every single thing that works and doesn't work. And then they're able to present these very detailed charts that show you know, progress, potentially, because the student is learning over time, hey, if I write those two sentences, I get to go to the nook a little bit faster. And so the time goes down 20 minutes, Monday, 19 minutes, Tuesday, whatever. But how do we document that doing the opposite using a co-regulation approach works in a way that we can kind of show the parents that it's working because we see it working? But how do we document that it's working? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, I think that's a good question. And I, I know that's a struggle for public health, too, when you're doing these, like preventative things, how you how do you show that it's actually preventing something from happening when it doesn't actually happen. And when you're a behavior analyst, you're looking at behaviors. And that's what we're doing as OTs too. We're just looking at the behaviors in a different way. And so you can still track those behaviors and the frequency of the behavior and the duration of the behavior. But the approach to the decrease of that is so different. It's not that you are you're moving a clip or you're giving them an incentive every time like, oh, he only needs five incentives now like, no, he only needs five minutes of being in a sensory nook or he only accessed a fidget toy three times today instead of eight times today. So I think we're still looking at those same behaviors, and we can document those behaviors in the same way. But the way that we're getting to the decrease in behaviors is really different. Jayson Davies Yeah, no, that makes sense. And I want to throw this out there too, is that the way that behavioral list their structure of practice is laid out? They are given the time to actually track data. When we think about a BCBA model. They have the BCBA who is kind of in a way the occupational therapist per se, right? We're the person doing the evaluation but then they have someone who is often sitting with a child for hours at a time. And they are marking down every single thing that happens. And as occupational therapists, we typically don't have that opportunity, even an occupational therapy assistant is not going to be one to sit with a child for three hours. And document every single time a student throws a book, or throws a pencil or refuses to do a task, or on a different side positively says, Hey, I need to go to the sensory nook, or hey, I need a break. So it's kind of difficult for us, to take data. And I know often a school-based occupational therapist, we are inclined. And we're, we're very polite about it when we try our best to get help from a teacher or help from a classroom aide to take that data for us. But to be fair, they have their own jobs to be doing. And it is very difficult for them to also take data on that when they're trying to. I mean, they're trying to teach that that's what their job is they're trying to teach. And it's hard for them to take data. And so I do kind of wish, and I'm almost jealous of these behavioral technicians that get to spend two hours, three hours, or even all day with a student. And I'm just like, man, what if I had one day that I could spend with one kid the entire day? Oh, and by the way, I'm in their natural context with the teacher there who I can also explain what I'm doing. And yeah, you know, I get a little jealous of that, because they do have that time with a child that we just don't have, we typically have a half-hour, maybe an hour, at best a week with a student. And I know there are studies going on right now to try and figure out dosages a little bit and compare that. But yeah, I just think it'd be awesome. If we could have just one opportunity to spend an entire day with a kid and how much progress we could potentially make. I don't know. Do you have any thoughts on that? Dr. Jamie Chaves No, I think it's true. And I mean, I honestly hope the model is shifting not only for the sake of OTs, for the sake of kids, I hope that the model is shifting away from ABA. And maybe it's more time like DIR floor time specialists who are spending the three hours a day in the classroom with them. And then they are getting these co-regulation techniques rather than behavior techniques. And floor time specialists can also measure data really well too I mean, in a different way. But yeah, I just hope the model is shifting away from so much of the ABA in the classroom and more of these co-regulation… Jayson Davies Strategies. Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, strategy. Yeah. approaches. Jayson Davies Yeah. All right. It's so easy to get off topic when we start going down that route. But let's go back and get on the topic a little bit. Talking about the classroom environment, how do you support teachers in understanding that the environment can have an impact on a student's performance and the child feeling safe? We've talked a little bit about safety. And you've also discussed a little bit about the nooks. So maybe you can expand a little bit more on that? Dr. Jamie Chaves Sure. Well, I would say one of the most enlightening things for teachers is two of them, actually, are one examining their own sensory preferences. I think a lot of people think of sensory and they think of sensory processing differences. But we all have sensory preferences. And once teachers realize, like, wow, I do have these sensory preferences, and they're inputs I lean into, and they're inputs that I stay away from and when I can't avoid those inputs, I feel more dysregulated. Or if I can't lean into the inputs, I need to I feel more dysregulated like I'm a sensory being too. I think that's really enlightening and helps them see all of their students in a different light and realize why someone might have different sensory needs on one day versus another day because teachers are realizing, hey, I have different sensory needs on a daily basis as well. And also, what I like to do with teachers is have them experience what different sensory processing differences might feel like. And that's something we put into our book as well. In each of the sensory chapters, we have an experience it box, and that's something that anyone reading the book could guide teachers through, just pick it up and say, Hey, teachers, we're going to go through this experience, and it really makes teachers step back and say, "Whoa, I can understand how a child would have a really hard time learning in this environment when this is what they might be experiencing" Jayson Davies Absolutely. So you've mentioned the nook a little bit during this hour so that we that we're talking and so what do you look for in a nook? Or when teachers are trying to develop a nook? What do you kind of recommend? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, so a sensory nook is really a place where kids can go and access different sensory inputs that would have a calming impact on their bodies. And it's not something that every student might access. And it might not be something that students access, even on a regular basis. And they might need different like one day, they might need body brakes versus going to the sensory knock, but it is, again, a tool in a teacher's tool belt. And so I like a place that has pillows, something soft, I like heavier pillows because they can give more appropriate receptive input, calming visual input, they have some of those fish tanks, those light-up fish tanks that kind of scroll around or like a lava lamp, but not one that plugs in, there's just like these things where the bubbles move in the water, something like that's really calming, there might be some noise-canceling headphones, there might be access to music, that's calming, they can put on headphones, and access calming music, fidgets might be like a basket of fidgets back there. And then I usually recommend having some sort of zones of a regulation chart with the green and red and blue zones, or different pictures of emotions, so that kids can communicate by pointing to different pictures because language is a higher-level cognitive skill that might drop out when kids are dysregulated. But so that they can communicate where they might be at in the process. And I think a lot of sensory notes have timers, and I really, really don't recommend having a timer in the sensory neck. I know you're asking what I do recommend, but I don't recommend putting a timer back there because it puts more pressure on the child and can make them feel anxious, which is a state of dysregulation about whether or not they're going to meet that time. Jayson Davies Yeah. And you know, I think I already know the answer to this question. But what would you say to the teacher, the parent administrator, who says, "well, then what's going to happen while that one student is in the nook and is missing out on the instruction that the teacher is providing?" What's your response to that? Dr. Jamie Chaves Well, I would say, particularly in younger years, I feel like this answer is easier because so much of the material is repeated. A lot of the instruction, like when you're learning to tell time, you don't just learn that in one, one instruction period, like you're doing it over multiple instruction periods. So I think it's easier to say, like, "Well, hey, they, they miss some of that, and they'll pick up where they left off the other day." But I think it's really important for people to see that regulation is just as important as taking in some of that cognitive information. And when kids are in a regulated state, they're going to be able to take it in faster, more likely, they'll be able to take it in faster, and they'll be able to integrate it a lot more, as well. So it might be that they just pick up where they left off. And then whatever the teacher needs to fill in, in a quick, quick lesson, it might just be that they kind of pick up there. But yeah, like I said, in the younger years, there's so much repetition that happens that I feel like it can naturally be folded into how the child's learning. Jayson Davies Yeah, and I think it's also a little, it's difficult to have the conversation, but it leads to an understanding of sensory processing. When we let the parent the teacher administrator, understand and let them know that that child isn't missing anything that they might have been already missing anyways because they were dysregulated. And so I could let them sit in that chair dysregulated for 20 minutes, not learning anything. Or I could let them go to the nook and become regulated in less than 20 minutes and get back to the task and potentially miss less instruction. And who knows while they're in the nook, regulating. They're still listening in in a little bit. And as they become more regulated, the more they might take in and so maybe instead of missing 20 minutes, they're missing five minutes, but they're in the note for an extra five to 10 minutes really getting to the point of regulation. And so they're still keying in on what's being said, maybe they're not seeing the board where the teachers writing down one plus one or whatever, but they're still potentially taking that in auditorily. So, yeah, I think it's really key that we let teachers know that part of it. Dr. Jamie Chaves I would agree. Jayson Davies Yeah. So we talked about a nook. But what about a sensory lab or motor lab? What are your thoughts on a motor lab within a classroom? That kind of looks more like a traditional sensory integration type of gym? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, I mean, I think it's great for school sites to have that it's great, particularly for kids who have sensory processing differences, who do need more of that because I see it written a lot, which is true to a degree, but I see it written that kids know their own sensory needs, and they will meet their needs. And then they will, like, kind of move on, which is, like I said, true for a lot of kids. But for sensory kids with sensory processing differences, that's not true. Their typical environments are not meeting their sensory needs, and they're not able to meet their own sensory needs, which is why they have sensory processing differences. So yeah, having a space to be able to access inputs that are more intense or less intense, or different than what their typical environment provides, I think is really helpful. The direction that Ashley and I really push for in our books is multi-sensory learning, where it's just folded into the curriculum and folded into the classroom engagement where kids are learning more through play and through experience and through Yeah, different ways of learning and doing and being and explicitly exploring with students how some students have strengths in some areas and vulnerabilities in some areas, and then other students, it's, it might be reversed, and how can those things complement each other? And how can we create a learning environment where everybody can learn, regardless of their strengths and vulnerabilities, rather than always leaning into the strengths of auditory and visual learners, which I think is what traditionally classrooms have done? Jayson Davies Yeah, I think you're right. And again, this kind of leads right into an area that I think is not well understood within sensory integration. And that's praxis. You know, when we think of sensory, we don't think of praxis, it's not a true sense. It's not a sense at all. It's a combination of how we act on our senses, along with the environment. And so I want to ask you a little bit about praxis and how you explain that to teachers, in the sense of learning, how does praxis impact learning? And how do you explain that to teachers? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, so what I've learned through the years is that praxis is really the foundation for executive functioning skills. And I think teachers know a lot more about executive function and how executive function impacts learning. And basically, if we can't organize our bodies and organize our body movements, and how we're moving through space, then organizing materials and objects, and thoughts within the environment are going to be even more difficult. So I think that's something that teachers can really relate to, in particular with praxis. Jayson Davies And then do you feel that praxis can have an impact on child safety and child regulation as well? Dr. Jamie Chaves It's one of the biggest factors I think I see with kids with sensory processing differences. I mean, the confidence that we gain through our movements and being able to depend on our movements and depend on our motor responses, and when we can't rely on that. It's so frustrating and it just becomes us a space where you're like, I don't want to try anymore, or I just want to be goofy because it hides the fact that this is challenging or, and so kids with praxis, I would say are one of the biggest group with dyspraxia, I should say, are one of the biggest groups who need co-regulation and who really need safe environments where they can trust what's going to happen and have things more in their sense of control and build their resilience more so that they can take steps to be more independent in some of the things that are really just so challenging and take up so much cognitive space that they don't have anything left to actually learn the math problem because they're taking up so much cognitive space just on figuring out how to hold the pencil. Jayson Davies Exactly. I agree. And, you know, that's one of the things that I find myself explaining within IEP meetings so often. It's just that, you know, handwriting we make it look simple. But there are so many factors that go into handwriting. And of course, praxis is one of them. And then you add on the demand of putting a sentence together, or you add on the demand of putting multiple sentences together, and you're just adding demand on demand on demand when something hasn't been perfected. And they're trying to relearn every single time how to make a letter R. And we're trying to get them to spell a word that has two R's in it, or whatever it might be. And so we're just adding demands before the student has kind of moved beyond that motor learning or beyond that praxis ability to muscle memory. And so yeah, that's, that's very difficult. I'll never, I'll never forget this one time, I was working with a kid. And she just threw her book and her pencil on the floor, I think we were coloring and it was something very simple, like just coloring in and shapes. And she became so distraught that she just threw everything off the table onto the floor. And immediately, she felt so sad and started apologizing, and went to go pick everything up. And I was like, that's not frustration. That's not a behavior of, I don't want to do this. That's a behavior of I can't do this, I need help. I don't want to do this, because it's difficult for me. And I think that just shows the praxis. And I think that shows how dyspraxia, like you're talking about, can lead to dysregulation so yeah, I'm right there with them I feel like practice is 100%, something that needs to be intact, in order for learning to occur in the classroom. Dr. Jamie Chaves And we actually wrote a whole chapter in our book, the why behind classroom behaviors, which is the first book we published, we wrote a whole chapter on handwriting, because we thought, this is an area that causes so much dysregulation, not only for students but also for teachers and helping teachers understand, like you said, what goes into handwriting and how many layers are present and that it's not a developmental skill, it's something that you truly have to learn through so many integrations through the integration of so many areas of the brain. So yeah, Jayson Davies so I think that's going to kind of wrap up what we're talking about. But I do want to dive into your book a little bit, I was reading it the other day. And I really love how you guys organized the chapters, and actually want to give you a second to kind of talk about that organization a little bit because you kind of talked about knowledge first, and then what a teacher may see and then kind of what they can do based upon that. And so I want to let you share how you and Ashley kind of developed the book and came to organize it. Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, as I said, it was really developed out of the trainings that I was doing. And that just happened to be how I was organizing the trainings. And it was working for the educators with who I was doing the trainings. And they liked the flow of that. So I just kept it as the flow in the chapters. And I wanted to make it accessible, while at the same time, make it informative. And I want educators to have all of that information background, but then also not have to connect all the dots as to okay, how might I see this in the classroom? How might it be impacting kids' behaviors the most in the classroom? And then what might I see? And then how specifically, might I address this? And then, like I said, earlier, we wanted those experience, experiential learning things to be part of the picture as well so that teachers could take a step back and really feel like what sensory processing differences might be. Jayson Davies That's awesome. Yeah, I really love it. It's super affordable. I was telling you that earlier, I really expected this book to be more like the price of a textbook. And I love that you guys have made it right around that $29-30 price range. So it's actually accessible for both occupational therapists, teachers, any educator, which I love about that because the last thing anyone wants to do is to spend 120 bucks on a book and I know that's difficult. But at the $30 price range. This is information that's so valuable, that teachers can pick up and read a chapter a week and it's going to help them better understand their students that have sensory processing. differences. So that is awesome. Dr. Jamie Chaves And OTs too Jayson Davies and OT Dr. Jamie Chaves OT like OTs who are just starting off or even OTs been in the field for a while. I mean, I had OTs in mind when we were writing this as well because we all get different levels of training. Jayson Davies Yeah, and we all can't afford a $600 level one course from any of the sensory processing. Big. Yes, $30 You can't beat that for getting a very good start with sensory processing and understanding all of the senses from the five typical senses and then also into vestibular proprioception. I think you even wrote a little bit about interoception on the right. Yes, yeah. So it's a great place to start. I told you, I was gonna give you an opportunity to shout out to Ashley and I completely missed that part. So if you can share with us a little bit about Ashley, how you guys came to work together? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah. So Ashley Taylor is a PhRSID. She has a specialty in early childhood development. She's a practicing clinical psychologist, she does a lot of neuro-psych neuropsychological testing, I met her at the Center for Connection. And we just really hit it off. And we shared a lot of clients together. And we've learned so much from each other throughout the years. And I would really highly recommend all OTs to buddy up with somebody who does really good work on neuropsychological or psychoeducational testing and really understand those assessments and how they overlap with OT, and then vice versa, being able to share as an OT how what we are seeing in the kids and students that we work with, how that might inform the neuro-psych and psycho Ed assessments as well. Jayson Davies Yeah, and you know, I know, if you're not within a big city, like myself, and you are in Pasadena, a subset of a large city, then you're often left to work on your own as an occupational therapist, and you may not have another occupational therapist, within your city or sometimes within your county that you get to work with. And, you know, we have to remember that we can get knowledge from people who are not always occupational therapists, and our mentors can be people who are psychologists, speech and language pathologists, physical therapists, you know, we don't always have to have an occupational therapist, I recommend you do find occupational therapists. And that's probably why you're listening to this podcast right now. But at the same time, learn from people who are outside of the field of OT, because they have so much to teach us as well. And we also have so much to teach them. And so working together, using that interaction approach, we can support students from all sides, and not just from an OT lens, but from a PT, a speech, a teaching lens. So definitely agree with you there. So yeah, where can people learn a little bit more about you, if they want to buy the book? If they want to just get in touch with you? Where can they learn about you? Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, so we are on Instagram at the @whybehindbehaviors. My personal website is jamiechaves.otd.webstarts.com. And then our books, the why behind classroom behaviors. And creating sensory smart classrooms are both available on Amazon. Jayson Davies Great, and we will be sure to link all of those in the show notes. So be sure to head on over to the show notes for this page. You can find that in your podcast player and all of the links to her website to the Instagram pages, and the books will be there for you all to find super easily. So Jamie, thank you so much for coming on the show really appreciate having you on. And I know this specific, this topic, the knowledge that you've shared today is going to help so many occupational therapists, I mean the occupational therapy assistants, and in turn, hundreds 1000s Maybe of teachers and the students that they serve. So thank you so much for being here today. Dr. Jamie Chaves Yeah, thanks for the conversation. That was great. Jayson Davies Definitely take care and have a great rest of your day. Dr. Jamie Chaves Thank you too. Bye-bye. Jayson Davies One more time. Thank you so much to Jamie for coming on the podcast and sharing all that information about sensory processing, sensory integration, and self-regulation, and safety within our students. She really obviously knows everything that she is talking about. And if you want to learn more about everything related to this topic, be sure to check out her book on Amazon. It's got a lot of great information and it is a pretty easy and also cheap read so be sure to check that out. Thank you so much for hanging in there and listening to this entire episode. I appreciate you being a part of the OT schoolhouse community. And I look forward to our next episode together. Take care. Have a great rest of your day and I'll see you next time. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT Schoolhouse podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now, head on over to otschoolhouse.com. Until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- Top Tips For New School-Based OTs From the OT School House Community
The world of school-based occupational therapy is unique and different than any other setting. We are medical professionals in a world of education. You could say that we are “the odd man out”. As occupational therapists, we are educated to support a medical model. However, when we cross over to school-based therapy, our framework and foundation must shift to an education model. Because of this, I feel like school-based OTs spend an insane amount of time educating parents, faculty, and staff about our role in the school system. Since we are initially trained in the medical model, if a therapist is just starting in the school system as a brand new graduate, or if an OT practitioner is transitioning into the schools after 20 years in inpatient rehab, the simple idea of starting in a school-based model can be daunting and terrifying all at the same time. So, when Jayson prompted the community to share a tip for new practitioners on Instagram, there were almost a hundred helpful comments from experienced school-based OT practitioners. Clearly, therapists are more than willing to give advice, especially related to areas and situations where they wish someone would have told them how to (you can fill in the blank). As we dove into the comments more, several themes surfaced and we wanted to take some time to share and expand on these words of wisdom. Tip #1: Build relationships with everyone on campus “Make sure your admin know who you are” @Theaccommodationstation (Alexandra) “Make friends with the custodian! You never know when you’ll need to borrow tools/hardware or have them rig something up for you!” @Theeverydayot (Sarah) “In addition to making friends with the building secretaries and janitor, befriend the gym teacher…Also, don’t forget to provide support to the ‘specials’ teachers (art, gym, music, and computer). These teachers a lot of time get little support and aren’t quite sure how to meet students’ needs. Art and gym are often great classes to push in to for OTs.” - @Raejean84 (Raejean) Each school you walk into is a family. Each member has its role and place, and no one wants to be left out. In all the years I have been in the schools, I cannot count the number of times I have borrowed the janitor’s hammer to “fix-up” a student’s locker to increase accessibility, or the number of adapted scissors (usually the loop scissors) I have given to art teachers for our students in special education classrooms to use while in their classroom. These are all things that can help build relationships within each of your campuses. No one is too great or too small to be involved. When you ask for that hammer, be genuine while you ask how their day is going. Take a second to see what the cafeteria monitor’s favorite TV show is. When you take the time to build these relationships across the entire campus, you can bet that they are going to reciprocate that relationship and take an interest in you. Tip #2: Take time to build rapport “Always start with building rapport with your clients, you’ll be able to more effectively meet your goals once your students have a solid trust in you and your relationship!” - @Kidscopinglab (Dr. Meryl & Shae) The phrase “It takes a village to raise a child” can definitely apply here. Taking some time to build rapport with each of those individuals can help bring the entire team together. It can be simple things, like asking about their day, or offering to check supplies of adapted paper so they never run out. It could mean taking some time to sit in on the IEP meeting they told you about last minute, or adapting and integrating parent strategies into the classroom setting. Once you take this time to build rapport with the team, it becomes easier for them to help you as well if you get into a difficult situation. Tip #3: Do not be afraid to ask questions “Don’t be afraid to ask questions #yr2schoolCOTA” - @Haepi_ft (Elisha) “Ask questions! Ask where the bathroom/gym/nurse’s office is rather than wandering around until you find it…Ask for help, Ask what people mean by acronyms- you get smarter and better at your job when you ask clarifying questions than when you pretend to know what people are talking about” @Michellemarie5 (Michelle) This is where the previous rapport building and building relationships can come in handy. If you have taken the time to build rapport and relationships on your campuses, they are going to be more likely to help you. It can be embarrassing to ask simple questions about the location of the bathroom or where room 204 is. If you take time to build relationships, the teachers and staff are going to be more than willing to help you. They know you care. Tip #4: Reach out for training and in turn, train others “Take advantage of all the mentorship you can get. Watch and learn” @Tarradp (Tarra) “Do a lot of training. Train those teachers, push in, and present, present, present. You have too many kids to see all alone so instill help in the staff. Collaborate constantly.” - @Kidsviewtherapy (Theresa) “Collaborate and create alliances with your case carriers and specialized academic instruction teachers, They will be your eyes and ears for your students everyday even if you physically can’t be on the school campus.” @Mamawells329 (Christine) “Push in to the classroom, let the teachers see you working with the students. It will help create rapport with the teachers and buy-in for interventions you want to implement. Also makes sure what you might be working on in a pull out session transfer into their everyday environment” @Ashmenzies (Ashley) Take a second to think back to your entry-level OT curriculum. What was one of the tools your professors or instructors would use to help teach concepts? Teaching others! Once you have received some training or some correction, take the time to turn around and apply it. This could be through training a teacher on a strategy you are using with a student or discussing a new strategy with a coworker or colleague. This can also help you build collaborative teams and alliances within your different campuses. If you have access to other OTs, maybe see if they can come and observe you or sit with you through your first IEP meeting. They can help you point out things about yourself that you may not pick up on. It could be little things like “your posture appeared very closed and uninviting” to “when you are talking with the parent, a different way to phrase that would be…”. Do not look at it as a colleague trying to pick apart everything little thing you do, but as an opportunity to grow and learn as a therapist. Listen to Episode 45 of the OT School House Podcast for even more tips! Tip #5: Find your own organization strategy so you can be flexible “1. Using electronic documentation as much as possible and find some sort of way to keep track of IEP dates. 2. Try to avoid bouncing back and forth between schools.” - @Yoursch00lot (Amanda) “I recommend making yourself a checklist of all the things that need to be completed before/after IEPs (data collection, teacher consult, scoring goals, drafting goals, documentation, etc.).” - @Sarahbeeot (Sarah) “Before IEP meetings observe the child in class, talk to the teacher, and call the parents." - @Wootherapy (Meghan) “Be kind to yourself. Figure out a schedule that allows you to spend the most time with your kiddos and supporting staff.” - @Mornings.with.an.ot.mom (Danielle) “Be flexible! Write everything in pencil because it will change. Also, give yourself some grace to make mistakes and take long on things. The first year is DIFFICULT and so you need that year to learn the rhythm and routine of the school year.” - @hopemccarroll (Hope) Everyone is going to have their own way to keep organized. Jayson, for instance, keeps items electronically. He even offers you resources for free to help with organization when you subscribe to the OTschoolhouse.com email list. I, however, do not keep up with items well if I keep them online or electronically. I have forms that I keep in one binder and have dividers for each campus. I have had systems in the past where I had a binder or folder for each campus. I think you need to figure out a system that works best for you that is going to help you stay organized. Also, I keep a paper planner and write out a schedule every single week. I take it as an opportunity to cluster treatment sessions on the same campus and look at moving sessions if I have an IEP meeting or additional staff meeting on the campus a different day of the week. I do this knowing that my schedule will change during the week, but I can easily keep track of the sessions I need to move and reschedule when changes come. And that is not an “if changes come” but “when they come”. Tip #6: Document everything “If it’s not documented, It never happened!” -Elisa Wern Documentation is everything. Documentation is not just for treatment sessions but, it is also for everyday tasks and conversations as well. If an incident happens, document it. A consultation with a teacher or conversation with the parent, document it. If you attended an IEP meeting or staffing, document it. You really should do this for a number of reasons: First, It becomes part of the child’s running record and chart. Even IEP meetings can help document recommendations made about service time so another therapist could look at it and see the progression over time. Second, this can also really show the time it takes to be part of a child’s case. Districts are always looking for documentation related to how you spend your time during the day. This is a great way to document that. It is hard to quantify a conversation with a parent or how long consultation meetings with teachers actually take. This is a way to keep track of that. And finally, if you are ever questioned about how you spend your time, you are able to pull your own documentation records and see exactly what you did because you documented it. Tip #7: Advocate for yourself “Advocate for the children but most importantly YOURSELF.” @OTwithKenzie (Kenzie) “Change takes time. You will see many things you are not ok with. Focus on the things you can change.” - @mornings.with.an.ot.mom (Danielle) In the school system, advocating as an occupational therapist could look many different ways. Maybe it is advocating for additional OT staff or for help on a campus or two because you are behind on treatment sessions or piled with evaluations. You may also choose to advocate for additional programming on a campus because of a trend you are seeing related to the mental health and anxiety in the children on that campus. You may also advocate for additional training and help on a particular case. Do not be afraid to be honest with yourself and others about your needs. Many of the educational service centers and AOTA have tons of resources, but you may not always know how to access those. It never hurts to ask! Although you may feel alone in this endeavor of school-based therapy, know that you have access to a plethora of other school-based therapists virtually that you can also rely on for additional advice. There are many Facebook groups, podcasts (such as the OT School House Podcast), blogs, and Instagram accounts (including all the people who are quoted in this article) that can all be used as resources to build your own therapy community. Do not be afraid to put yourself out there and to build that community! Have a great first year! Author Bio: Hope McCarroll has been an occupational therapist since 2011. Her primary area of focus has been school-based occupational therapy services. She recently made the leap to academia and is currently core faculty at University of St. Augustine for Health Sciences. Hope continues to practice as a pediatric occupational therapist while teaching occupational therapy students.
- OTSH 86: Journal Club - The Problem with Caseloads
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Welcome to the show notes for Episode 86 of the OT School House Podcast. In this journal club edition of the OT School House Podcast, we are examining the 2020 Seruya & Garfinkle article about the current workload trends in school-based OT. We will discuss the findings from a survey of 571 OT Practitioners working in the schools just like you and talk about the real-life implications your caseload can have on your practice. Spoiler alert: Your Caseload is likely holding you back, but listen in to hear how you are not alone and what steps you can take to move forward. Also, stay tuned until the end for a special announcement and giveaway from Jayson. Links to Show References: Get access to the Making the Shift: Caseload to Workload Workshop! Article Citation: Seruya, F. M., & Garfinkel, M. (2020). Caseload and workload: Current trends in school-based practice across the United States. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 74, 7405205090. https://doi.org/10.5014/ajot.2020.039818 Transcript Download the Transcript or read the episode below! Jayson Davies Hey there, and welcome to this journal club episode of the OT School House podcast. My name is Jayson Davies. And I am so happy to have you here joining me from wherever you are. As you might have noticed, we're starting this podcast off like we have a few in the past where we do the intro first. And then we're going to cue that intro to the music that we all love so much in just a moment. But first, I just wanted to let you all in that this episode is a very important episode because we're talking about something called a caseload and a workload and how those differ how they're similar a little bit. And we're actually bringing in an article from the American Journal of Occupational Therapy to kind of show where we're at today, or actually where we were at in 2020, right before the shutdown of everything. But anyway, that's a different story for another time. So I'm excited to have you here this entire, this entire episode is going to lead to something bigger I have an announcement as well as a giveaway at the end of this episode. But I really want you, to listen in to this entire episode because it all comes together at the end for one big announcement that I'm super excited about and cannot wait to share with you. So let's go ahead and cue the intro. And when we come back, we're going to talk about an article titled caseload and workload current trends and school-based practices across the United States. Alright, I will see you in just a moment right after this intro. Amazing Narrator Hello, and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school-based occupational therapy, tips, interviews, and professional development. Now to get the conversation started. Here's your host, Jayson Davies, class is officially in session. Jayson Davies Alright, welcome back. Thank you again so much for being here. I want to start off by sharing a little bit of the demographics I guess you can call it the information about this article that we're discussing today. The title is "Caseload and Workload: Current trends in School-Based practice across the United States". It was published in the AJOT, the American Journal of Occupational Therapy back in 2020. So it is relatively new. And the authors who I just admire so much are Francine Seruya and Mindy Garfinkel, more on them in just a bit. The full citation can be found down in the show notes or at otschoolhouse.com/episode 86. I cannot believe we're on episode 86. This has just been a whole blur from episode one to Episode 86. And thank you so much for being along for the ride. So I want to talk to a moment about Seruya and Garfinkel, Mindy, and Francine they had been so instrumental in supporting occupational therapy practitioners working in the schools. This article as well as some of their other articles have been my go-to Resources. When it comes to thinking about what the next step in occupational therapy within the schools is. They have published articles about workload and caseloads and where we're at and maybe where we could be in the future. They've also looked at the three to one model, which some of you might know as being a model where you provide direct therapy services for three weeks and then you have that fourth week of the month to kind of do other things like maybe get into the classrooms to observe those students that you would regularly pull out and see also to maybe complete those evaluations maybe participate in some RTI or MTSS tiered intervention. So that is the type of thing that Seruya and Garfinkel have been pushing forward, almost kind of the next step for occupational therapy, how we can move from where we are today to where we can be in the future to support more students, more teachers with potential even less time. So I want to get into that. But first one last time, I want to give a huge shout-out to Francine Seruya and Mindy Garfinkel just for all the work that they have done for occupational therapy practitioners working in the schools. So let's go ahead and dive into some of the key terms some of the background information that this research article actually starts with. They identify a few things that we really need to know about in the first is caseload versus workload. They do define caseload as basically the students that are on your list of students that you have to serve. So the students that you serve, whether they're on an IEP or 504, the students that you are directly responsible for that is your caseload. We'll talk about the average caseload in a little bit. Now they define the workload as going beyond that more than just your caseload. But all the responsibilities and the time that those responsibilities take throughout your week or throughout your month, that's your workload. How many hours do you put toward RTI, toward driving, toward seeing the students on your caseload, toward maybe training teachers and working with staff, all of that is part of your workload. And as we get further into this study, you're going to see how many are using caseload but they're not using a workload approach. And when you're not using a workload approach that could potentially kind of skews what the numbers look like your caseload just simply doesn't tell the whole picture. And then they go on to talk about how this is really a paradigm shift. And switching from a caseload model to a workload model would in theory allow for occupational therapy providers to provide occupation-based interventions within the natural environments such as within the classroom. As you'll see in a little bit, most occupational therapists are using a pullout model, partially because that's what we have kind of schedule for us, you know, it's very easy to control a pullout model service, it's a little more difficult to control that push in. And therefore, it does take a little bit more time in order to actually prepare and complete that push-in model. In fact, we discussed this a little bit in the most recent episode, Episode 85, at OT School House podcast with Megan, right, we talked about how the struggles are so real when it comes to moving from that pullout model to more of a collaborative type of push-in model. And there are a lot of barriers involved in moving from that pullout, traditional pullout model to a push-in model. And one of those is that we are using a caseload-based model, that really just assumes that every student needs 30 minutes of services. And that's not always the case. And it does take a little bit more time when you have to plan to go into the classroom. And you have to figure out what time to go into the classroom. All those barriers that we talked about in episode 85, with Megan, are all relevant to what we're going to be talking about right here within episode 86. And moving from that caseload context to a workload approach. And then there's one last thing before we jump into our goals and hypothesis, and that is that the researchers know within their background of this article that while there are state guidelines, and even some district guidelines that have been published related to caseload and workload approaches, some states have even gone as far as putting a soft cap in place. But there have been no general standards implemented at the national level. And even at the state level, many of those guidelines, they're not law, and so they're not enforceable. And so you have districts kind of using them when possible feature with a cap, you know, a cap might be 55 kids, but then it says at the end of that when possible. Well, what does that mean? When possible? I mean, does that mean Oh, right. You know what, we have four therapists and we have 300. Kids? Sorry, it's not possible to keep your caseload at 55. So you all have to take on 70 kids? Well, no, that means you should be hiring someone, right? The district should be hiring. But because it's not a national law, or because it's not really enforced at even the state level, that isn't happening. And that is what is leading to some of our caseloads, continuously expanding, or maybe your caseload isn't growing, but your workload is growing, because you're getting more duties such as tiered intervention than your team wants you to be a part of. Or maybe you're being asked to be in more IEP meetings or longer IEP meetings. Well, that includes your workload, without actually increasing your caseload. Your caseload might still be 55 kids, but your workload, the time that you actually need to complete your job is growing. And so nothing related to national guidelines for that really exists. There are guidelines from AOTA and even ASHA, the American Speech and Hearing Association that say we should be moving to a workload approach. But again, they're just guidelines. There's nothing forcing that we do that. And there's nothing forcing the school districts to make us do that or allow us to do that. And so that brings us to our goals of this, this research and what the purpose of this research was by Seruya and Garfinkel, well, they wanted to reach out to occupational therapy practitioners working in the schools and find out what their caseloads were, and what activities were a part of their workloads. They didn't necessarily ask, Hey, how many hours of student direct therapy time do you have? But they did ask what do you have to do other than direct therapy time? And you know, documentation and evaluations writing up evals but also tiered intervention, all that is part of the workload. So they ask them what is a part of your workload? They also wanted to know the why behind who was using a case of the model and who was using a workload model. Why were therapists using the caseload model versus their workload model? Or vice versa? Why were they using a workload approach as opposed to a caseload model? So we'll talk about some of the data that came as a result of that. So then, let's have a look at the participants who completed the survey who participated in this. Well, there were actually 541 Occupational Therapy practitioners that started this survey. I am proud to say that I was one of them. Many of you probably also completed this. They did have therapists from all over the country participate in this of the 541 Occupational Therapy practitioners that started the survey 371 completed the survey. So what We kind of round-up, that's four out of six therapists that completed it. So that's about 66% of the therapists who started the survey also completed the survey. And in case you're wondering if the 541, occupational therapy practitioners that started the survey 479, were occupational therapists and 44 were occupational therapy assistants. There were a handful of others who are not US based, or they're not currently working, and they were excluded from the survey results. Demographics from this participation group showed that most of the therapists were working in a full-time job, meaning that they were working either 30 hours or more per week as an occupational therapist, going even a little deeper than those therapists who participated came from all over the country and had various levels of experience, if I remember, right, the most therapists came from the northeast, I think it was around 20%. And then about 20% also were within the one to five-year range. Within experience. However, there were therapists who had many more years of experience than those, who also participated in the study. So that covers the demographics of the participants. And of course, this is a survey so the word no interventions used, and the results are directly related to the survey conducted. So let's go ahead and take a look at the results. We're going to start with some key results here, and that is that therapists reported working in anywhere from one to 10 schools, and the average caseload was identified as 41-50 students, there's actually only one therapist, I think, that reported working at 10 schools, most of the therapists reported working in one to four schools. And despite having schools across the gamut from elementary to middle and high school, a majority of the therapist did work within the elementary range. Diving a little bit deeper into the caseload, I mentioned that the average caseload was 41 to 50 students. However, as we know, the average is not always what everyone has. So I want to share a little bit of the extreme. Looking at the graphs in the article, it's actually a little shocking, because you see that 10 therapists reported as having a caseload of greater than 120 kids. So 10 therapists, and more than 120 kids on their caseload, it does not identify as to whether or not they had an occupational therapy assistant, working to help them with that 120. But still, 120 is a lot, even if you do have an occupational therapy assistant working with you. Maybe if you have two or three OTAs working alongside you, then maybe that's a little bit more manageable. But that wasn't identified here. Going a little bit deeper, because we all know that 120 is a lot, but so is 80. And if we look at any other therapists who had 81 students or more on their caseload, 35 therapists or almost 9% of all respondents had 81 or more kids on their caseload. That's a lot of kids, I've been there, I've done that. That is a lot of kids, especially if you are trying to do that by yourself, it almost makes it impossible to see kids on a weekly basis, you can only see them on a console, maybe on a twice a month basis. Now, again, if you have an occupational therapy assistant, it does make it a little bit more manageable. But that is what was identified here in the research. Now with such a high caseload size, it's not difficult to understand this, but 60% of the surveyed therapist reported that their caseload was not manageable. And 55% of all of those who were surveyed noted that they were not always able to meet the mandated IEP minutes for the students on their caseload. That means that over half of us are not able to see the students that we need to see every week. That's pretty crazy. Because we are, that's our sole purpose. Even if you're going by a caseload number and you don't have any RTI going on on the side, your sole purpose of being on campus, is to evaluate students, and provide them the minutes of therapy that they need, right? That's like the basics of IDEA. And so to say that 55% of us are not even meeting the minutes that we are, "prescribing or recommending", if you want to say that, that's kind of a scary thought because we're saying these students need services, and we're not meeting those services. That's also a liability for the district. If parents knew that half of us were unable to see all of our students, can you imagine the uproar that would be happening among the parents, they'd be questioning whether or not their students actually getting the services that the occupational therapist recommended, and it might extend beyond occupational therapy might extend to speech therapy, physical therapy, adaptive physical education, who knows? Now getting beyond the average caseload, when asked to rate their most frequently used model of service delivery, 63 and a half of us occupational therapists who work in Schools rated non-integrated pullout as their most frequently used treatment model. The second most used model was integrated pushing services. So I think that was kind of expected. I think, at this point in 2021, where we're at or even 2019-2020, when this survey was conducted, I think that's the case most of us are using a pullout service as our primary model that we use as the students. Now, I do think that it is a bright point in the research though, that about 70% of therapists rated push in collaborative pushing services as being their most or second most used treatment model. That means that most of us are using a push-in service, in addition to a non-integrated pullout service, which is kind of cool, right? That means we're kind of choosing one of those two, as you get into collaboration, consultation, those numbers really start to drop, I have a lot of data. So I'm not going to go over all the data. But you can obviously check it out in your AJOT, the American Journal of Occupational Therapy, access that and you can find all the data, all the tables, and whatnot. Now, what we didn't get here that I would have liked to see is how many of those who are using a push-in model, or really any model for that case, felt comfortable using that model because I hear a lot from therapists on Instagram and in my email inbox that people aren't quite comfortable with that push and model. They don't know how to do that and be effective. They know how to go in and observe, but they don't necessarily know how to go in and actually provide therapy to the students within that context. So I would actually like to see another survey where we're able to see, do they feel comfortable with doing that. Now, another bright side to this research, in my opinion, was that about 50% of therapists reported being a part of 504 and servicing students that were on a 504 plan. I think that is awesome. I was actually a little surprised by how high that number was, I did not expect it to be at a 50% clip. Also, about 38% of therapists noted participating in some form of tiered intervention, which as you know, I'm a huge advocate for so that is also great to see. In the next section that we're about to discuss, I really consider this the bread and butter of this article. It just really shows where we're at and where we are going. And so about 46% of the therapist reported using some form of blended workload and caseload model, and 1/3 reported using only a caseload approach, about 20% noted using a workload-only approach. Now, this kind of didn't bother me. But I was a little left wanting more because I don't know what a blended program looks like. And I don't know that. Let's say Johnny over in San Demas. And Christine over in Glendora knows that their blended program looks the same. And so I think that if we're going to give an option of saying we use a blended approach, that needs to be a little bit more identified as to what that is because they kind of said that some therapists were using a blended approach, meaning that they had time for a workload, but they didn't really incorporate it. And it was, it was a little tricky to understand. But one thing that was very easy to understand is that only 1/5 20% of therapists had made the move to a full workload model. Not only that, but more than 60% of therapists reported attempting to make a shift to a workload model, but we're not successful. Despite that 77% of therapists reported being satisfied with their job and salary benefits and the therapist relationship with stakeholders was identified as the reason why therapists were satisfied with their job. So let's take a pause right there. Because I think that's a big number 60% of therapists have reported, hey, you know what, we want to make this shift to a workload. And we tried, we talked to our administrators, maybe we showed them some research, maybe you showed them this very article, but for whatever reason, the administrator said, No, we're not making the shift to a workload approach. Maybe you didn't even get that far. Maybe you just kind of wondered about it. And you're just like, Nope, I can't do it. There's no way the administration is going to go with this. I'm not going to go with it. I know that in the past, I have been just plain out shut down by an administrator saying No, I don't want to hear the term workload. We're not making the shift to a workload. We give you a caseload. You're expected to meet that caseload. Then they're also surprised when halfway through the year we're asking for help. So you know, it is hard, and I've been there done that. I've gotten through it with a few people and I've tried with others and I haven't gotten through it and I know many of you are experiencing that same exact thing. Now, as I kind of went on to say, it is nice to see that despite people still being on that caseload model 77% of therapists that reported here are happy with their job or generally satisfied with their job. And as I mentioned, the salary, the benefits, and therapist relationships with stakeholders, meaning like the teachers, administrators, were why therapists were satisfied. However, when they were asked to rank what would increase their job satisfaction. So even if you're happy, what would make you happier, or if you're not happy, what would make you happy, lower caseload numbers with the top selected option. So yes, people are happy because they have a decent salary, because they have good benefits, and they like who they work with. But they'd be even more satisfied if they had lower caseload numbers. And that information actually directly correlates with another article that I'm familiar with about where burnout is directly correlated with our workload. And the higher our workload, the more likely we are to be burnt out. But here in the schools, less than 20% of us are really even calculating our workload, because we're on a caseload model. And so we don't know what our workload is. Part of our role as an occupational therapy department is to really understand whether or not what we are doing is having an impact and who it's having an impact on, is what we are doing impacting student performance and increasing outcomes, or is it not? And also, what effect does it have on us and the entire district as a whole. Now, if we are only measuring by the number of students that we serve, that we're not measuring the impact that it has on the students, and if we're not measuring workload, then we don't know if what we're doing is actually effective with our time, maybe our time is going to IEPs for 18 hours a week. And is that really effective use of our time when we could be doing that with students. And so that's where a workload approach really can come into play because it can help us to evaluate our program internally. Likewise, if we think about that burnout rate, if we have high workloads, and we're getting burned out all the time, it's not only impacting us, but it's also impacting the district. It's really expensive for a district to hire a new occupational therapist when one leaves because they're burnt out. And so we can convey that to our administrators and say, hey, you know what, we can actually save money by decreasing our workload because that's going to save the district money in the long term because every year you're having to hire a new OT because the previous OT quit and was burned out and decided to go start a podcast or whatever it might be. So there is a reason to, to measure our workload. And it's not just for us, but it's for the entire district. Before we move into talking about some of the conclusions that the authors had related to this article, I want to let you in on some of the things that the researchers did not find because what they don't find is also just as important as what they do find the authors in this case, they tried to cross-reference some of the survey responses. And when they did that, it did not result in relationships developing between the use of a workload model and other factors such as the employment model region of the country and years of experience. I was kind of wondering if maybe the workload model would correlate with job satisfaction or even the caseload and they didn't provide that information within the survey. So I'm assuming when they made those cross-connections, nothing of significance popped up. Later in the article in the limitation section, they actually do mention that they wish they might have asked the questions a little bit differently and maybe formatted the questions a little bit because some of the questions did not lend themselves to being cross-referenced with another question. For instance, they did some ratings, right? Rate this from one to five or rate your top five reasons for being satisfied in your job. And some of those are hard to cross-reference to another question. And so that was one of the things that they think maybe they would do differently next time. And that leads us right to the author's conclusions. What did they take away from this? What do they want us to take away from this? Well, Seruya and Garfinkel, felt that OT showed that they have some control in the role, but primarily only during IEP meetings. They actually did ask a question, you know, do you feel like you have control in your role as an occupational therapist? And everyone said, Yes, or a large percentage of people said yes. But then when it came to moving to a workload, everyone said, Yeah, we tried, but it didn't work out. And so what they really gained from that was that yes, people feel occupational therapist, they feel like they have some, some authority when they're in an IEP, and they're providing the recommendation for goals and services. But outside of that IEP, they kind of feel like they don't have control, and they don't really have a role in the direction of the OT department, or the special education department as a whole, even potentially. Seruya and Garfinkel also noted that caseloads appear to be tied to job satisfaction, and because of this, they should be some form of effort from higher associations such as AOTA or maybe state organizations to advocate for national caseload or workload cap that may actually be enforced. As I mentioned earlier, we talked about this, they just were seeing that the caps that were put in place weren't really being enforced. And they thought maybe if it happens on a national level, that maybe it'd be a little bit easier to call out districts when they're not enforcing that cap. One of the barriers often identified for moving to a workload model from a caseload model is the funding. And they noted in their conclusions that therapists you know, if they are interacting, and they are participating in tiered interventions, such as RTI or MTS s, this could qualify a district for additional funding through IDE-IA of 2004. And going even further than that, this is my own part after I've learned a little bit from Dr. Bazyk, and so many others who are working in the role of the Every Student Succeeds Act, which didn't come out till 2015, and is still being a little interpreted to figure out how it really works. But maybe you would also get funding from ESSA, Every Student Succeeds Act, if you're doing more of those tiered interventions in the general education realm. Remember, IDEA is really specific to special education. But ESSA is really general, it's for all education, not special education. And so if we're supporting students, not in special education, then there are additional funding sources potentially, such as through grants from ESSA. And finally, what I think they felt like the largest outcome from this study is that therapists have a high level of interest in moving to a workload approach. Remember, 60% of therapists have tried and failed, and 20% have actually tried and made that switch to a workload model. That's 80% right there. And based on the high rate of therapists who have tried to make that shift, and were unsuccessful, they feel that more resources and training are needed to make that shift. And with that outcome, that is where I start to get really excited because I do see that happening, I do see the need to move from a caseload to a workload model. And I really have heard from you, the occupational therapist, that is working in your schools that you need help and that you want to make that shift. And so yeah, I'm just going to kind of forewarn you that the giveaway at the end of this and my announcement has something to do related to a caseload and workload shift. But before I get there, I do want to add that there were some limitations to this article. And the authors know that they pointed that out, they do have a limitation section, and the main flaw that they point out, and they knew it was that this was a researcher design study. And they knew that that could skew results. They did take measures to ensure the quality of the questions such as reaching out to colleagues before they sent it out to kind of have it proofread and check for understanding. But without using a standardized tool, there's always a question around validity and reliability. Likewise, they would like to see additional stakeholders such as parents, teachers, and administrators surveyed about similar topics, to compare that with the occupational therapist results. And now that brings us to my takeaways, which I'm kind of peppered a few in here and there. But I just first want to say I love what Seruya and Garfinkel have done here. There is something to be said about the perceptions of occupational therapists working in the schools, not just you know, how effective are we, but also what are our perceived notions about working in the schools. And what I'm hearing from all of you on Instagram and in my inbox is that you too are feeling overwhelmed by your caseload. And you want to know how you can change that you want to change and you want to know how to change. In fact, just this morning, I was messaging, an occupational therapist on Instagram. Hi, Alison, I know you listen to the podcast, and Alison and I were talking and she shared with me that she and nine other occupational therapy practitioners are responsible for more than 26 school districts and charter schools, herself has four different schools that she has to be a part of. Now four schools aren’t unheard of, but it's really difficult. I've worked at six different schools. Well, I had 12, we had two therapists, anyways, it's really hard to keep track of who everyone is, who the teachers are, who your kids are, even when you have so many schools that you're bouncing around from. And I think that by moving from a caseload approach to a workload approach, we'll start to see, you know, all that time that we spent driving, how can we decrease that time, all that time that we spend jumping around to an IEP, and then the therapist or sorry, not that therapist, the teacher or a parent isn't ready for that IEP, and we just wasted time. Now, a lot of that is changing, because we have zoom IEPs now. But still, there's a lot of things that go into a workload that just isn't accounted for in a caseload. And when you have a caseload consisting of four schools, six schools, one person 10 schools or more, that wears you down, and it's really hard to participate to your full extent, when you're trying to figure out what to do at four different school sites. I think there are two things that I can say here to kind of maybe help raise your spirits and the first is that you're not alone. 60% of therapists feel the same way according to this survey, they feel like they have too much on their plate. Remember, 55% of us can't even meet all the IEP minutes that we are responsible for every week for treatment minutes. So if you feel like you're struggling first and foremost, I want you to know that you're not alone. Right? We talked about earlier, 60% of therapists are feeling the same way according to this survey, we're feeling like we have more on our plate than we can manage. That's a lot. And 55% of us feel like we can't even meet the minutes that are required within our IEPs. That's a problem not just for us, but also for the district, as I mentioned earlier, right, the district has an obligation to meet whatever they are putting into the IEP. And if they don't, there are actual real significant outcomes that can come with that. And the districts can get penalized, right through either court or through funding, whatever it might be. So I do think that moving to a workload approach is actually a potential solution here. Likewise, another solution, I think, is that tiered intervention is something that we can provide to our schools that a lot of us are not yet providing. Only about 38% of therapists reported that they are using tiered intervention at their school, we're all using direct pullout, most of us are using pushing services. But very few of us are actually using a tiered intervention that could potentially prevent impairment or loss of function as Ida actually defines occupational therapy in Section 300, point 34, which can then potentially reduce the number of evaluations that we have to do and even lower our caseload, which ultimately, it doesn't necessarily lower our workload, but it allows us to put our time toward other aspects. Now, don't get me wrong, there will always be a need for individual occupational therapy services. I'm not saying that every student needs a push in occupational therapy service, there will be services that need to be in that pullout model. But we know that we can potentially help more kids through an MTSS model, and do that in less time than a pullout individual service. I really do wish that we had some sort of OT intervention research that showed how MTSS actually decreased the number of evaluations that were needed three years down the line or whatever it might be. Unfortunately, we don't have that maybe one of us listening out there, right now I myself can go back, get our doctorate or Ph.D. and do some research in that area. But it just isn't there. And, you know, RTI is picking up because there is research behind it. There's just not a lot of research related to RTI and occupational therapy. So that's one thing to keep in mind. And that brings me to my final takeaway, which is that we need to support each other in the shift from a caseload to a workload approach. I have been a little obsessed with Hamilton recently. And so the line that comes to my mind right now is that this is not a moment, it's a movement. And I think that's true. Right now we are seeing occupational therapists in the schools start to slowly move to that workload approach. And I think it's only going to compound and get more significant over time. And I really want to be there to support that. And that's why I am super excited today to announce that I am hosting a new course it is called Making the Shift: Caseload to Workload. And it really is a three-step process about helping you move from a caseload approach to a workload approach within your district, you yourself or you and your occupational therapy team will be able to go through this and I'm going to give you everything that you need in order to complete a time study to figure out what is going on with your time. And then analyze that and present it to your administrators in a way that hopefully, they can understand. Because we all know administrators think a little differently than we do as occupational therapists. And so I want to help you get into their brain a little bit, see what's important for them, and how we can come to some sort of an agreement that a workload approach is an approach that we need to move to in order to support our students, our teachers, our school and our community as a whole. Because it is not just for us, yes, it will benefit us as occupational therapists, but we want it to benefit everyone involved from the students all the way up to the superintendent of schools or even the county of education. We want to benefit everyone. I have been able to make the shift from a caseload approach to a workload approach. One and a half times in my career as a school-based OT. The first was for an entire small district though, I was able to move myself another occupational therapist and an occupational therapy assistant, we were all able to move to a workload approach and that allowed us to measure our time and it also allowed us to actually hire an additional occupational therapist when we were able to show that our time was really maxed out that we couldn't provide any more therapy service than where we were at. The other half-time. As I like to say that I did this was in my most recent occupational therapy job where I basically showed through a time study to my administrator, that I didn't have time to see all those students. And I was able to get help from a contractor. And then over time, we started to make more changes. Now, this was with an administrator who did not even want to hear the term workload. But through constant, I don't want to say pressuring or anything like that I didn't pressure. But I made my needs known through data, I use data to show that it was impossible to do my job. And by doing that, I was able to get the support that I needed. And that's why right now, I'm super excited to share that later this month in November of 2021, I am releasing my caseload to workload workshop making the shift. And I really just want to help you make that shift. There are so many of you out there that want to make the shift 60% have tried and have not been successful. Well, I want to take that 60% of you that want to do this, and I want to help you be successful. I want to help your district be successful. And so it is not quite ready yet. I will let you all know when it is. But right now, I want to give away access to the caseload to workload workshop for one lucky winner right now. And so all you have to do, yep, this is the giveaway point. If you fast-forward it, you're in the right spot. All you have to do is tag me in an Instagram story with you listening to this podcast. So either take a screenshot of your phone, or take a picture of your car with the OT School House podcast playing whatever it might be, and tag me in a story. And yeah, that's all you have to do. Just do that between now and Sunday, November 21. If it's November 22, or later, and you're just now hearing this, I'm so sorry. But I have to have an end to a giveaway at some point, right? It can't go on forever and ever and ever. So November 21 is the last day that you can enter to win the making the shift caseload to workload workshop by tagging me OT School House in an Instagram story. Okay, do that show me that you're listening to the OT School House podcast. And I will be happy to enter you in to be one of the potential winners for the giveaway. And with that, I'm going to say goodbye to episode 85 of the OT School House podcast. Thank you so much for being here. I always appreciate my time with you. Thank you for allowing me to be a part of your day. And I'm so excited to help you make the shift. Let's make the shift for the OTs make the shift for the students make the shift for the principal to teachers all the way up to the superintendent. Let's make that shift from a caseload model to a workload model to support everyone. I cannot thank you enough for listening. Have a great Thanksgiving. Have a great rest of your week. And I will see you back here for episode 86 Take care. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now head on over to otschoolhouse.com Until next time, class is dismissed. Jayson Davies Oh and one more thing if you just listen to this episode, and it is beyond November 2021. And you are super excited to make that shift from a caseload to a workload model. I want to help you go ahead and head on over to otschoolhouse.com/maketheshift to learn how you too can make the shift from a caseload to a workload model. See you over there. Bye Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 85: Facilitating Collaborative OT Services with Meghan Fox, OTR/L
Press play below to listen to the OT School House Podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! In this episode, I am bringing on Meghan Fox, OTR/L, from Wootherapy.com to talk about her transition from providing primarily pull-out OT services, to a more collaborative service approach. Meghan shares with us why she decided to make the move and what those collaborative services look like. Also, she gets very real with us and shares what is (and is not) working during the transition. There will always be students who need pull-out services, but there will also be students who learn best from in-class, contextually relevant services. So let's talk about how we do that. Listen in for more and check out the show notes at otschoolhouse.com/episode85 Links to Show References: Wootherapy.com Get Meghan’s free Desk Check! Episode Transcript Download or read a rough edit of this OT School House Podcast episode Amazing Narrator Hello and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school-based occupational therapy tips, interviews, and professional development. Now to get the conversation started, here is your host, Jayson Davies. Class is officially in session. Jayson Davies Hey there, welcome back to Episode 85 of the OT School House podcast. My name is Jayson Davies, thank you so much for being here with me today. Whether you're in your car, working out at the gym, wherever you might be. Thanks for joining in and listening to this episode of the OT School House podcast. Today we have joining us, Meghan Fox, she is an occupational therapist here in Southern California actually not too far from me. We'll talk about that during the episode. But yeah, I'm excited to have her many of you have probably already interacted in some form with Meghan on Instagram actually, that is her main platform where she does post under the name wootherapy. She is the brilliant mind behind wootherapy and the woo tape that she produces for her company wootherapy. We're not going to talk too much about the woo tape even though it is a fantastic product where you can actually it's taped that has handwriting lines on it. So you can rip off a piece of tape, add it to a piece of paper and you have a handwriting line. So we're not going to talk too much about that, you know, Meghan is just so humble, so kind. And we're not trying to sell anything, but I do want to mention it because it is such a great product. But what we are going to talk about today and I'm super excited, because we're going to be very open, very candid in this episode, and talk about how Meghan has started to shift from a pullout model of services more to a push in collaborative model service. And you know, this isn't something that happens overnight, you can't just flip a switch and turn all of your students from a pullout model into a pushing collaborative model. That's not how it works. But as you will hear from Meghan today, it does happen over time, and you can make a slow, steady shift, she is not to the point where she's at a full 100% of a collaboration pushing model. And you know what, she may never get there and that's okay. Most of us probably never will, because that wouldn't necessarily be ethical. Some kids do need a pullout model of service and that's okay. So without any further ado, let's go ahead and jump into my interview with Meghan Fox from wootherapy and talk about how she's making the shift from a pullout model to a collaborative model. I really do hope that you find our candid conversations really helpful within this interview. Hey, Meghan, welcome to the OT School House podcast. How are you doing this evening? Meghan Fox Hi, Jayson I am good. So happy to be here. I know. We have both been looking forward to this for a while. So excited to finally be on that OT School House. Jayson Davies Yeah, I'm really surprised it took us this long to get you on to the podcast. I mean, we've known each other for a little while. A few years now you live literally like, I mean if there wasn't hell in the way. Baseball? Not quite that far. But not that close. Yeah. But no, I'm so happy to have you here. I mean, you are the mastermind behind wootherapy and woo tape. Don't give me that. Look, you are a mastermind. You are awesome. Every OT, we are all awesome. So yeah, so we're going to talk a little bit about that. But first, I want to give you the opportunity to kind of share your story about how you fell into occupational therapy. And even more specifically, how you fell into school-based occupational therapy. Meghan Fox For sure. So I feel like I've heard this story a lot from other OTs I've heard on podcasts but it's so funny how it happens because I literally thought I was on the path to PT through college and then I get to my junior year and then they want me to take like quantum physics and like all these crazy science courses and I'm like, like pump the brakes, no not going there. And so it just kind of snowballed into talking to my advisor. What other you know, I've taken all these, I was a cornice major. So took all this human movement, all the anatomy physiology courses, like, what other realm or you know, road and path Should I go down? So she's like, oh, have you ever ever thought of occupational therapy? I'm like, No, what's that? Got more information? and funny story. She literally showed me the pamphlet of the top OT Schools and USC was on there. I'm like, I knew before college that I wanted to be out in California. So I'm like, Okay, done. Like, let's just put in the application. Hmm. Yeah, no, that's just another side story. But yeah, so that's kind of how I fell into it is, I wasn't up for taking all the coursework, not because I'm lazy, but just that wasn't my interest. If that wasn't my strength and my skill base come to find out and turns out occupational therapy is the most perfect fit for my creativity, my coping, you know, interaction with people. So, yeah, that's kind of how it happened. And then for as getting into school-based, so I ended up coming to USC, as you know, didn't even apply anywhere else should have, like, looked into it more, but I was kind of like one-track mind, I want to get out to California. So everything has worked out so far. But uh, so while I was there, I took the school-based course with Julie Bissell. And so which was great. And we've maintained a relationship still to this day. She's a great mentor to me. But what happened was, I did two years in a clinical-like sensory clinic on the west side of LA, and then decided I was going to move down to Orange County. So reached out to her for some, you know, I started applying for school-based jobs, and there was like, four available and I was like, What do you think of these? I, you know, I'm not so sure I'm familiar with these districts, and one was like, OCDE... Jayson Davies Orange County Department of Ed. Meghan Fox Yeah, sorry, jargon for those listeners don't know. And so she kind of steered me in a direction where she was collaborating with my current district to actually start an OT-PT department. They had been contracting for so many years, and not being able to keep reliable, consistent therapists in place for all the services that they were needing to provide. So she collaborated did the whole needs assessment, like, this is how many therapists you would need that this is what you would need to pay them, this is what some of your spaces should look like. And they bought, like all this equipment, it was really rad. She was very instrumental in developing our department, and then was very instrumental in helping me get the job because I didn't have any school-based experience. So she was kind of offering them, you know, my personal strengths. And, you know, so anyway, it worked out because, at the time, I think they hired in waves, and in my wave, they hired like, six, and I think I was the only one without school-based experience. So they really took a chance on me, which I'm grateful for. Because now being on some interview panels, it's like, oh, I don't know if I would take someone without experience and not disparage any listeners who are new to school-based or hoping to get into it. But it's, it's challenging. If you don't know, you know, you have to start somewhere. So obviously, Jayson Davies we actually do have a lot of people that listen to this podcast, specifically, because they think they're about to have an interview. And they know they need to learn some of the lingoes. And this is the perfect place for those people to be in my opinion, because we talked about IEPs. We talked about treatment. And we talked about the hard stuff about school-based OT, so I kind of want to lead you right into that you're kind of going there. But tell us about those first few years that first year, even in school-based OT what was it like and what did you learn? Meghan Fox Yeah, so I think I had an experience, unlike others, that I'm extremely grateful for. So because I didn't have any school-based experience, they placed me at two school sites where there was another therapist there. So we kind of I split the caseload at two sites, and another therapist was also there. So we overlapped at least one day where I could watch her treatment plan, I could watch her right IEPs, I think I sat in on a few IEPs that I wasn't a part of to understand, like, you know, kind of speak when spoken to like you know about you the areas that are relevant to you and just the dynamic of the team and how-to, we would have a lot of collaborative meetings with the whole IEP team prop you know, staffing is essentially before big meetings and stuff. So I got mentoring that I don't feel a lot of therapists get. And to me that made a lot of difference in my ability to then feel successful or confident to then keep going because I know school days can be grueling. For those that don't have any mentorship and they're just handed caseloads of 60 plus students, you know, plus, plus. So kind of piece of advice if you can, if there's anyone that you feel like you can trust or reach out to just say, hey, once a month, can I email you some questions and get some feedback, like any sort of opportunity to get some experience from someone else if you're new to school basis, kind of invaluable. Jayson Davies Yeah, and you know, I even found because I was in kind of that position at one point where there wasn't really any other OTs and I kind of reached out to other OTs that weren't in my district, but also to other speech therapists psychologists to, you know, they weren't OT they didn't know that side of it, potentially. But they knew about the IEP, and they knew how to get through tough IEPs and even a little bit that can help you with understanding IDEA and the laws specific to your state, just that kind of material that we don't get necessarily in school-based OT. What about actual therapy? You those first two years? What type of therapy did you actually provide? were you doing collaboration at that point? Or was it a lot of pullout pushing? What did that look like? Meghan Fox So it was a lot of pullouts because that's what I felt comfortable with. I didn't know the teachers, so I didn't know when was appropriate, or if it was okay for me to go into their classrooms. And, you know, it's taken many years for me there still find a rhythm with them, like, sometimes I'll schedule kids, and they're not even working remotely on something that's going to apply to my goals. And so it's just like an ebb and flow. And so yeah, those first few years, I was so comfortable with my clinical kind of experience. So I was pulling them into my room, like, so thankfully, I had a space where I could work with them. And I was kind of pulling a lot of that kind of treatment out and working handwriting in until all these different things. And I felt like I saw tons of progress. And at that time, because my district was transitioning from contracted therapists to district employed. Yeah, we saw, how do we put this kindly. We saw a lot of students getting services, maybe that didn't need the intensity, based on contractors aren't going to get paid unless they have students to service. And I'm saying, I'm trying to get it. Jayson Davies Yeah, no, no, let's have a conversation about that because I think it is a real conversation to be had. And I've seen it go both ways. You know, I've seen, I have worked with contracted therapists, I've been a contracted therapist. And personally, when I was a contracted therapist, the last thing I thought about was, I need to give this student more services so that I get more hours. However, that being said, when I was a contracted therapist, I was almost an in-house provider, because the entire every single person that worked at that district worked for the same contractor. And we were basically hourly employees at the school site. So it didn't matter whether or not we had 50 students on our caseload or 25 students on our caseload, for the most part, we were, it was like we were in the house. And I've seen other therapists too. I just don't think that they feel like they're personally doing that. But I can see maybe where people are independent contractors, they're their own business owners. And that does happen. And I could see that potentially being something that they think about, you know if I see the student three times a week, that's an extra two services to pick up as far as $50 an hour or whatever it might be. So I can see how that could work out. Meghan Fox Yeah. And so I think it was a combination of me just being really green and excited. And like, coming off that sensory type of intervention, that I saw a lot of progress. And then coupled with maybe the students were receiving more services than I thought. So I was able to just decrease the number of kids on my caseload because I felt like I was seeing progress where they were successful in their classroom environments. So So yeah, like I was saying a lot of, what I was doing at the time was pull out because I wasn't sure how to break the ice with the new teachers that, you know, I hadn't built a rapport with them. So a lot of them can be particular about other people coming into their classroom being more disruptive than helpful. So it took me a few years to find my groove with that, and, you know, build up the report. And it's hard for those that travel to different schools, there's not a lot of opportunities to really get to know the teachers on campus. So I would say if you are planted at a certain site, even if you're there for a full day, at the most and then you go somewhere else, do your best to go eat lunch in the lounge and be able to talk to teachers so that they can open up to you and feel comfortable letting you into their space. Jayson Davies Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's hard when you're at, especially if you're at like more than three sites, you know, you're not at a single site for more than two days a week. I mean, some of us are at a site for half a day, a week, or even half a day, a month for some people who are more in rural areas. And that's tough. And you literally just don't have the ability to sit in the lunchroom and say hello to people. And when it comes to scheduling you, you can't even take into account what's going on in the classroom. Because you can only be there for half a day. And you have to see those six kids while you're there for half that day. And the half that you're there, they're not even doing language arts, and so you can't go in and look at handwriting because that's just not what's going on. So it's tricky. But like Meghan said, Yeah, anyway that we can work to build that rapport. And so Meghan, those first two years, you said most of it was pulled out, was it one time a week, once every other week, for the most part, was a spread out different frequencies, or what? Meghan Fox I had a lot of kids that started at two times 45. And those sessions seem to last forever. Not to mention, many of them were Gen Ed kids that were out of their classrooms for that huge chunk of time. And so obviously, it took me time to learn about like, Oh, well, yeah, I guess if they are with me, they are missing a huge part of academic instruction. And, like, that part seemed obvious, but I was just doing what was on the legal paperwork, like, "Okay, this is the services that I was inherited". So yeah, over time, you know, we evened out the service minutes, and everything seemed more appropriate. Yeah. Jayson Davies And you said earlier, you said sensory? Did you have some training in sensory? And is that primarily what you were doing with the students that you were pulling out? was some, were you in like a sensory-motor lab? Or is that just one of the many things that you... Meghan Fox Yeah, I mean, I am CIP certified and trained. So I did that at the previous job that I was at for two years, just more strategies like, for me, a lot of positive results come from having a good rapport with the student. And so if I'm bringing them in there and setting up some cool obstacle course, and like in this corner, you have found a word in the word search. And then you get all the way over here, and you have to write a sentence about the word, you have to remember it the whole way, like those type of motor learning strategies, but I wasn't in a sensory lab later, when I transferred schools I have, I'm on a site that has something more like that. But at this particular school, where I started, it was just kind of a closet, if you will make the best of it. Jayson Davies Right, do with what we have. Absolutely. All right, well, let's go ahead and move on because you kind of already started to allude to it, and as people know because they clicked on the button to press play. We're talking about collaboration today. And so you have been in the schools for a little while. Do you mind sharing exactly a round number for how long you've been? Meghan Fox On my 12? school year? Yeah. Jayson Davies Okay. So 12 years in the schools, and we talked about how it was very tough to start, or just I'll put it this way, you started off with a lot of pull out sessions, some as many as twice a week for 45 minutes, which, I'm sure there are some people out there listening, like their heads exploding twice, times 45 minutes, like why, but let's move forward to now 12 years later, what do your services look like a lot more now? Meghan Fox Yeah, so I do have a range of needs and ages. So I'd say it's typically anywhere from one times 30 to two times 30. And then quite a bit of consultation, which we can get into later. But so those needs and populations range from like a couple, mild mod SDC classrooms, special day classes that are that I say, preschool age, and then up through Gen Ed as well. I'm kind of going out of order if you look at the continuum of restriction, but I'm just going by like my two primary sites, and then, at another site, I have three moderate-severe classrooms that I work with a lot. And so, what was the question? Jayson Davies We're talking about kind of what your services are looking at these days, maybe in fact, you can even kind of just off the top of your head, what percentage would you say or pull out? What percentage is collaboration? And maybe what percentage is more than consulting? Meghan Fox Yeah, so I would say right now, probably 50% is probably still on a pullout model where they're really needing a lot of direct instruction about what they're learning. But more recently, in the past few weeks, we've transitioned to probably about 25 percent push-in service. So I mean, just today alone I was we have a student that's been having enrollment problems. So the teachers like just for a few sessions, can we see what not transitioning him down the hall will look like. So he can make the most out of his classroom needs and his OT session. And sure enough, it was great, you know, so then I did it for another student in there. And so it's just continuing to see the benefits of the student not having to generalize those, you know, those skills, so, so I'd say about 50%, pull out, still 25% push in, and that number is going up, as you know, the weeks have gone, and then about 25% consult. Jayson Davies Okay. And so I want to pause here, then when I get this question a lot, and I find a way to answer it. And I think there is a right answer to this. How do you answer the question when someone asks you what is the difference between pushing into the classroom and a consult. Meghan Fox So for me pushing really is that collaboration where a teacher and or another staff member that you know, a lot of the classrooms I'm in have aids, where they're working in the near vicinity of what I'm doing with the child, whether most of the time it's with what they're already doing as a whole or a small group, a lot of my special ed kids work in small groups, and we go from center to center, but, versus a consult, I typically will do outside of the school hours or when the child's not there. So they're not seeing what I'm doing with the child, the language I'm using with them, the types of prompting I'm giving them, I've just gotten so much feedback on how helpful that is, so that when I'm not in there during my one or two times a week, that they're really able to implement a lot of those strategies because we've had time to share them too. Whereas, you know, if a student doesn't have a consult on their IEP, in addition to their direct service, a lot of times, there's no time or opportunity to communicate what I've done to those teachers, with those teachers about what I've done with the students and their sessions. So, Jayson Davies absolutely. And how would you go about making a determination for a student to receive that push-in collaboration type of service? Oftentimes, we have students that are a pullout model, how do you make that switch? How do you decide, you know what I want to try seeing the student in the classroom, instead of in a pull-up model, Meghan Fox A couple of different scenarios Go on, where I'm like, Yeah, I think they're ready for that, or no, this needs to happen because I'm actually not getting the results that I'm hoping for during our one-to-one pull-out session. So the first would be that they've pretty much mastered the skills that I'm working on with them in a one-to-one setting. So for instance, say a kid has a goal where they'll write a few sentences, maintaining the spacing between their words, and they can do that when there's not a noisy environment. You know, I'm next to them. So I'm actually a visual cue for them of what's expected. And so they've mastered that, but I can't, I can't in good faith report on that goal as being met, if I don't see that goal met within the classroom consistently. Without me there, you know, samples and all that. So I really, that's like my first cue to, yeah, let's go push in. And let's find a time that works when you're working on writing skills, and show me that you can actually do this in the classroom. When you have your peers around you when the teacher is giving instruction. Maybe when the kid next to you is fidgeting in their desk, can you modulate and tune out all those extraneous things and still execute the skill? successfully? So Jayson Davies Yeah, I 100% agree with that. Man, I've got so much going in my mind. I like I want to ask you so many questions, I want to make sure I get to all of them, but also ask them in a logical sequence. So with that collaboration, now, let's go beyond that to the next step, which is consultation potentially that's less restrictive, right? Because you're no longer even working directly with a student. How do you make that determination from whether it's a student that's on a pullout model or a push-in model? How do you make that jump to the consultation? Meghan Fox Yeah, so that'll come after I've, you know, pretty much ensured that they've been successful in generalizing the skills. You know, there can be a range of skills, it doesn't have to just be handwriting, but that they're being successful in their classroom. They're accessing everything they need, fairly independently, every kid requires a few prompts here and there, right? So, and then at that point, a few things could happen where, you know, I just want to ensure for an, you know, another cycle of an IEP that that's the academics are going to increase in the demands are gonna get harder, can he keep up with that? Or she, whatever, sometimes a parent wants to keep it, you know, I wasn't willing to let go or, you know, a lot of things happen, you legally have to. And for us, we have to do an assessment to discharge, yeah, all those things. But I think it's the right thing to do to keep on as a consult, especially for the transition to a new classroom. So that teacher knows, what are all the supports, you know, they can be outlined in an IEP accommodation page. But what does that look like in real-time? Are those you know, if he requires maybe he required he or she requires a checklist of some sort? You know, is that checklist physically attached to the IEP? Is that kid going to remember after a whole summer, how to implement all those things, so I think it's a nice want to call it a safety net, but just a nice transition to ensure that they're successful all along the way. Jayson Davies Yeah, and you know, that's funny with the OT School House podcast, obviously, I hear from therapists from all over the country. And, you know, the pullout model is pretty straightforward, right? We have a goal, we pull the student out, we work with them on a scale, hopefully, we see it generalized back into the classroom. The Push-in model gets a little bit different. Some people just sit by the student, and it might look like you're almost doing a pull-up model but inside the classroom. Other people are more collaborative, they get the aid or the teacher involved, kind of like what you were talking about. But when it comes to consults, there's a lot of difficulty there that I hear from school-based OTs, and they're done completely differently. You know, some people have goals, other people's don't have that other people don't have to have goals within their schools and districts, maybe they're tagged on a goal, maybe they're not tagged on a goal and, and they're just kind of there to check-in. Sometimes there's a very outlined detailed not rule that they have to follow up a structure that they have to follow. And it might be you know, what, they're incorporating a sensory plan of some sort. And they're making sure that the teacher is able, to implement that sensory plan. So consults are, they change, they have a big variety, from what I, from what I hear from everyone. I personally like to use consults, it's kind of like what you're alluding to, I think, is to make sure that all the accommodations that are in place are actually working, because it's one thing to say, Hey, here's an accommodation, but who's going to introduce that accommodation, who's going to let the child know that they even have access to that accommodation, let alone how to actually use the accommodation. So that's where I think that, that the consult model really, really comes into play. I don't know if you want to add... Meghan Fox No, I was just gonna say, in our district, specifically, we, if we are linked on a goal, we have to be on a service box. So like, we can't just recommend a consultation, if we are part of the success and execution of a specific goal, then we need to be direct service. I mean, that can look like one times 30 per month, you know, whatever. But we should be having some face-to-face time with the child to ensure some success, not just with the teacher. And then the second thing I wanted to say is when we write a consult, it's my preference and my department's preference that you specify like not just say, "consultation between teacher and OT", but to expand on that and say, "What are you specifically consulting for?" Because, like, if it's for consistent pencil grasp and spacing between words, or whatever it is, so that when that I get it all the time, I've had five this year, kids who moved from out of district and you're just given a new IEP, that therapist needs to know. I mean, it's so helpful to know just exactly what they're going to be going in to do. It saves a lot of time, you know, trying to figure everything out. So Jayson Davies yeah, yeah, I'm on the same page with you with trying to almost over-explain on the IEP exactly what's going on. Because you really do want the therapist that that student might move to and we never know when a student is going to move when they move, it would be nice to be able to pick up that IEP and kind of see at least what the OT was thinking. So yeah, over-explain that a little bit. Meghan Fox We got to work together as OTs to like, lessen our workload, because, you know, just make things clear for each other. Got Your Back. Jayson Davies Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. You kind of mentioned a grid box versus not a grid box when it comes to consultations. versus regular services. I, some people will know what that means as far as the grid box. I think most people will kind of get it. But I want to explain that a little bit further and go beyond that, why would a consult beyond or not beyond the grid box? Meghan Fox Okay, so basically, it's just a way that we differentiate the services. So a lot of times, you know, I have a, I have a lot of kids with visual impairments. So we have a visual teacher for the visually impaired, she rarely gives direct service, but she will consult with anyone on the team about what the needs of that child are. So because she's not working directly with the child, that she is not deemed a service provider, which would require minutes to interact with the student. What does that mean? Jayson Davies So that would be if it's on the grid box, then it is a service that's outlined as weekly, monthly, yearly, whatever services are outlined on Meghan Fox With directly working with the student. Jayson Davies Okay, and so then if they're not on the grid, explain that, Meghan Fox then, you know, they just changed us a few years ago, but then you're basically on accommodation, but on our new IEP forms, whatever, there are three different breakdowns. So I used to, if I was proposing a consult, it would just be basically an accommodation to the student's IEP. And that's where it would go under the accommodations. Now it's kind of differentiated as personnel supports. So it is technically still just an accommodation. But there wouldn't be direct, really working with the student on anything, it would be supporting the teacher and the classroom needs and implementing the other accommodations. Does that make sense? Jayson Davies All right, so I'm going to get on my soapbox. Because I have strong feelings about this. Because from my experiences is if it's not on the grid if it's not direct service, A) it either gets lost or B), when the student goes to a new school, they don't, doesn't hold the same weight as being on the grid. And I've had both of those happen. I've had a student come in who kind of had OT, but it wasn't well explained like we were talking a moment ago about it was kind of on there's consult, but it didn't really define what the consult was. And therefore the special education department actually didn't even tell me about the student. And so I didn't find out about the student till later. And now I'm trying to figure out okay, well, what have I missed. So that was an instance where the kid actually came into our school district. But I've also just been completely forgotten about when it comes to IEPs because the student again is not on the grid, they have a consult. I have them down on my caseload, my workload document. But I don't learn about the IEP till the day of or three days after the IEP was held, because I'm not on the grid. And so it almost bothers me that we're not putting consults on the grid, and be it right or wrong. I put my consults on the grid now for that reason for those two reasons, because I don't want to be forgotten. And I will, I will somehow figure out how to attach OT to a goal to make it so that I'm on board. But yeah, I know it happens again, that kind of goes back to what we started with this down this road is consults get done differently everywhere. pullout services look pretty similar no matter where you go. Consults and collaborations, they get a little, they get a little dicey everywhere. But yeah, so sorry, soapbox. Meghan Fox No, I agree with you. I hate getting left off and getting an email in the 11th hour saying, oh, we're having this try next week. Like, excuse me, like, so I get that frustration completely. So yeah, I think it makes sense in my mind when I'm just doing it within my district. But getting a kid and it's not clear. I don't know why. I know we never case carriers. But why is it so hard for a case carrier to look at? Any person that has access to them on whatever computerized? Yeah, the thing that you use? Jayson Davies Yeah. Oh, blame the IEP. The IEP system, it's their fault. Meghan Fox All right. Jayson Davies All right. All right. Well, let's hone in on the collaboration because I know that's kind of you even alluded to it, that you're kind of moving toward a lot more collaboration. You're slowly moving kids over to collaboration sounds like I'm assuming those are kids that were pulled out, you're slowly moving them into a collaboration? Meghan Fox And especially those that I have twice a week. I love one of each, you know, like, one week, one day focus on really instructing the skills that we're working on and the second day, you know, so there's a nice ebb and flow to generalizing, and it's just not all of a sudden I'm, you know, showing up or expecting them to execute something that they've only done in on one to one settings. So Jayson Davies I think you just answered the question that I had earlier that I forgot to ask. So you'll do two services, one will be a pull-out and one will be a push-in. Is that what you're saying? Meghan Fox Yeah. Jayson Davies And do you Okay, so I have another question then is, is that on the grid as two separate services? Or is it one service twice a week, in the class or twice a week? Meghan Fox I, the way I write it is two times 30 minutes. And then in the notes saying push in, or pull out based on student needs. Jayson Davies Okay, gotcha. I've done it both ways in the past. I've done what you just said. And then I've also had people ask me to actually break it up. And so it'll be OT on there twice. Usually, I don't do twice a week, usually, it's every other week, but I'll put twice a month, push in twice a month pull out. But it looks the same as far as Meghan Fox There are people that are particular about how they want things outlined. And so it's clear to everyone. Jayson Davies Right, and by the way, there are so many differences, and literally the districts that I've worked in, and the districts that Meghan works in are literally like two cities over. And so you can hear the differences that we have going on between the districts that we've worked for, and we are so close geographically, and so that's just how different the world is when it comes to IEPs and how things work. So all right, back to collaborations, what has facilitated your move toward this collaborative approach? What are some things that either you've done? Have you done any trainings or other professional development? Or are you just reading learning more, or what is facilitating your move to this collaborative approach? Meghan Fox So it started more with my special ed teachers that were really on board and eager to know what I was doing in my sessions, and how that they could implement that in their classroom. And so it just seemed like the obvious thing to just be in there when they're doing those types of activities, or, you know, sometimes it was as simple as telling the teacher that the student needs left-handed scissors, it's like because they're just little things that we pick up on. And unless they're explicitly told about it, they continue to do things, they're a very certain specific way for years and years and years. So it started off with literally just because my room is so close to my preschool teacher, my preschool special ed classes. And so it's just so easy to hear her see what they're doing in there and want to jump in. And they're doing so many crafts-type things at that age level, that it's so relevant to what I would be doing in a pullout session anyways. So to give them language and demonstration on how I kind of also coach the kids through some of these things. It's been so helpful to them. So I started there, and I'm slowly working into the gen ed population. Jayson Davies Awesome. Awesome. So it started really, it's the preschool. Is that like an It's a special education only preschool? Meghan Fox It's a... Well, yeah, so it's district-run kids students are on IEP is, but it's cool because both so it's to pretty much the same class, they just divide the students and they have reverse mainstreaming. So we have neighborhood buddies that come into the classroom, a couple of days a week so that those students have peer models and exposure. And then you know, it's great for those neighborhood peers to be involved in supporting the special ed kids. So that's really great program. Yeah. Jayson Davies So how is it going with moving into more Gen Ed, with the gen ed teachers and Gen Ed Students? Meghan Fox It's going well, it's a lot easier to do, the younger they are because they're kinda want to say this. Jayson Davies I think it's honestly to me, it's because it's play-based, it's a lot more play-based activities going on. And it leads to occupational therapy, like the activities that they're doing are just so much more similar to the activities that we might traditionally do in a small group pool Meghan Fox And those foundational handwriting skills of Okay, you start your letters at the top like that, just counting and those things that need the repetition that maybe a kindergarten teacher with 30 kids, that's not she's repeating Johnny sit down or, Sam, stop playing with that, you know, rather than being able to focus on the letter formation and all those things that you want to get really solid in the beginning, but I think the challenge with moving as you get a job, it's, the kid is more embarrassed or to you know, have an extra adult next to them in class or, again, they flip their schedules all the time, so they're not always working on something that's going to be related to what I need to address. So then I feel like, Oh, well, that was kind of a bummer of a session that I, you know, I didn't get done what I wanted to with the student. So that's pretty much it. And so that's kind of where I do, like a lot of my booth therapy stuff is, I want to give teacher gen ed teachers little snippets, little micro size, easily digestible information on how the kids’ desk should be set up, or quick tips to adjust a grass, you know, those types of things where it's short, as the training, I think can be valuable. But a lot of the times, you know, it's more of, I guess you could do a volunteer one, but sometimes I've been asked to speak at like staff meetings, and some of the teachers are just checked out. And I don't feel like it's a valuable use of everyone's time if they don't want to be there receiving the information. Plus, if it's too much info, are they gonna even remember half of it to go back and implement it? So that's where I've just found small bite-sized pieces of content are easy for them to be like, Oh, that makes sense. I can go try that with this kid. I, you know, it sends up a little flag-like, Oh, I have a kit, I know exactly who I can use this for. So, yeah. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Okay, I found that training really works for me when I'm able to get to just like, the kindergarten team of teachers, or the first-grade team of teachers, where I can sit down with them during their planning time. And just ask them, Hey, what's going on in your classroom? How can I help? And just let them vent? Almost let them share with me, what are they having? What behaviors? What are they saying? What? What weird pencil grasp? are they seeing what I mean? Who's the kid or what kids are using scissors to cut toward their body or like, and it just leads to, they have a desire to learn about whatever you have to give them at that point? Because they're the ones bringing the concern to you. And they actually want to hear an answer. So that's really helped for me is actually just going in and talking to the three Kinder teachers or the three first grade teachers or whatever. I found that to work out. Meghan Fox Well, that makes a lot of sense. And I like that as well. Because now that you're mentioning it, this was the first year that I reached out to. So my one of my school that's pretty small, but there are only 200 teachers and I just my caseload was a little smaller to start off with there. That's where I have the preschooler. So that caseload will build over the course of the school year. So because I was lowering the beginning, I was like, hey, like, I was super excited to try a new handwriting screener. So I did it with the whole class and like, to just educate them on what really the expectation is for a kindergartener, and, you know, kindergarteners, when they first come in can be a hot mess, I have one of my own, so I can speak freely on that. I think the expectation that the kinder teachers sometimes have is what the end of the year is going to look like. And you know, you those kids have 180 days to make that progress. So within the first few weeks of school, yeah, it might look kind of bad, but the barometer for what they should know is only at about, I use the handwriting without tears screener, and then part of Miss Jamie OTs new handwriting screener, she has out just with a starting spot assessment. And the handwriting without tears screener says like, at the first benchmark, they should only be about 61%. So most of the students were meeting that, and so well, we'll see where they go. So I have collaborated in those smaller settings. But those larger training, I haven't found to be as effective as I would like, for the time I put into them. Jayson Davies Yeah, yeah, they do require more time. And yeah, you're, you're more likely, it's kind of like the whole person on the side of the freeway who needs help, you know, if there's only one person going by that one person is likely to pull over and work with that, or help that person that has a flat tire. But if just cars are going by, the odds of one person stopping are slim or so nil because they think someone else is going to stop. And I think that is kind of the same thing when it comes to large training if you're trying to help everyone. Plus, it's just really hard to give a first-grade teacher and a fifth-grade teacher the same information and expect them to find both find it helpful. So there's some I really do think that that the way to go about it is to be a little bit more specific. Maybe you can do even to grades, kinder first, second and third, but to break it down a little bit. Okay, so what have been, what are three things that you have had to learn in order to make these collaborations with teachers successful? Meghan Fox Okay, so the first one is what I do for, you know, the rapport, making sure that they understand you and respect you. And that's the number one, the number two is like you suggested going in and letting them vent, hear their concerns. Like, what's the point of spouting off all your knowledge, if it's not what they're looking for? So really listening to them? And then the third, to be effective follow-up, Jayson Davies I just came up with a random number, if you have Meghan Fox no following up after you provide your suggestion, like, did what I say work? Like, how long did you try to implement it? You know, how much support did the student require? So and if that didn't work, let's try something also offering other strategies. So that follow-up pieces is super important because it's kind of pointless to offer a strategy, or multiple suggestions if you're not going to bother going back to find out if they worked? Jayson Davies Yeah. In your eyes, what has been one of the top struggles for making this work? Meghan Fox I think mostly the willingness of some of the students, Jayson Davies oh, the students Meghan Fox that are aging up the ones that I'm like, yeah, it's time to, like, get off this IEP. But like I said, I can't do that in good faith, unless I know you can generalize the skill within your classroom. And so they're more resistant to having that additional adult sitting nearby them or any of their friends knowing that I'm particularly there for them. That's kind of a roadblock for me. Jayson Davies What age do you start to see that at? Meghan Fox starts in about third grade? Jayson Davies Okay. Meghan Fox Definitely fourth and fifth. Third, you can sort of get away with it. Jayson Davies And so how do you deal with that? Or how do I mean, you just kind of sorry, kid, we need to, we need to get to this, where do you compromise? Or how do you? How does that go for you? Meghan Fox I pull them out, you know, after the fact or on our next session, maybe we don't push in that time that he pulls up. I mean, I don't really see too much, I guess I kind of does. But if they're leaving the classroom for something special or specific, anyways, then their friends know that they're doing something else. But, you know, I'll just be real with them most of my gen Ed. So this is related to Gen Ed kids, mostly that I'm getting pushed back my special ed kids that they like having Yeah, they do. I know. It's nice to feel loved. But you know, I can be real with them. Because I'll just tell them what the expectation is like you do this, for me show your teachers and your parents all the hard work we've done like, this doesn't have to be hard. And I, I can get off your back sooner than later if you execute. So kind of putting it more back on them if they don't want this, this lady around. Jayson Davies So for those when you go into the classroom, are you specifically working directly with that student? Do you sit near them? Do you try and hover around the classrooms? to kind of make it a little less obvious? Or? And what does that look like? Meghan Fox I guess it depends on what the assignment is that they're working on, and how much direct oversight that they're requiring. But I am trying to pull back a little bit because I'm trying to see what they can do independently. So yeah, I don't need to be exactly next to them. But I need to make sure that, you know, they have the accommodations that I've trained them to use out and available and they're implementing them. You know, I'm hoping I don't have to provide cues for them to pay attention and those types of things or follow along with what step the teachers are on. So, yeah. Jayson Davies Yeah, that makes sense. I want to ask you about goals because we are talking about collaboration, when it comes to if you know, you're going to be collaborating with a teacher, for a student, whether it's Gen Ed or special education. Do you write more collaborative-based goals? Or are you writing separate goals? OT goals, per se? Meghan Fox I would be a huge fan of writing collaborative goals. I just, we're not there yet. With all the teachers, and for some reason it comes down to Okay, like even when we're just staffing like, Okay, well, what goals are you going to write? And I'm like, Well, what, what is the student need to be doing in the class that they're not doing? And how can I support that is how I try to approach it. Um, but yeah, at this point, um, unfortunately, I feel like many of us are still writing our own goals. And I don't necessarily know that's what or think that's what's best for the child. Because if the teacher is also on there, then it gives them some accountability, shared responsibility to, you know, be working on those things. And that's where that push and collaborative collaborative model comes in. Because then the progress and the generalization is going to be greater. Jayson Davies Yeah, no, I completely agree. And it's tough and within the same school, you know, you'll have maybe one teacher who's all up for collaborative goals. And then the other two teachers that you work with primarily are like, Nope, I don't want to do it. And it really comes back down to what you're talking about earlier, that rapport building, oftentimes, you know, it's, it's not that they're against it, it's just that they're kind of, we all get set in our ways, you know, and it's, it's easier to continue down the path that we're on than it is to make a change. And it takes time, and it's hard, and I'm sorry, what's that? Meghan Fox Well, I was sorry to interrupt you, but I feel like that they feel like it's more work for them, you know, like, well, I'm on an OT goal on it's like, No, no, no, this is what the student needs to be doing in class. Yes, it's something that I'm maybe more of the expert in if you want to call it that. But I think we need to work together for them to achieve it. So it's kind of how you reframe what you're looking for, and when goals come up. But I do have some teachers that really dig their heels in and have the separate goals and like, even when you go around in an IEP meeting, and they're like, okay, would you please report on the goal, and I'm like, Okay, here we go again. Jayson Davies I'm right there with you. Meghan Fox My goals were. So Jayson Davies Yeah, and I can't remember who originally started doing this that I caught on with, but it's starting to reframe the idea of you know, what, it's not an OT goal. It's not a speech goal. It's John's goal, it is John's goal. And I'd rather have, you know, five collaborative goals that are going to be addressed, no matter where the student is, than 15 goals, where three of them are going to be addressed only in OT three are only going to be addressed to speech, and then five are going to be addressed in the classroom, and another one's going to be addressed may be in the cafeteria, you know, like what's, we want to help the student make progress. And the only way to do that is to incorporate the goals everywhere, doesn't matter where they are, we all need to be working on similar goals. But we all come from different backgrounds, different expertise. And we have a different way of helping the student to achieve those goals. And if we're lucky, we can share that knowledge with each other, so that we can all make progress from each other's specialties. So yeah, yeah, I know, it can be tricky, but I do think it is the right thing to be doing. And I know a lot of OTs are working on it. And yeah, and just continue on with it. If you're writing collaborative goals, keep going. Meghan Fox Rock on props. Jayson Davies Making this just gave you all right. Well, Meghan, you know, thank you so much for all this information, collaboration consultations, a little bit, pull-out model. Earlier, you mentioned some like mini trainings, is that something that's coming along with wootherapy? Or how's what's going on with wootherapy these days? Meghan Fox Oh, wootherapy. So there's OT brain, you know, there's lots going on out there all the time. As we spoke about before, pre-recording, I don't have a ton of time these days. So I'm working on scheduling more with every time I do have a course in mind that would be for teachers specifically. That's in the like, pre-development stage. So I'm excited about that. But I cannot give you an idea of a launch date. Jayson Davies No worries, no worries. But tell us about what you do have. I know you've got some cool stuff going on? Meghan Fox Yes. So obviously, I think I'm most known for woo tape. And that is my little handwriting, adaptive handwriting tape that helps put visual boundaries anywhere a child is needing to produce handwriting that gives them pretty much I see such a difference just in the sizing and the placement and other take some training like regular paper to work on the proportions. But I see almost an immediate difference when a kid has provided the appropriate visual boundary. So I've just gotten so much joy, seeing direct results, hearing about them from everyone who's used it, I bring it into the classroom every time I'm there because they're typically working in like a science notebook or you know, a Venn diagram that has just no nothing. Just you know, some circles fill in all the blanks, and obviously the kids on our caseload that doesn't work for them. So I created it for my OT brain, but it's really a tool for I'm hoping every classroom because that's where it needs to be. I mean, I think any accommodation needs to be in any place. But the child is required to execute those skills. So at home in the classroom, in OT, I think those need to be consistent but yes, I think, woo tape belongs in every classroom. So I'm working to share that more with teachers. And every time what else do we have going on? I don't know writing some more blog posts and hanging out on Instagram. That's where you'll find me at woo therapy. And I'm kind of embarrassed to say I joined tik tok just today. Oh, I joined tik tok. So I'm gonna see how back Jayson Davies I saw your dance moves. I saw your pencil-breaking dance. Meghan Fox No, the crown break the crown the Jayson Davies crown breaking Yeah, sorry, crown breaking, you got to break those crowns into smaller pieces Meghan Fox every time. Jayson Davies Yes, and you know, I really do like the woo tape for the same reason you just mentioned because it's so easy just to give it to a teacher. And you know, it's like here, here's some tape, this is the tape that your kids need as the right size. And now you have three or four different sizes, three or four or four different sizes. You know, like, you know, kindergarteners, he needs a different size and second graders, but teachers are always giving kids papers that don't have lines on them. And they're expecting them to write and then they write really big because they don't have guidelines on the paper. And then the next thing you know, they ran out of space and well might give them some lines. Yes, so I 100% agree, you know, just handing it to the teacher and showing it one time, you just have to show it to them one time. And then they see Wow, how big of a difference it makes and how easy it is to get that big difference. And what's cool about it too, is that I'm sure the kids love it. I mean, they enjoy it. I mean, it kind of looks like a road. So I'm sure the boys absolutely love that. And then you just kind of put it on there. And they have something, to write on. So yeah. And I have to say thank you also, Meghan, because you actually sponsored the back-to-school conference and gave out 200 rolls of the tape to the first 200 people that signed up for the conference. And then you also gave some away. So thank you so much for that. Meghan Fox Absolutely. Jayson Davies Yeah, so you know what I think we're we talked a lot today, we talked a lot about what services have looked like in the past when you first got started. And we talked about the transition a little bit to collaboration, consultation, and some of the struggles and some of the things that that we have to keep in mind because we know that it's going to be a barrier to building that rapport, especially when we're not on the campus all the time. But it's so important to build that rapport. And so thank you so much for sharing all the wins all the difficulties, all the struggles, because they are real, and how to move forward. I really appreciate that. Meghan Fox Absolutely. And just one last thing, like, I know that I haven't so easy, I won't say easy. Our jobs are very difficult. But I have a lot of things in place that many of the listeners do not. So I want to be available to those who are in, you know, more rural communities or multiple schools. And if they have any questions on how to navigate some of this, please reach out to me at wootherapy on Instagram is or wootherapy@gmail.com. if it's a longer thing you want to email me about so just as a support to newer therapists or those looking to dive more into a collaborative model. So... Jayson Davies absolutely, yeah. And I will be sure to link to your social and your website on the show notes. So everyone will have access to that right there on the show notes. Oh, yes. One more thing. Go for it. No... Meghan Fox No, Okay, I want everyone to get this desk check. Because this is the easiest thing I meant to mention that I give to all my teachers. So if you're just looking for a way to support some teachers, I have this great PDF, it's just like, quick how-to arrange desks and everything like that, that I just it's a kind of an icebreaker, if you will, like you could put it in teachers mailboxes as a way to say, Hey, I'm available as a resource on your campus if you need something. These are some simple strategies to help your classroom and your kids attend the best. So it's just called desk check. We'll put that in the show notes. I'll send you the link, Jayson. That's a really easy way. Jayson Davies Perfect. Well, thank you, Meghan. It's been a pleasure. And yeah, take care. We'll see you soon. Meghan Fox You're welcome. Thanks. Jayson Davies Bye, everyone. Alright, everyone. Thank you so much for sticking around all the way through to hear what Megan had to say about moving from a push-in model to more of a collaborative model for those who it's appropriate for, you know, this isn't designed to be a one size fits all model or approach. You know, we need to still see kids in a pull-up model. We'll never get to that 100% because it wouldn't be ethical. But it is something that many kids will benefit from and so we should start using it a little bit more frequently. Thank you again to Meghan for coming to the show. I really appreciate having her on. I really appreciate all the candid conversations that she was open to having during this episode. Really appreciate it. Be sure to check her out at wootherapy.com And also check out the show notes for all the things that we talked about today. She had a little checklist that she mentioned, and we'll be sure to add that to the show notes. All right. Take care everyone. Have a great rest of your week, and I'll see you next time. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now. Head on over to otschoolhouse.com. Until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 84 - Journal Club: OT in High School & Post-Secondary Transition Planning
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! "Help! I was just assigned to a high school & I have no idea what to do!!" Ever had that thought before? It is not uncommon for me to receive an email with something like that in my inbox. Now, I am no specialist in providing OT in high schools, but just like you, I can read some articles and listen to others who have done it before to learn from them. In this episode, I am sharing my experiences from working at the high school level and also what I learned from two recent articles about OTs providing Post Secondary Transitional (PSTP) Services. Press play above to listen, or find it on your favorite podcast app. Links to Show References: Doris Pierce, Amy Spence, Lisa Sakemiller & Celeste Roberts (2021) School-based Transition Readiness Services for Adolescents with Disabilities, Journal of Occupational Therapy, Schools, & Early Intervention, 14:2, 207-224, DOI: 10.1080/19411243.2020.1835601 Pierce D, Sakemiller L, Spence A, LoBianco T. Effectiveness of Transition Readiness Interventions by School-Based Occupational Therapy Personnel. OTJR: Occupation, Participation, and Health. 2020;40(1):27-35. doi:10.1177/1539449219850129 Episode Transcript Download or read a rough edit of this OT School House Podcast episode Jayson Davies Hello, and welcome back to the OT School House podcast for Episode 84 today, so happy to have you here. My name is Jayson Davies and I am a school-based occupational therapist in Southern California. One of the most common questions that I get on social media refers to high school. So today we are going to do just that. We're going to talk about high school. And I'm not talking about, you know, my terrifying and also glorious days in high school, with marching band and animation class and Spanish, all those things that man I just couldn't do today, I couldn't remember half of that stuff. But we're gonna talk about occupational therapy in high schools, also in middle schools because that's kind of that transition period into high school. Traditionally, most occupational therapists work in elementary schools. But one day, we often get the call and say, Hey, you know what, we have services that need to be provided at the high school, and I need you to provide those services. And we look like a deer in the headlights we don't know what to do. And I do get questions on Instagram and in my email box about Hey, what do you do with high school students? What do I do with high school students? How do I support these students? What is educational for high school students, and maybe what about transition or planning, we did have an episode earlier about transition planning with a special guest? But I do want to go a little bit deeper than that. Because, well, I'm not a specialist in high school services, I have provided services at a high school for a total of about two years at two different high schools. That is my total experience within the 10 years that I've been a school-based occupational therapist. So I am by far not a specialist in that area. But just like you, I do have the ability to look up research to find articles to support what I can do. And so that's what we are going to do in today's episode, we are going to dive into a little bit of research. I actually have two articles today that we're going to be discussing. They're both from the same core researchers, but they have different not opinions, but differing visions. I should even say that they do have similar visions. It's the same research, but it's pulled two different ways. And so I want to share this with you because they not only looked at the quantitative data as to whether or not the students made progress and what they did. But they also looked at the other side, the qualitative side of the occupational therapist who provided that service, what their perceptions were, how they experience the services that they provided to students. So let's go ahead and cue the intro. And when we come back, we're going to talk about high school and even those older middle school kids as they transition from high school and out into the real world. So enjoy the music. Stay tuned, and I will be right back. Amazing Narrator Hello, and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school-based occupational therapy, tips, interviews, and professional development. Now to get the conversation started. Here is your host, Jayson Davies. Class is officially in session. Jayson Davies All right. All right. All right. We are back like a Lincoln commercial from Matthew McConaughey. And we are ready to discuss High School and occupational therapy within the high school. I cannot believe I just use All right. All right, all right, in a podcast. Anyways, let's go ahead and get started. We have two articles that we are discussing today. The first is titled "School-based Transition Readiness Services for Adolescents with Disabilities", and the second is actually a very similar title, but it is the "Effectiveness of Transition Readiness Interventions by School-based Occupational Therapy Personnel". Both of these articles have the same primary researcher and the name of that researcher is Doris Pierce. And there are a few other researchers that collaborated with Doris on these articles. The first article is Doris Pierce, Amy Spence, Lisa Sakemiller, and Celeste Roberts. The second article is again, Doris Pierce, Lisa Sakemiller, and Amy Spence. But instead of one of the other therapists, we have Tony LoBianco that also helped out with that second article. These articles are relatively recent, they come from 2019 and 2021 of them come from the Journal of Occupational Therapy, Schools and Early Intervention and the other comes from the OTJ or Occupation, Participation and Health Journal. As I mentioned earlier, one of these is more of a quantitative article and the other is a qualitative article. The quantitative article looks to see if transitional services provided by an occupational therapist would be effective for students in high school, aged 14 to 16. The other article looked at that same exact that's same exact research, but from a different lens, they looked at a qualitative idea. And they actually spoke with the occupational therapist to see what their impact was and what their thoughts were about providing these services to transitional age students. And so we're going to talk a little bit about both, I am really hoping that I can eventually have doors or one of the other researchers on here to go more in-depth with these two articles. I think that'd be awesome. But for now, I really want to share with you what I learned from these articles, as well as some of my experiences from working in high school and how I participated as an OT within a high school setting. So I'm going to go ahead and actually start with sharing some of my experiences in high school. In fact, I don't think I've ever really had experiences in middle school, I've always done either elementary or high school. But with that said, my very first year as a school-based occupational therapist, and actually, as a contracted school-based occupational therapist, a high school was one of my assignments. And my goodness, I had no idea what to expect, and I had no idea what I was doing. Now looking back on that. I really did approach working with those students in high school. Well, actually, all my students at that time, from a very clinical based model, I had had volunteer experience in a clinic, I had also completed a level two build work at a CCS, which is a California Children's Services, which is very much a clinical model as well. And so when I got this job, I knew the thing to say, because people had coached me and what an IEP is. But, when it came to the treatment side of things, all I knew, was very much a clinical model. And I was very much working on performance skills as opposed to functional output for the students. In that sense, I would potentially go into the classroom and work on things like range of motion with students with severe disabilities and, and motor disorders. And I would work on simply pushing a button, but there was really no functional aspect to it. And I had no idea what I was doing. Fast forward about eight years, and I had another round of opportunities to work in high school, and man were things so different. Rather than working with them on the performance skills that they had probably been working on for 12, maybe as little as eight years with their occupational therapist, in K through eight, or even early intervention through eighth grade, I went a different route. I started to have conversations with the students with who I could have conversations, and ask them what was meaningful to them. What did they want to do after high school? How can I facilitate their ability to make that happen? The kids who were in RSP resource, and mostly in general education, for the most part of their day, really were able to tell me what their plans were after high school. And I was able to support that and support them in that opportunity. We talked about jobs, we talked about college, we talked about what might be needed in order to make those things happen. I had the opportunity to work with students that were both in that ninth grade through 12th grade, traditional high school age, but also students who were in post-high school classrooms from that 18 to 21-year-old range. And you know what, I found that they were so similar, especially those classrooms with students who had moderate to severe disabilities, they were no longer focusing on math skills, and history and science, they were now focusing on daily life skills and being able to eventually leave high school and be as independent as possible. And so you know what, that's what myself and my speech therapist that I worked with, there, really tried to do, rather than pulling students out to just working on some simple, meaningless handwriting that they might need to learn. We embedded ourselves into the classroom, where we could teach the aides, the teachers how to actually implement that in the classroom. Not only do we help the teachers and the aides, but we developed a rapport with every single student in that classroom. And they knew who we were. And as many of you know, especially if you have dealt with teenagers, maybe even teenagers of your own, that rapport is so important. They know when to call BS on you, right? And so you have to have that rapport with them. And you start to see where they are not functioning within their community, their community, is their classroom, the school, and the larger community, the city, the county, whatever it might be. And so that was how we saw our role was by helping them be a part of the community. So we got away from those performance tasks that they had been working on for so long with occupational therapy. And we really started to focus on how they can be independent at school and in the community. In regards to the term and idea of post-secondary transition planning or PSDP think I said that right? I had never even heard of this term when I had my first stint in high schools with students with disabilities and as an occupational therapist. I didn't know what a transition plan and I don't even remember hearing the word transition plan. When I was in that first, that first job, that was back in 2012-2013. Fast forward to 2000 and about 18-2019. At a new school asked to work at a high school, I definitely became more familiar with the transition plan. But never did anyone ever asked me to help out with it, I'd be in an IEP, and the teacher would kind of review what was on the transition plan what they had created for the transition plan. But it wasn't really something that I was included in. I guess I knew it existed. But I was not part of the transition plan is how I would best describe my role within the PSDP. So now I have done the research I have learned, and there is so much more that I believe we can do and that we should be doing. And it's really funny that we often are not included in a transition plan because ADL is is like one of the key points to a transition plan, making sure that students can actually live independently in their life skills. And if that's not OT, then I don't know what OT is, right. So I think it's almost comical that we are not embedded in that we should be. And that's going to bring us now back to our research articles that really share how we can and what we can do in order to be a part of that transition plan, and why OT being a part of the transition plan is truly effective. So let's go ahead and dive into a little bit about the articles. So Doris Pierce knew that IDEA mandated post-secondary transitional planning and services. But what they could not find was a lot of research, at least on the occupational therapy side, showing how OT is provided for these PSDP services and planning. And also whether or not that was effective, you know, if you have been in the high schools, you might know about the basics program or other programs that that teachers use in order to facilitate life skills and whatnot. But there isn't really anything out there for occupational therapists. And so they knew that IDEA use language similar to the language that we might use in our OTP at the board. You know, words and phrases like life skills, work skills, self-determination, are all words that are used within IDEA are phrases used within IDEA that we as occupational therapists know, that are meaningful in a patient's life or a student's life because that's what's in our occupational profile. We have research that shows that OT does help with life skills, work skills, and self-determination. And I know a lot of us to get frustrated by those who just think that we help people get jobs. But for these students who are in high school, looking to the future, that's exactly what we do for them. We use both occupations as a means and as an answer to help them to develop the skills that they need to be successful and whatever is meaningful to them, right? I get that we feel slighted when people think we just help people get jobs. But in a roundabout way, that is exactly what we do. And so Doris Pierce and the other researchers that were a part of this wanted to look into what a program might look like in the high school for Post Secondary Transition. And they also wanted to determine whether or not occupational therapy can be effective in helping students in their post-secondary transition planning. So what did they do then? Well, they found some OTs and they found some students and they got busy. They actually found 42 students to participate in this research study, along with 10, occupational therapists and four occupational therapy assistants. So a total of four Occupational Therapy - Occupational Therapy Assistant teams. Now, the students who were a part of this research study were adolescents with IEPs and disabilities who spent at least part of their day in general education. Surprisingly, the funding that they received required that the students did have some form of general education which was mandated by the state who helped to fund the study. They also required that the students had an IQ of 60 or greater. This led to them having a pretty diverse set of students. Some of the identified criteria on an IEP included Asperger's, autism, and learning disabilities. But no matter their identified disability on the IEP, they all spend at least part of their day within a general education classroom. So this is where things get a little interesting now because you know, when you're reading a journal article, you really want to know what the therapist actually did in order to see the progress that was made right? Well, that's not exactly what they did here. The researchers actually pointed out that they wanted this to be as realistic to occupational therapy in the schools as possible. So they actually didn't give the school-based occupational therapist a specific program, because they know that that's just not realistic for most school-based OTs, which I thought was absolutely amazing that they did that. And that they actually included that, because we all want to have this cookie-cutter program to implement. But that is not always the case. And so they actually specifically put it in the article that they didn't do that cookie-cutter program because they knew that therapists wouldn't be able to follow a cookie-cutter program. So instead, what they did was something more like what we might actually do. They had an annual meeting where the therapist got trained in some different ideas in different theories. And then they also had monthly meetings, like many of us also have with our OT team, if you have an OT team, or maybe you go into Facebook once a month to ask a question or whatever that might be. But they use monthly meetings, to then give more ideas, and to also collaborate and see what other therapists were doing, and get ideas and bounce those ideas off of each other, so that they could then use those ideas at their school. I found this very unique and really intriguing because that's what school-based OT actually looks like. It is not a perfect program. And even when we are given a program, we know that those programs don't typically go exactly as they say in the book, right, they have to be accommodated for and adapted in order to meet the needs of our students. So I really appreciated how they use this intervention. Now, because this was a post-secondary transitional planning and research project, they didn't use assessment tools that we might typically use, they weren't going to use the BOT, they weren't going to use the sensory processing measure, they weren't going to use the sipped, obviously, because the students are too old. But just because that was not what they were focusing on. So they ended up using two assessment tools that honestly I had never heard of. The first is the Scales of Independent Behavior Revised. And this was a self-report from the student. In most cases, they were able to get that self-report, although they did mention that in some instances, they had to get help from a teacher or a parent to fill that out. And the SIBR includes four scales, I guess you could call them the motor scale, the social interaction and communication scale, personal living skill, and community living skills. So that was the SIBR and actually, the SIBR had been used in the national longitudinal transition study, which is the largest national study for students going into the workforce from school, and that they use to track whether or not students with special needs are getting jobs at the same rates, which they're not, it's much lower as their typically developing peers. So they did use that same tool that was used in a very large study, which kind of shows that, you know, they, they're using something that is valid and reliable. The second tool that they use with the arcs, the ARCS self-determination scale, and was to assess self-determination, as it implies in the name of the assessment tool. So this was used, it wasn't something that had been used in the national longitudinal transition study, I don't believe, but it is something that gave them some information. Now, in the findings, they ended up finding that the arcs self-determination scale showed some improvement, but nothing that was significantly relevant during the course of the time. Now, something that I forgot to mention earlier is that students participated in this program for two full school years. So from August to June, and then August to June, again, the second year, they started right before they turned 15 for the most part right at 14. And they ended a little bit before they turned 16 because it was about an 18 month-long program. So now that you have that 18-month timeline from 14 to 15 and a half years in your head, let's talk a little bit about the SIBR results. On average students scored in a range that showed that they were at about a nine almost 10-year-old range at the onset of this research. So when they were about 14-14 and a half, they were scoring at the range of a nine to 10-year-old. By the end of the 18 months, almost two years of the study. They were now scoring at what a 14 and a quarter-year-old student would score. So they jumped up almost for almost five years, actually, in this time span of about a year and a half, almost two years. So while they were physically aged about 18 months, their scores on average on the SIBR increased so much that it was like they had gained more than four years of experience related to life skills. That's pretty awesome. That is showing that you know, these students who were on average behind, were able to make up ground by going through this program with occupational therapists. How cool is that? I think that deserves another Matthew McConaughey. All right, all right, all right. All right, for reals though I'm done with that. Anyways, that is really cool though. Doris Pierce and her team showed that therapy can make a huge difference. Over a course of about 18 months, they made almost four actually closer to five years worth of progress in the areas of motor skills, social interaction and communication, personal living, and community living, as shown on the scales of independent behavior revised, or the SIBR. Now, you may not be able to access the qualitative article, the school-based transitional readiness services for adolescents with disabilities article, because that is in the Journal of Occupational Therapy Schools and Early Intervention, which you don't get with your AOTA or NBCOT monthly or yearly dues. But you all should be able to get the other article, the more quantitative article which is titled, "Effectiveness of Transition Readiness Interventions by School-based Occupational Therapy Personnel", because that does come to us from the OTJR, Occupation Participation and Health Journal, which you do get access to if you are an AOTA member, so be sure to check that one out. And I do want to go just a little bit further because you're probably asking, you know, what did those OTs actually work on? From the qualitative article, we actually see that OTs spent a lot of time working on self-determination, groups and group projects, pre-vocational exploration, like what type of jobs are out there, and what jobs they might want. They also heavily relied on life skills, cooking was a big activity, because it was more easily graded than some of the other life skills. Social and communication skills were also a big area as studied organizational, and time management skills. Among those a few things that really stood out to me was the group projects, they really saw students as a group, not individually, they didn't meet with them individually for the actual assessment, and then also to kind of start to build that rapport. But they quickly turn those into groups. And they did long-term projects, these weren't just like, come to OT, we're going to do something for today. And the next week will be totally unrelated. Nothings were long-term. They had to plan this week, they had to plan next week. And then the week after that, they actually had to implement something. And then they had to go further. And further and further until they actually achieved whatever goals that they had actually set out for. The therapists were not the ones that were creating the long-term outcome goals for the students, the students were creating goals themselves. That's that self-determination, part, right? Teaching students that they can have their own ideas and their own goals that they are not just living to please the adults in their life, the therapist really wanted the students to have a sense of autonomy, and to understand their disability, and be aware of their strengths and their concerns and what they have access to as far as accommodations about the internet, how to use the internet to find things. But even going further than that, the students work together in some cases to create their own jobs. They actually created stores and collected money within the high school community, and then donated that money to a foundation, which they were actually then able to attend the foundation award ceremony and be recognized for their contribution. How awesome is that, that they had so much personal, personal investment into this and then also got to be rewarded for it. That is so much learning that can only be done through real occupations. We can't just work with a student one on one on an off-shoot day, I guess, you know, working on one skill, and then working on a new skill a week later and expecting that to make a change. These are real things real activities that the students are engaged in. And that I believe is what's leading to that such large impact that the research shows. So what can we do with this information? First and foremost, I would highly encourage you to go get access to at least one of these articles and read it for yourself. After that, you're going to take a time, take a moment to reflect on what your practice as a high school or even a middle school occupational therapist looks like and how you could potentially change things up over the next year or even two years. It does take time to change. But by reading this article and getting a piece of what is there, you can change the way that you are providing services to be more occupation-based to think about not just tomorrow with a student needs but think about what they need in four years, five years, six years, when they're no longer in school, perhaps. What is meaningful to that student trying to actually have conversations with students to determine what they want to do. Even high schoolers who give the most simple one-word basic answers when given a simple question, even they want to talk about themselves in a positive light, and they want to envision themselves outside of high school, they want to envision themselves succeeding in life. And so if you can give that opportunity to them to share with you what they want to do long term, you're going to learn so much about those students. I think another key aspect from this article that I learned is that groups are so important, and I knew this to some extent, but I think if you get that small group, as opposed to potentially even a whole classroom group, then within that small group, those students can really learn to, to learn from each other to feed off each other to help each other out. And that is then going to be shown to make difference when those students are in the larger picture. One of the things that they did within this, in this study, some of the therapists talked about talking about bullying and talking about social interactions. And, and at least one of the therapists actually uses video modeling. So, they recorded each other having social interactions, and then watch that back to see what they actually did when they were interacting with their peers. And they learned so much, you know, social communication is not all that you say, but also how you say it. And a lot of times you don't get to know what you're doing or what you're saying unless you listen back or look back on it. Trust me, I know from recording podcasts. But you know, that's just really awesome what they were able to do with this study, and I really cannot wait to see what they are able to do next. And Doris or anyone who was a part of this research, I would love to talk more to you about this. So please reach out if you're listening to this. Otherwise, everyone, I think we are done for today, I want to say thank you so much for listening to this. If you are a therapist that's about to start in high school or middle school, or maybe you've been in high school or middle school for a long period. I really hope that this does help. Please feel free to reach out to me on Instagram or via email at jayson@otschoolhouse.com and let me know what you think about this research. What did you learn from this research? And how might you make a difference in your provision of occupational therapy after hearing what we talked about today, I'd love to hear from you. So please, please, please go ahead and reach out anytime, anywhere. With that, I'm going to say goodbye to everyone. Take care and I will see you in Episode 85 of the OT School House podcast. Have a great rest of your week everyone take care. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now. Head on over to otschoolhouse.com until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 83: Evaluations vs. Screenings
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Welcome to the show notes for Episode 83 of the OT School House Podcast. In this episode, Jayson shares the difference between screenings and evaluations. Using AOTA documents, IDEA references, and court cases, we will discuss when it is and is not appropriate to use screenings in a school-based setting. We will also briefly discuss how to ensure that your using a top-down approach when completing evaluations. Links to Show References: Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, Subpart Occupational Therapy Practice Framework - 4th edition OT School House Evaluation Checklist Tereance D v. School Dist. of Philadelphia Learn more about the A-Z School-Based OT Course Episode Transcript Download or read a rough edit of this OT School House Podcast episode Amazing Narrator Hello and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school-based occupational therapy tips, interviews, and professional development. Now to get the conversation started, here's your host, Jayson Davies. Class is officially in session. Jayson Davies Hey there and welcome to Episode 83 of the OT School House podcast. Thank you so much for being here. For anyone who has never listened to an episode of the OT School House podcast, maybe you just saw something on Facebook about evaluations and screenings, and you hit play. I just want to thank you so much for being here and also introduce myself. My name is Jayson Davies, and I am an Occupational Therapist in Southern California. I'm the host of this podcast, the OT School House podcast, and I've been practicing as a school-based OT for about nine years now. And well in this episode, I am just super excited to get into the three keys to school-based occupational therapy screenings and evaluations. That's what we are going to talk about today. How screenings are similar, how they are different from evaluations, and also when to use a screening versus an evaluation. So we're going to talk about what IDEA says we're going to talk a little bit about what AOTA says about screenings and evaluations. And then we're going to kind of bring it all together and talk about when to use which one and how they can impact your practice as an occupational therapist working in the schools. All right. So real quickly, usually, this is the moment in the podcast where I get to introduce our guests. But I'm going to take this opportunity since it's just me and you today to share a little bit about myself. I am a school-based occupational therapist as I mentioned in Southern California. And I do have experience as both a contracted occupational therapist and in-house or district employee occupational therapist. In fact, recently, I also had an opportunity to work as an online contracted therapist for a teletherapy company, which was very interesting, I must say, personally, my preference is to work within a school district. I just feel like you have a better connection with all the people involved. The kids, the teachers, the administrators, people up above you, the speech therapist, the other occupational therapist in the district, I just really appreciate that setting. I'm also the creator and owner of otschoolhouse.com and School House education LLC, which is kind of the overarching company that runs OT School House. So at OT School House, we provide professional development opportunities through this podcast their conferences, through recorded CEU or professional development opportunities. And you can learn all about that at otschoolhouse.com and by listening to this podcast, really, this is really a place for school-based OTs to come to learn to be heard, I really like to interact with you. And with every single person that listens to this podcast. If you've ever sent me an email, if you've ever sent me a direct message on Instagram or Facebook, you know that I get back to you. It may be a week or two. But I will get back to you. It's something that I just believe in that we all need to communicate and get in touch. So feel free to hop on Instagram, if you're not driving, and send me a quick message saying “hello, let me know you're listening to Episode 83”. And just that, you're enjoying this, that you appreciate this, and that you want to learn more, you can even drop a message in there and say, Hey, Jayson, I'm really trying to do this at work. I'd really love a podcast about whatever that is that you're working on, I will definitely try to get something in here for you. So if you're here today, listening to this podcast, you saw the title, maybe you just listened to every podcast no matter what the title is. But this particular title, maybe you saw it and it said evaluations and screenings. Well, you're probably just like me, your school-based OT practitioner who wants to do right by the children and the students you serve. And by that I mean, you want to know when should I do an evaluation? Or when should I do a screening? What's the difference between the two? You're right on, you're in the right place. You might also be wondering, you know, how can I make my life as a school-based occupational therapist easier? I've heard of people using screenings. I've heard of people using the evaluations. But sometimes it seems like a screening can be an evaluation or an evaluation is a screening. How does that make my life easier if I screen? Or how does it make my life more difficult if I screen? Well, we're going to talk about that in a little bit. Okay. So, today, we have three overarching key points that we're going to go over. And those three, I'm going to lay them out right here so you know what to expect are, why screening is not an evaluation, how to use screenings as a means to reduce unnecessary evaluations and actually help more students. So how you can help more students even though you're actually going to be evaluating fewer students. And also how to how to produce effective evaluations to support individual students, we're going to go over that just a little bit as well. So we're gonna start with what I think most of you are very familiar with. And that's OT evaluation, not everyone's screens. But I think everyone does occupational therapy evaluations in the schools. I'd like to share with you a direct quote from the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, also known as IDEA. And well, this is talking about evaluation. So listen really quickly, each public agency must conduct a full and individual initial evaluation in accordance with other parts of IDEA before the initial provision of special education and related services to a child with a disability under this part. So basically, it's saying that we must conduct an evaluation, not screening and evaluation before the initial provision of special education and related services are provided. As an occupational therapist, we are a related service provider under IDEA. And so in order to provide a student with services, under an IEP as a related service, we must have an evaluation. If we are going to provide that service to the student, whether it be an individual or even a small group service, or even consultation on behalf of that specific student, we need to have an evaluation. The fourth and most recent edition of the occupational therapy practice framework published in Asia by AOTA, notes that the evaluation process is focused on finding out what the client wants and needs to do, determining what the client can do or has done, and identifying supports and barriers to health, well being and participation. Participation is the key word there because as school-based OTs, we are really focused on the student's ability to participate and access their curriculum. Within the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, they don't break down different evaluations like what an OT evaluation should look like, versus a speech evaluation, versus a psychoeducational evaluation. But they do list out in Section 300.304, that we must use a variety of assessment tools and strategies to gather relevant functional, developmental and academic information about the child, including information provided by the parent, that is a key one information provided by the parent, I recently went through a due process. And well, I'm not gonna lie with you, I'm not perfect, I omitted getting parent information. I might have called the parent and left a voicemail, but I never actually got the information that I should have gotten. Usually, I sent home a questionnaire at the very minimum or a Google form in this case, to be honest, I can't remember if I sent it out, but I did not get that information back. And that was something that, fortunately for me, and never went to due process. But that would have been something that I would have had to potentially explain in that due process. So be sure that you do get some parent information. It also requires within IDEA that we use more than one tool to determine the need for services. So we can't just use observations, we can't just use that parent information, we need to use multiple tools, that could be an observation in addition to a standardized assessment tool, but you still need to be sure to get that parent information. And then also laid out in Section 300.304 is actually that we just need to be at the goal that is actually laid out in IDEA. I thought that was almost a little silly that it had to be mentioned there. But it is there that we have to be ethical. While AOTA and the OTPS occupational therapy practice framework don't necessarily mention using a top-down evaluation procedure. I think that's something that we all learned in OT school is kind of starting with that very general top theme that concerns overarching concern, and working our way down. And so that is the evaluation process that I use as well. And what that kind of looks like is starting with that student's occupational profile, getting a good picture of them, their strengths, and their concerns. And then from there branching down to the embedded observations to actually get into the classroom and see or translate almost, if what you were told or what you found out by doing a review of historical records and talking to the parent, if what they told you, you can actually see within the classroom happening from there, going down a little bit further then we can pull out this year. And do some structured observations and our standardized assessments in a controlled environment. You can also within that controlled environment, and actually in the classroom, if you want it to is try some relevant trials, if you have the opportunity, you can say, Hey, we still have a few weeks before the IEP or before that assessments do, let's see what happens if I give that student a pencil grip. Or if I put some Thera band around the chair, or if I try one of those other strategies that can be implemented, right within the classroom, that's okay. And that can go into your evaluation. And maybe at the end of your evaluation, you find that those trials that you completed are actually enough for the student as possible. After you do all of that the profile, the observations, the assessments, any trials that you want to do, then you have to be sure to include two more things, your interpretations. What does everything that you did actually mean? This is really where some reports, I see fall apart, and I've been guilty of that, too. You know, we can't just summarize our findings, we need to actually interpret our findings. What did it mean that the students scored below average on this assessment, but average on this assessment? How does that impact the student's ability to complete classroom activities, that is all part of the evaluation, and then at the end is when we can summarize that up. And even if your district wants you to provide a very specific or general recommendation, some districts even want you to add goals into your evaluation. Again, that's up to the district, it is not required. So I do actually have a tool and I want to offer this to you, you can head over to otschoolhouse.com/checklist. And you will get the checklist that I use during my evaluations. And this is something that just helps you control or not control, I guess it helps you ensure that you are using that top-down approach. If you go down the list in order, you will be completing a top-down evaluation. So that's going to wrap up our discussion on evaluations. But now I would like to take a moment to talk about screening. So let's go ahead and jump into that. Now I want to start off this section of the podcast with a very clear statement. screenings are not evaluations. This is another quote that comes from IDEA section 300.302. The screening of a student by a teacher or specialist to determine appropriate instructional strategies for curriculum implementation shall not be considered to be an evaluation for eligibility for special education or, and related services. So it's saying that screening is not appropriate in order to qualify a student for eligibility for special education and or related services. So it's not exactly identifying what screening is here. But it's saying that screening is not enough. It does say that screening is really for determining appropriate instructional strategies for curriculum and implementation and around about way, again, this is section 300.302. If you'd like to listen, or sorry, not listen, look it up for yourself in IDEA. So this is kind of how I break down evaluations versus screenings, and evaluation is individualized, right, you're going to only look at one student, when you do an evaluation, you're not going to see three students and give them all the bot at the same time. That's not what we do. An evaluation is always individualized. The evaluation also will have implications for an IEP team right? After you complete your evaluation, you're going to go in and you're going to give a report to that IEP team, you're going to let them know what the strengths for the student are, what the weaknesses for the student are. And also you're going to present goals and whether or not you recommend services. It's also 100% required before the provision of related services. And occupational therapy, as it relates to IDEA is a related service. Now there are ways to provide services as an occupational therapist without going through IDEA. And that's where the education or sorry, Every Student Succeeds Act of 2015 comes into play. And that's kind of where we're going to go with the screenings. But for this, if you're going to provide services to a specific student, you're going to need that evaluation. Now, on the flip side, screenings do not have to be individualized. You can maybe not the bot but you can use some tool and provide that screening to an entire classroom or an entire group of kids. It is not necessarily individualized. Screenings are also used to determine appropriate instructional strategies. Whereas the evaluation is used to determine related services and goals. Screenings are used to determine appropriate instructional strategies. Those instructional strategies could be put in place by yourself alongside the teacher, or you can provide the teacher with recommended instructional strategies. And that teacher can then carry out those strategies, you are not providing an individualized strategy, you're providing strategies for the entire instruction. And finally, you can probably already assume this, but screenings do not result in the provision of related services. So now, if screenings don't lead to services, then why would we screen right? As an occupational therapist, you were hired by special education to evaluate and treat students and to go to their IEP is to write goals to write progress on the report. That's what you were hired to do, right. But if you can't do screenings, I shouldn't say if you can't do screenings, because everyone can do screenings. But that's what you're hired for. And so what does it mean to make that shift over to screening and why would we want to do that? Well, that brings us to the second part of this podcast, where screenings as a means to reduce unnecessary evaluations. And to help more students, you may have heard the term RTI, RTI, or MTSS, these are all multi-tiered levels of systems that we put in place to support students before they need special education, and occupational therapy, as specialized instructional support personnel under the Every Student Succeeds Act of 2015. We can absolutely 100% partake in that RTI, which stands for response to instruction and intervention, RTI, or MTSS, which is multi sorry, got to make sure I get that right, multi-tiered support systems. We can participate in those different systems, whether they call it RTI, MTSS, or just multi tiered system. So just to break down RTI, a little bit, there are three tiers, you have tier one, which is strategies for all, a tier-one strategy would be something like, using appropriate posture, we know that's going to help every single person in the classroom, including the teacher, so if we can train teachers about posture, then they're going to translate that into their students, everyone's going to have better posture, therefore, they're going to have more success, or at least that's in theory, right? Well, maybe you provide those postural strategies, and I'm just using an example that doesn't have to be about posture. But maybe you do share these postural strategies with the teachers, the teachers, in turn, do share that with all of their students. Well, you just helped an entire school at that point. Maybe the more if you presented this at a district level? Well, now, say there's a group of students that don't quite or maybe the entire classroom, one of those three classrooms that you presented to, they still need a little bit more support. Well, that's when you get into a tier-two strategy, where you are really providing that it's not individualized, but it's more specific to that entire community of the classroom, the classroom as a community. So now maybe teacher number two comes back to you and says, you know, what, my students are still kind of fidgety. And, you know, it's just I need a little bit more, would you mind coming into my classroom, just observing the student as a whole, not one particular student, but just looking at the student as well, or looking at the community that is the classroom and providing some potential strategies that I could use. So that would be more of tier two, a tier two strategy under RTI or MTSS. Now, tier three is where we get a little bit closer to that line of what is individual services and what is still under that RTI, what's special education versus what is RTI? And some districts will even identify tier three as being a referral to special education. I don't think that's quite right. In my opinion, tier three is for students that are kind of on a student support team sometimes called an SST. It's almost like a mini IEP, except it's really just a consultation between the administrator, the teacher, the principal, and maybe yourself if you're involved. There's not going to be special education teachers involved at this point, but you can still come in and provide general strategies, not student-specific strategies, General strategies. Think about a teacher who's googling for students. is kicking legs on under the desk? sure that student is or that teacher is thinking about a particular student. But you don't need to know all the information in order to answer that Google question, right? You have some general strategies that may support that student without knowing any more about that student. Maybe the teacher tried the strategies that you gave to the entire district, that just the strategies that you gave to her as a classroom. But there are still, maybe two or three kids in her classroom that are still fidgeting without doing any evaluation. Again, you can provide some very general strategies. RTI, two, aims to prevent students from requiring special education through this tiered prevention. So by providing those tier-one strategies, we're helping the entire school, maybe even the entire district. at tier two, I like to think of it as helping either a specific grade level, maybe three teachers that are all third-grade teachers, or at the individual classroom level. When you get to tier three, you may be talking about an individual student, but you're still providing general strategies as opposed to student-specific strategies. So now, where do screenings fall into the whole RTI or MTSS process? Well, I kind of alluded to it a little bit earlier when I talked about tier two. And that's where I feel screenings can have the most impact when it comes to supporting classrooms and supporting students conducting a screening for an entire classroom. Remember, tier two would be an entire classroom, or maybe a group within a classroom, you can then lead to that collaborative intervention with that teacher. So let me lay out what that might look like. We'll get away from the postural example. And we're actually going to move now to a handwriting example, mostly because I feel like this is the area that it's easiest to transition to, to start screening and start that RTI process. It is something that all the teachers recognize us for, and therefore we can use that to start the process. So let's say you just provided some general handwriting strategies through an in-service for all of the kindergarteners and first-grade teachers. Well, now, teacher number two in the first grade comes to you and says, Hey, Mr. or Mrs. so and so I loved those strategies that you gave me, some of them are working. But there's still this going on, maybe it has to do with students writing, like literally on the line versus on top of the line, maybe she has several students that are writing letters. And they don't understand the big small talk, where you place letters either on the line to the top of the line, and so forth, right ground, grass, sky, and dirt letters type of thing. Well, now you can then work with that teacher and maybe set up a time for three weeks in a row where you can go in and co-teach that. And you can bring in your materials, you can bring in your sky grass, dirt, paper, 30 copies of it, and do it with all the students, as opposed to pulling out just that one student that might have a little bit of trouble with it. You also don't have to take the time to evaluate that one, maybe three students that are having trouble, you can go in and support the entire classroom. So odds are that first-grade teacher, especially if it's a kindergarten, kindergarten teacher, they are going to be working on some sort of handwriting. And maybe it's not directly handwriting, if it's in first grade, maybe they're working on sentences. But that doesn't mean that you still can't be a part of that lesson, and kind of focus on the actual act of handwriting while they're working on the act of the grammar of putting a sentence together per se. So that screening can then lead to some intervention within the classroom. Now that I've discussed a little bit about how that screening can help you, let's talk about the steps to a screening. There are three steps that I'm going to lay out here first, and the first one is to determine the need through teacher feedback. So obviously, in the example that I use about handwriting, the teacher came to you and she said or he said, Hey, I have some difficulties with my students writing on the line. Their kind of their G's are on top of the lines, their Q's are hanging down below the line, whatever it might be, that she's giving you or he's giving you some general feedback. Based upon that feedback, you're now going to go into the classroom and either observe the classroom from afar, you're not looking at any one child in specific but you are there to just observe the general setting. However, if you're going to be screening for handwriting concerns, it may actually be more beneficial for you to use a screening tool such as maybe the print tool or the etch, which is the evaluation tool for children's handwriting if I got that, right, etc, ah, and you can go in and it's not an evaluation, because you're going to give it to the entire class at once. The print tool is a pretty simple tool. However, if you want to go even more simple than that, you can have all the students copy a sentence and write a sentence on a piece of paper, they don't need to put their name on it, and they can turn it into you. Now you can look at those 30 papers or 25 papers, whatever it might be. And based upon those, you can develop an idea of what supports those students need, then that can lead to your intervention, which leads to number three, which is collaborating with the teacher to determine potential solutions. So, meet with the teacher after school that same day or that same week, at some point, and say, Hey, this is what I saw based upon your students turning in those papers to me. And you know, I don't know which student had these difficulties. But I saw about five students that had this going on, I saw a few students that had this going on, here's how I can support you, do you have any lessons coming up, where you're going to work on writing, is there a time that I can push in and work with you a little bit, I would love to teach you so that you can, in turn, continue to support them throughout the rest of the school year. So that is one of the potential outcomes of screening, maybe you do end up collaborating with the teacher. But there are also two other potential outcomes from a screening. One is very simple and is literally just providing strategies. Maybe you went in, you observe some postural instability, and you said, Hey, a few things that might work, I can provide you with these tools, and you can easily use them within your classroom. Or maybe I can provide you with some handouts that you can post up and explain to your kids once a week and remind them about postural stability and being able to touch the floor, or the ability to stand while doing work. Instead of sitting if they don't feel comfortable, whatever it might be, there are so many different options to there are so many different solutions to a number of difficulties, and you can work to provide that for your teacher. And then your teacher can implement that. The other potential outcome of screening is a referral. And I know some people will use a screening. And when I say people, some occupational therapists will use screening to determine if an evaluation is necessary. That is not what I'm saying here. By all means, and I will make this as clear as I can, you should not be screening an individual student. As soon as that student is told to you that there is a concern by name and you know that student by name, that is essentially them saying an evaluation is needed, the bar is very low when it comes to when a new evaluation is needed. The reason that I am so persistent on this about screening and not being an evaluation on vice versa. And not using screening as a way to determine whether or not you should complete an evaluation is because there have been lawsuits where that has turned out poorly, where someone completed a screening, but then did not do the evaluation based upon that screening. And so I'm going to share that lawsuit with you in just a few minutes. But I want to continue on first and kind of go through. It'll make more sense if we go through everything first and then go for that lawsuit. So bear with me. However, in the sense that I was talking about a screening where you are determining instructional strategies, there is the possibility that while you are screening the entire classroom, that you do see a student that you really believe needs a referral. And when that happens, you need to work within your school's guidelines for referring a student, you probably need to work with that general education teacher in order to refer that student. After all, it is really the general education teacher that has that concern. Or even if you're in a special education classroom, that special education teacher that has that concern, whether they have an IEP or not, you can still be a part of that referral process. Maybe you're in the classroom and you see a student that has no services at all, no IEP at all. But you see something that is concerning, you probably want to start with a psychoeducational evaluation, or perhaps a speech evaluation. Because those services are kind of the kickoff to special education. Speech can be a standalone service. Occupational Therapy, in most states, cannot be a standalone service. If you can be a standalone service, then maybe you could refer the student to yourself. However, you probably want to start with whatever your district has outlined. When it comes to referrals. The second example is if the student already does have an IEP, maybe the student already is identified as having an IEP and needing additional supports. Well, in that case, maybe you could go to the case carrier, and let them know what you saw and why you think the student may need a referral to yourself or to another special education provider. So to kind of summarize those three outcomes of a screening or the potential outcomes of screening, it could be as simple as providing strategies to a teacher, you may provide strategies and then also help in the implementation of those strategies through a collaboration or co-teaching model. Or you may also decide to submit a referral for a formal evaluation of a student. And again, work with the teacher to do that, it should not just come from you, you should have that discussion with the teacher to make that referral. Just like any occupational therapist, when there is research about something that we're discussing, I want to share it with you. And there are two sides to the research here because RTI MTSS tiered supports are relatively new as his screening when it comes to an occupational therapist, the SSA Every Student Succeeds Act that describes us as specialized instructional support personnel was only passed in 2015. There just isn't a lot of research. In fact, I couldn't find any research related to occupational therapists providing screenings within the school system and the effectiveness of doing that. However, there are many research studies out there about the effectiveness of handwriting programs for an entire classroom or for many at-risk kindergarteners, for instance, the journal club that we had just on episode 82 of the podcast, where Dr. Beth and Dr. Sheryl came on and described how they use the size matters handwriting program to assist several students, not just a single student who had an IEP, they saw all students or not all but a large group of students of kindergarteners that were at risk. At risk, not necessarily meaning that they had an IEP. In that case, it could be called a tier two intervention that the occupational therapists were seeing students not with an IEP, but in a group because of their concerns based upon a teacher screening. Beyond the research, I also have an actual court case that I'd like to share with you. And this is actually the court case titled Terrence Dee versus School District of Philadelphia, and it comes to us from 2008. So it is 12, almost 13 years ago, probably. But it does kind of explain why we need to be sure that we are using screening and an evaluation appropriately. Because if you use one when maybe you should have used the other than, well, it might come back to haunt you, like it did in this case. The lawyers for Terrence Dee argued and correctly I might add, they argued that Terrence actually was not fully evaluated by the occupational therapist, when the district said that they were completing an evaluation. Instead, they quoted that the Occupational Therapist performed only a cursory OT screen and failed entirely to assess tolerances need in the sensory area. Now I know everyone has their own opinion on sensory in the schools or whatnot. But if you say you're going to assess something, then you need to assess it. Or if there's an area of concern within that area of sensory, you need to assess it. Right. So what happened then, based upon those findings that the occupational therapists never fully evaluated, Terrance, well, turns out turns did eventually qualify for Occupational Therapy through a full evaluation at a later time, the court ruled that if any evaluation would have been conducted earlier, a full comprehensive evaluation rather than an "OT screening", then Terrance would have had occupational therapy services potentially for a much longer time and at an earlier period. So the Occupational Therapist did that cursory screen, it went to court at some point and well, the school district did actually lose that argument. And compensatory strategies were required to be provided. The lawsuit doesn't actually state that OT services were part of those compensatory services. But it also doesn't say what services were required. So I'm going to assume that OT was part of that based upon the outcome, however, I could potentially be wrong, so take that with a grain of salt. The court also found that the district actually violated the Americans with Disabilities Act by withholding public services because of this whole debacle for lack of a better term, I guess I can say. So with that, I think I gave you some evidence that shows Yes, we can be efficient within the RTI setting. I think I also shared with you some decent points as to why screening is not an evaluation. And I laid out a little bit about what an evaluation should look like and what screening should look like. Remember, you can get that checklist that I use at otschoolhouse.com/checklist. I'll also make sure I put a link to that in the show notes for this episode. But I just wanted to make sure that you have this overview of screenings versus evaluation and know the difference between the two. I think sometimes those words, those actions of screening versus an evaluation can get misused and confused. And a speech therapist might use one and you might use another and some people might kind of say, well, the speech therapist said screening, you said evaluation, but they sound the same. Well, now this can help you to identify maybe some common language to be used within your school, or even at your district. And you can also use this to share with your administrator the next time they ask you to do a screening and ask them to really define what they mean by screening. Are they really asking you for any evaluation? Or are they asking you to complete screening, all very important things that need to be identified within your role as an occupational therapist in the schools? Alright, well, that is going to wrap up our discussion on evaluations and screenings, when to use them when not to use them and how they can support you. Before I let you go, I do actually want to let you all in on. A lot of this information actually comes directly from my course, the A to Z school-based OT course, the A to Z school-based OT course really is the perfect course for anyone that is either currently or transitioning to a school-based occupational therapy job in the course we really start from scratch and work our way all the way up within the school-based OT realm. We start with understanding what school-based OT the role of school-based OT is in schools, we then move on to the referral process and RTI strategies that you can put in place. I even provide an entire slideshow for you to complete as an in-service for your teachers. I mean, I have a lot of resources in there, so be sure to check it out. From there, we actually talk about evaluations, I give you templates for evaluations. And then we go into actually dealing with IEPs, treatment planning, and even how to exit a student from occupational therapy. That is all included in the A to Z school-based OT course, which you can learn more about at otschoolhouse.com/A-Z. I will definitely put a link to that in the show notes as well. Until next time, take care, and yeah, just enjoy your week. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now head on over to otschoolhouse.com until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 80: Ergonomics In and Out of School with Kirsten Beshay, OTD, MA, OTR/L
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Welcome to the show notes for Episode 80 of the OT School House Podcast. We are kicking off the 2021-22 school year with the perfect topic - Ergonomics. For the better part of 18 months, many of us have been working from home and students have been learning from their couches, beds, & Kitchen table. If you are lucky, you have had a desk in your home to work from. Now, Most of us are heading back into the school buildings and that is going to be a big change on our bodies. So today I am bringing on School-Based OT and Ergonomic Specialist, Kirsten Beshay, to talk a little bit about how ergonomics has and will continue to impact us, the teachers in our schools, and the kids we serve. In this episode, we dive into both her experiences as an ergonomic specialist in the private sector as well as her experiences in the schools. Links to Show References: Kirsten.beshay.net/schoolergo Follow Kirsten on Instagram https://www.aota.org/Conference-Events/Backpack-Safety-Awareness-Day/Handouts.aspx REBA assessment RULA assessment Teaching from Home Ergo Brochure Learning from Home Ergo Brochure Article References: Jacobs, K. (Ed.). (2008) Ergonomics for therapists. Mosby Elsevier. American Occupational Therapy Association. (2020). 2019 workforce & salary survey. Fisher, T. (2019). Occupational therapy’s work and industry area of practice: Content in entry-level professional occupational therapy curricula: A survey. The Open Journal of Occupational Therapy, 7 (4), 1-10. Guirado, Terry, Chambonnière, Camille, Chaput, Jean-Philippe, Metz, Lore, Thivel, David, & Duclos, Martine. (2021). Effects of classroom active desks on children and adolescents' physical activity, sedentary behavior, academic achievements and overall health: A systematic review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18 (6), 2828. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18062828 Sarafian, A. (2019). Educational participation for children 5-21 years. Systematic review of related literature from 2010 to 2017 [Critically Appraised Topic]. Bethesda, MD: American Occupational Therapy Association. United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2021a). Detailed event or exposure by selected natures [Data file]. Retrieved from https://www.bls.gov/iif/soii-data.htm United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2021b). Employment status of the civilian noninstitutional population, 1950 to date [Data file]. Retrieved from https://www.bls.gov/cps/tables.htm#annual Wong, C. W., Tsai, A., Jonas, J. B., Ohno-Matsui, K., Chen, J., Ang, M., & Ting, D. S. W. (2020). Digital screen time during COVID-19 pandemic: Risk for a further myopia boom? American Journal of Ophthalmology , 2020-07. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajo.2020.07.034 Episode Transcript Download or read a rough edit of this OT School House Podcast episode Amazing Narrator Hello, and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school-based occupational therapy tips, interviews, and professional development. Now to get the conversation started, here's your host, Jayson Davies. Class is officially in session. Jayson Davies Hey there, welcome back for what I'm calling is the first episode of the 2021-2022 school year of the OT School House podcast. Thank you so much for joining me today. My name is Jayson Davies, and I am an occupational therapist down in Southern California. But I'm happy to be with you, wherever you are in the world listening today really appreciate you being here. Today, I wanted to have a podcast that really embodied the return to schools. Because right now, you know, some of you got back to school to the physical building at the end of the last school year or some part of last school year. For others of us, we're just going back in person this year. And so I really wanted something that would embody that. You know this is a start to a school year, like none other, there is just so much. I don't want to use the word controversy. But really, there is controversy about everything that's going on right now. And so we're gonna set that controversy aside, and we're going to talk about ergonomics today. And why I think ergonomics is the perfect topic for today is because like I said, we have people who have been learning from their couches, learning from their beds, learning from their home offices, whether you are an adult like you and I probably, or a kid, they've been learning from their bed, you've been maybe working from your bed or couch. And now we're all having to go back into work potentially. And that is going to be a big change in our own bodies. And so today I am bringing on Kirsten Beshay. She is a Doctor of occupational therapy. She studied at the University of Southern California, my own alma mater fight on football season is coming up for all you Trojans out there, and everyone else who's interested in football. And then she ended up getting her OTD at Boston University. And we'll actually talk a little bit about that, as we get started with this interview. She is an ergonomics specialist. And you know, she's actually pretty new to school-based OT. And so she's going to talk to us about ergonomics in school-based OT as well as ergonomics outside of school-based OT for any of you who have ever had an interest and what that might look like. So kick back, relax, put that phone away if you haven't already. And please enjoy this interview with Kirsten Beshay. Hey, Kirsten, welcome to the OT School House podcast. How are you doing today? Kirsten Beshay Hey, Jayson. I'm so happy to be here. I'm doing great. Jayson Davies Awesome. And you know what, I have to start with this because you just said you're going on a trip. And by the time people hear this, you will probably already be back. But tell us where are you going? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, I'm going to Egypt tomorrow. My husband was actually born and raised in Cairo. So we are going to see family. Jayson Davies Oh, wow. So it's not just for I mean, just have fun. I mean, it is to have fun, obviously. But it's also to see some family huh? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, yeah, I've done the pyramids before. I've been on the camel. So I think this one will be a pretty low-key family... family visit. Jayson Davies Not too much sightseeing. Just kind of taking easy eating some good food, I'm sure. Company... Kirsten Beshay Always about the food for me for sure. So yeah, I think that part will absolutely be a big piece of it. Jayson Davies That's awesome. Oh, man. I've never been to Egypt never been to. I mean, I've been to Europe. But that's about I've only been to Europe and Peru as far as outside of the country. Unless you count the Virgin Islands, but whatever. But yeah, that'll be a fun demo now to Egypt. And sounds like you've been there before. So that's gonna be one... Kirsten Beshay Once before. Yeah, I'm still relatively a newbie. But you know, I have a family of experts. I get the insider scoop. Jayson Davies There you go. That's always nice. Right doing some of the local stuff as opposed to some of the tourists. So very cool. Well, we are actually here to talk a lot about ergonomics today, you have done ergonomics, both in the schools, as well as outside of the schools. And we're going to talk all about that. But first, I want to give you an opportunity to share a little bit about yourself and your background as far as occupational therapy. Kirsten Beshay Yeah. So um, this is always kind of a fun question how people got into it. I graduated with my bachelor's degree in psychology and music. And I was initially thinking about studying cognitive psychology, maybe tried to get into a Ph. D program I applied to those, but it just kind of didn't work out. And so I graduated with my bachelor's degree and was like, Well, I don't have a plan now. Am I gonna do and my dad actually mentioned he'd read in US News and World Report that OT was like this up and coming great future job and I was like, Okay, dad, but I ended up shadowing, you know, all sorts of different OT settings to get a sense Because I read the description, and I had no idea what OT was. And then I shadowed and I still really didn't know what OT was because it was so varied. But I said, I think I could do any of these, these look fun. And so I'm in right now. That's kind of what drew me and it's so fun. I just love that we can like do different things on different days of the week that are so different but are still so tied together with our skillset. So I love it. Jayson Davies Absolutely. Man, I love the whole psychology behind when your parents tell you about something. It's like, nothing is ever good. When your parents tell you like your parents could tell you you won the lottery. And you're like, no, that's not I don't want the money. But that's funny. Well, I'm glad you ended up finding occupational therapy. And if I remember right, you are actually relatively new to school-based OT. Right? So how long have you been in OT? How long have you been in the schools? And yeah, we'll start there. Kirsten Beshay Yeah, so I have been an OT for six years now. I just finished my first school year as a school-based OT, and your podcast, I've gone through dozens and dozens of episodes, in this past year learning and growing, and it's been great. So thank you. Um, I also, of course, have been partly seeing kids with teletherapy for most of that time, you know, so I know everybody's a little different regionally, but most of my year has been spent doing that. So coming back for a year or two, and the in-person is, you know, I've done some, but it's gonna be another learning curve. So I guess that's just how it is for everybody right now. Anyway. Uh, yeah, Jayson Davies Yeah. And you know, if you've made it through the last 18 months of the school-based OT, I don't think it can get much more difficult than that. I mean, was teletherapy was tough. I don't know for you. But for me, it was tough. Kirsten Beshay Yeah, absolutely. I think in some ways, it was a lower bar for me because everyone was figuring it out. So people were very, I mean, I have a very supportive team. But I felt especially supportive because everyone kind of felt like we're starting from scratch. So it was Yeah, I learned a lot. I think that it was an interesting time to have witnessed, you know, to see everybody kind of figuring this out and banding together. So I'm glad I was I wouldn't say it was easy, but I think that I was a part of it in some ways. Jayson Davies Yeah. And in me, I mean, it doesn't matter. You could have been an occupational therapist in the schools for 20 years before last year, you were still struggling last year. So it doesn't matter where you were, the whole playing field just got leveled, like everyone was, unless you were already practicing in teletherapy online, you basically had to figure it out. So we were all transitioning right there with you. So you mentioned listening to the OT School House podcasts? What else helped make that school year a little bit easier? Did you have any other resources that were some go-to resources or any mentors? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, um, you know, I've been thinking about, I know, we'll get into my background and what else I've done a little bit, but I've been thinking about making the switch to school-based OT for a while. And I was really holding out to find like a supportive, like team lead or manager or, you know, a team that was going to be really supportive, because I was just going to have a lot of learning to do. So. It took me a little while to find it. But I think like my shout-out to Laura, OT lead, she has been super supportive. So I would definitely call her my mentor. I also have multiple friends that I graduated from USC with back in 2015, who have been very helpful and just, you know, a phone call away when I have questions. And then just digging through, you know, I mentioned the podcast, I bought the e-book of the AOTA school-based practice, textbook and went through a lot of that, and I gotta say, the Facebook groups for some of these pediatric school-based OT communities have just been absolutely wonderful. You know, like, any questions under the sun are probably all in there. And if not, I probably asked them, and it's just an amazing community. So all of those have been a huge help. Jayson Davies 100% Shout out to Laura, shout out to the 2015 USC grads. Whoo, you're doing great. I was a few years before that, but good job. And of course, all the Facebook groups. Yes. Very helpful. I love the Facebook groups. You know I wanted to start one for myself. But then I was like, why there are so many good ones out there already for pediatric in school-based OT And so yeah, I go on there to ask questions, answer questions. I'm there too. Alright, so let's jump into school-based OT and ergonomics. First, we'll start with ergonomics. How did you end up actually kind of getting into economics? You know, we talked about this a little bit in schools, like when we're in OT school, but how did you just kind of end up going full throttle into economics? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, you know, it was always something that I've been a little interested in when I was doing my I guess gap year after my bachelor's degree when I was taking anatomy at night, you know, getting my prerequisites for OT school, doing my shadowing. I was also attempting at a small kind of tech company in the bay area, which is where I live in Northern California. And the HR team there was always kind of very puzzled by what to do if someone had an injury and like, what, what keyboard should they get? Like, should they order a footrest, they just kind of like didn't really know where to go. And I think it was such a small company that it was just a question mark, no one really had a process set up for like how to find this stuff out. So I remember kind of thinking, I think that might be something that I might be able to figure out once I go to OT school. So it was like, kind of in the back of my mind. And then I took an elective in ergonomics at USC, which was really fun, and just kind of gave me a lot more of that information. We had a couple of guest lectures of OTs who were doing ergonomic consulting, so it just kind of planted the seeds. And yeah, I just think the whole time I got exposed to it. I just loved how preventative it was, you know, how you can spend like 20-30 minutes with someone one time and just make a world of difference. And you know, preventing an injury, hopefully, and you can be super creative. You know, a lot of times they're really low budgets for ergonomic services. And so you're not going to go out and get someone that $1,000 deaths, you got to kind of work with, you know, a stack of books and all those, you know, duct tapes and crazy stuff. Um, and it's, it's pretty unique. So that's kind of fun, too, is you know, not many people know that. Well, I shouldn't say many, but it's definitely a unique practice area for OTs. And I think it's a pretty well-kept great secret because it's a pretty low stress. The hours are very good. You know, I used to work in the hospitals too. And so I feel like there were some aspects, I was like, Oh, I feel like I can breathe a little easier in this type of mission. Jayson Davies That's funny that you mentioned the low-key ergonomics ways to fix things because I'm not gonna lie. Yesterday, I was on costco.com and Amazon and looking for one of them, the adjustable standup desks. And I got to the point where I'm even like measuring my office, I'm like, Alright, do I want the 48 inches, so 55, which is like ordering a DV. But then I'm like, I have to get rid of my other desk, which I already like. And then you get into the rabbit hole. It's like, Oh, well, you have the ones that can go on your desk and rise up. And then all yanking, I'm like, dude, I have OT textbooks on my desk that are raising up my monitors. For my kids back when phone books actually existed, you know, I tape up phone books with duct tape and put that under their feet, turn the trashcan on its side so they can put their feet on the trash can try and I mean anything right to kind of try and get them in a position where it's easier for them. So you're right. It's a little bit different than typical traditional per se, occupational therapy. But I can see how it could be a good, a good changeup. Kirsten Beshay Yeah, absolutely. Jayson Davies All right. Before we get too far, though, I do want to give you the opportunity, actually, just to make sure we're on the same page to kind of defined ergonomics, what it is. And sometimes the easiest way to answer this is just like, what is someone who has no idea what ergonomics is, and they ask you, what do you do? How do you explain that? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, I mean, you know, we're all used to that. Right? OT or is like, How do I explain this, but we're gonna have, it's kind of the same. I like there's a quote by Pheasant and Hargrave that I really like that says ergonomics is the science of work of the people who do it and the ways it is done, the tools and equipment they use, the places they work in, and the psychosocial aspects of the working situation. So I mean, obviously a very broad definition. But basically, we're looking at work in, of course, we'll get into this, but that might be you know, children's work might be getting an education. So it doesn't have to be an office setting. But someone doing work and looking at the social aspect, the physical aspect, the mental aspect, and kind of approaching the environment, approaching the person in the occupation, and tackling all of those to ensure that people are healthy, and we're promoting well being. So if that's still a little broad, you can really spend a lot of time doing office ergonomics where you might go into someone's desk, like what you're mentioning, you know, a home office, we're seeing a lot of those and suggest equipment, if it's not fitting them well, in a school, we'll dive into this, but you might look at furniture fit for your students. If someone's working in a factory, you know, standing at a conveyor belt, you might suggest task variation for them. Someone's in a wet lab, you know, you might suggest more automated pipetting equipment, so lots of different things, but the world is your oyster in terms of how you specifically approach that. Jayson Davies Yeah, and you're right that that definition of ergonomics was very, very broad. And one of the key terms or two key terms that you used in that definition was physical, which I think makes sense. We're all used to adapting to the physical environment when it comes to ergonomics. But you also use the term social adaptions, which I don't think of typically when I think of ergonomics. I don't know if you can elaborate on that a little bit more. Have you even really touched upon the social aspect? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, I think it's kind of that mental health piece is a bit too in my mind. So if I'm evaluating someone say, you know, in an office setting, and they are extremely stressed, you know, am I going to completely like, take that out of it and just look at the physical piece and say, Oh, your desk is too high, you know, obviously as OTs were, like, absolutely going to look at that, and I'm probably not going to provide mental health services for the long term. But it's, you know, there are recommendations, if I know, the company's HR department might, you know, have some resources and employee assistance program, you know, I might kind of put that in the kind of write up or depends on the situation. But you know, that or, you know, just co-worker interactions can also if you're sitting in an open office space, and the coworker next to you clips, their toenails in the middle of the day, and that really bother you. Maybe having a slightly further desk space will actually be conducive to your well-being at work. So just some random examples, but it really can look like a lot of different things. Jayson Davies No, that is a great example, then I hadn't thought of that. Because you're right, you can't. You mentioned the PEO model person, environment occupation. And, you know, I love that model. And that's absolutely true. What you're saying though because even though you might give someone a new chair or a new desk, that doesn't mean it's gonna fix the problem. If you don't address maybe some of the other issues. Like what you use the example use high stress Well, I mean, sitting or standing, if you have high stress, that's still going to impact your body one way or the other. So very important, at least consider it. Kirsten Beshay And I have to add, you'd mentioned like the sit-stand desk, which, you know, I like those, but I do find a lot of times people get that, and then they never stand. So there's the behavior aspect, within like, the individual person is like, you know, you'd like to have this but are you actually like, can we work on like a, like a timer, or reminder or some app that will help you remember what motivates you to stay on? So you know, all of those things that we as OTs are looking at with our clients are exactly the same in ergonomics. Jayson Davies That's funny. Yeah. But that's totally true. I mean, all the even the apps that we use on our phone to remind us about things, I mean, all of those once upon a time, were really accommodations, and now their everyday life to remind us to mean, something simple as brushing your teeth in the morning, just a reminder to brush your teeth or reminder to drink water. I mean, how many of us have a reminder every three hours to drink a glass of water? I mean, things that were accommodations, at some point are now just everyday life. And so teaching people how to use even something like their cell phone, which they have on them 24/7. That's one way you can do it. Kirsten Beshay Yeah, cool. Jayson Davies So, ergonomics, you've been an OT for about six years, but you've only been in those schools for about one year. What were you doing during those five years related to ergonomics? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, so I mentioned I had a brief stint working as an inpatient in a hospital. But most of my time for the past five years was spent as an ergonomic consultant for a tech company. So I was a contractor. But I have pretty integrated with the like ergonomics department actually, within environmental health and safety, which is a pretty common way that an ergonomics team or an ergonomic consultant might be integrated. Because you know, there is a safety, health and safety aspect to that. I'm currently also like per diem as an Ergo consultant. But during the bulk of my time, in those five years, I did a lot of office assessments. But I also did some lab assessments, both dry lab, which is more like electronics, and then wet lab, like, you know, I mentioned pipetting. They also had some industrial assessments, awesome kitchen spaces, which was fun, got to use some different standardized ergonomic assessments, and then provide a lot of one on one education, but also did some team education to kind of strike more preventatively. So since the pandemic started, thing, so things shifted a bit. So while I was doing more ergonomics day-to-day, in that role, I really was focusing on working from home. So that has been even outside of schools a big shift and that same creativity element, like working with what people have what space people have totally different than being in the office. So that's been really fun for me. Jayson Davies Wow. And so did you do any? I mean, you mentioned the per diem work and the consulting work. Did you do zoom calls with employees at all in like, look at their workspace at home? Kirsten Beshay Yes, I've been doing virtual evaluations, in various capacities for five years. So that wasn't a big switch for me, but seeing people at home, most of those people might have been, you know, in a different place than I was but in an office and now, I already I should say back at the start of the pandemic, especially people just, you know, in a hotel room that was 300 square feet and like trying to figure out how to work so it's scary. Yeah, just very different than anything I've seen before, which was really fun. And there are a lot of solutions that you can provide in those spaces, that just force you to be a little more creative, which I really like. So not I would say to anybody who has worked from home, you know, as a result of the pandemic, that it doesn't mean that you can't be comfortable, and there aren't solutions. But you might just have to put in a little more effort to kind of look around the house and see what you have. Jayson Davies So I think I might actually have this question later. But I'm gonna ask it now. Because we're kind of on the topic of your previous employment. How did you even come to find a job like this? Like, you know, it's really easy. I don't know you type in school-based OT jobs, and they come up? Do you type in occupational therapy ergonomic jobs on Google? Or how do you even find these? Kirsten Beshay Not at all. Yeah, it's totally different. And I think this is one of the big reasons that many OTs don't really know much about, you know how to how to get into this or what this might look like. Because I don't search for OT related things I search usually, like when I'm keeping an eye on indeed.com, which is where I usually look, I just searched the word ergonomic, or, or ergonomist, or ergonomic specialists, but usually just the word like ergonomic or even ergo. You'll have to sort through a lot, unfortunately, but it's not quite as clean-cut as OT positions where you need a license, because you actually don't need a specific license or background to work in ergonomics. So of course, some backgrounds are more helpful than others, like our background, and Kinesiology and posture and activity analysis, all of those things are great, but you might find people coming from a lot of different backgrounds. And so I actually, when I first got into it and was looking for jobs after I'd kind of been exposed to this, I just started searching on Indeed the word ergonomic. And I also had sent some messages on LinkedIn, like cold messages, very uncomfortable for me to send some messages to people in the Bay Area, who were either OTs or PTs who were doing who seemed to be doing ergonomics for tech companies, because, you know, being from the Bay Area, I was like, that would be so cool. What would that be like? And I just messaged them and said, How did you get into this, but I shadow you, no one really could let me shadow them by someone gave me a manager's email, and then I just kind of periodically would check in with this manager. And then that's kind of one of the times I emailed they had a position. And then that's how I ended up, you know, interviewing for the position that I had for almost five years. So it was a roundabout way. But you know, I would say don't be afraid to just kind of look around for someone who is doing that type of thing, if that's what you're interested in, and often people are happy to help you. But if not, you know, starting with that basic search is good too. Jayson Davies Yeah. Wow. So you mentioned OTs and PTs. Did you notice while you were in the field, any other professions that were kind of gravitating toward ergonomics type of jobs? or What did you see? Where is it just OTs and PTs really applying? Or what type of other positions did you see applying for this type of job? Kirsten Beshay You know, I would say OTs and PTs are actually less common, at least in my personal experience. I don't have any hard, hard data on that. But I actually consulted for install and per diem for a physical therapy company that does some ergonomic consulting. So they have a few OTs in the clinic, too. But they actually have a lot more therapy background people because you know, their primary focus is outpatient therapy. Yeah. But of the other people that I've kind of run into, I've seen a lot of people who come in with maybe an athletic training background, or I don't know bachelors in human resources or kinesiology, or it really, really can vary. I'm trying to think of who else but yeah, it really draws a variety of people who have some sort of interest in like health sciences or movement or engineering, I actually have also met a lot of people in, you know, at conferences and things who are like engineers who focus on like, the ergonomic side, but they might look more at design. But yeah, it's definitely a mix. And I think the fact that you don't explicitly need a certain background or certification also, is a little confusing at first, but I think that also makes us very well qualified because we do have such wonderful training and a lot of relevant aspects. Jayson Davies Yeah, whenever you don't need a license or certificate or something, it definitely opens up the possibilities for other people to apply. But you kind of started to allude to and so I want to go with it is during your interviews during your application processes, do you feel like having that OT degree, supported you and helps you to find a job potentially? Kirsten Beshay Yes, I was huge. They like communicated to me that it was a great background. I think the key thing when I'm talking to OTs who are interested in ergonomics, you know, as a consultant or something like that, outside of school, specifically, that job search term criteria being different as one thing, that's a hurdle. And the other hurdle is when you get an interview, when you're sending in your resume, I have a different resume for that type of work. That is basically it's the same experience, but I don't use our like OT lingo terms, I use terms that a layperson would understand, you know, who doesn't know the OT world. So it's still relevant, but it's slightly different. And same with interviews, I really try to use terms that make sense without talking about oh, you know, I saw, I don't know, just talking about caseload in the hospital didn't wouldn't really make sense to them. Yeah. So I think just thinking about vocabulary was was another big piece. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Those are two great tips for anyone looking for a job. Alright. That leads right into the next question I have is you talked about using different lingo. You know, if you're in an interview for Corporation, a tech Corporation, you're not going to throw out terms like IDA, IEP, like, those are out the window. Vestibular, probably, yeah, you're not gonna use those. But where did you learn this lingo for ergonomics? Did you go out and search for additional training outside of school? You did mention that you had an elective at USC about ergonomics, but I'm sure you've read books, went to conferences, maybe what have you done to further your education in that particular area? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, well, I would say first, like the be day-to-day, I think familiarizing myself with the standardized assessments that I got in the elective was, you know, a crucial piece in the beginning, but working with clients doing education, I need to use simple language anyway. So you know, I'm going out and like learning all the technical terms and things, I'm still going to do exactly the same way we do with like, you know, Family Education, you know, like, I'm really gonna think about the way I present it. So that said, I use the textbook ergonomics for therapists by Karen Jacobs, who was actually my, my academic advisor when I did my OTD, which was really wonderful because it gave me as a therapist, kind of a good perspective on ergonomics. AOTA also has a lot of school-based OT Ergo stuff and some ergonomic things in general. So that is a great resource. And depending on interest, I actually have a course for occupational therapists who want to work in Ergo. And I also will have a free school-based OT ergonomics webinar at some point in the fall. There are also some other online and in-person courses on ergonomic topics. So depending on you know, if you're interested in industrial ergonomics for factories, you know, there's something specific for that. So it kind of depends on what level you're looking for. Jayson Davies Yeah, and you know, we always have show notes, we'll be sure to link your website so that people can find that. The other resources you have, you mentioned, familiarizing yourself with a few assessments. You don't need to go into detail. But are there a few big ones that you would recommend anyone kind of look into if they're interested in this line? Kirsten Beshay Oh, that's a good question. I have just been kind of going through my list for the course. So they're all fresh in my mind. And it's really honestly hard to pick. So there are a few checklists out there that are pretty, pretty standard. And then there are also a few kinds of more standardized assessments. So one that I really like is the Rebbe rapid while I'm thinking of the robot, and the real, actually, anyway, there are a few, but there are a few kinds of one to the page, you kind of take a quick look at posture, and it gives you a score, the ruba and the real, I can send you those links. And those are freely available. And you know, as a school-based OT you might not actually be using those to assess children. But I think that might still be kind of a nice, just gateway into, like, what we're looking for. I mean, we look at posture all the time. So I don't think that's new for anyone. But it's kind of nice to see another aspect of that. Jayson Davies Yeah, absolutely. Great. Yeah, go ahead. And you can send me those resources at any time. And we will add it on here. You also mentioned your mentor, which Karen Jacobs, I love Karen Jacobs. And, Karen, if you are listening to this, let's do a podcast together sometime. If you're listening to gears on this podcast, you need to know that you and I need to jump on a call together into one of these because you just have so much knowledge to share. So I just kind of plugged that in real quick. But that's so awesome that you get to work with her. Did you meet her and start working with her as part of your OTD? Kirsten Beshay You know, I actually met her at the human factors and ergonomics society conference in October. And then I had kind of there weren't any OTs there. And so I had kind of found her on the brochure and was like, I gotta go to everything she's doing. And I went up to her at a poster and in five minutes she convinced me to do the Boston University OTD program, and she was my academic mentor, and she has such a wonderful background in school and ergonomics. So it was a perfect fit. So yes, she has been a huge support and developing that course as my OTD project. She was a huge advocate for that too. Jayson Davies Awesome. Yeah, she's a brilliant mind. She's always Go in. And I just Yeah, she's fantastic. So you mentioned you went there for your OTD. And it sounds like you actually did your OTD in relationship to ergonomics. What was that all about? Kirsten Beshay Yeah. So a lot of people as we kind of touched on earlier who are OT practitioners really don't know how to get started in ergonomics are really totally feel like they know what it is. We do have some questions about the licensing exam. But I think we spend a lot less time talking about ergonomics or at least terming things ergonomics that we look at, as I said, we look at posture all the time, and grasp and things like that, which are kind of overlapping and ergonomics and other areas. But I just felt like we have such a good background and activity analysis and knowledge of Kinesiology and creativity. So I thought that we are such a great fit. But it's strange that under 2% of OT practitioners are in that practice area. But I saw a statistic that about 69% wanted more information on the working industry is under so yes, and also musculoskeletal disorders were the most common non-fatal work-related injury in 2019. So it's just a huge scope, you know, like ergonomics gonna have such an impact. So I felt like we really needed more people, whether they're ergonomics consultants, or whether you know, we're in schools or in hospitals, like, they're aspects of ergonomics, and each, and I really felt like it was an opportunity for us as OT. So that's what led me to start developing that course. Jayson Davies That's awesome. Well, I'm excited. I think a lot of people are going to benefit from what you have to share with them, especially on ergonomics. So that's fantastic. And you said you're doing a webinar specific to school-based OT, so even better for our population at least. Kirsten Beshay Yes, that should be a one-hour webinar. So I will be condensing just the information that I think is most crucial. I won't have you go through all eight to 10 hours. Jayson Davies Yeah, that's cool. Very cool. So before we move on to how ergonomics relates to school-based OT, that's what we're going to get into for like the second you know, half of this episode, I want to ask you one more job as it relates to ergonomics outside of school-based OT and the job and, and all that and would you say it's a growing field, a shrinking field, a steady field? Do you think there's going to be a lot more opportunities for school-based OTs to use to get into this type of area? Kirsten Beshay Yeah. Are you thinking more like consultants? Jayson Davies Yeah, consultant or no? Do I don't even know big businesses? Do they hire their own person just to do ergonomics? Or is it mostly consulting work? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, that's a great question. The very, very large companies will have an internal team, I was at a very large company, as a contractor, and I was still a contractor. So even if you're part of like a team, that's just at one company, you might still be a contractor or a consultant, you might just, you know, have more hours there. But if, if it's not a really, really large company, it might be more of like a quarterly need, or they might want to have someone on hand if Oh, I think there's an issue here. So it depends. But all the need is absolutely there. And it's growing. I mean, especially with all of these changes in what work looks like with people just working from home with, you know, of course, none of us had much morning. And so I've seen a lot of discomfort coming from that. And I want to touch on that, in terms of us as school-based OTs too, because we have to think about ourselves and our own health and well being I'm sure there are people listening who have had some sort of discomfort or re come up of working from home on a laptop without much mourning. But yeah, in transitioning back to the office, things might start looking different. Some people might not be there, you know, people might be rotating desks, or people might be partly working from home. So I think there's a huge need. And as I said that, that musculoskeletal disorder incidence is so high. And we really, if you look at the data, we can save so much money by, you know, providing ergonomic services, whether it's preventative, or we're addressing something that's already going on if you make the case that the company can really save so much money in workers compensation costs, and it's a huge and growing field. So I think we have to kind of think a little bit about how we approach that and present that. So for new people, I found it easier to go with an existing company that had an opening for a consultant, but I think it's it's a wonderful thing to keep an eye on and I do touch on promoting ourselves and making the financial case for services in the course if that's something people are interested into. Jayson Davies Gotcha. You know, sorry, I just keep coming up with new questions. So we're gonna stay here a little bit longer and that is, so you are a consultant. You work for you said at the time or I don't know if it still is but for a physical therapy practice. The company is reaching out to the physical therapy practice asking for a consultant to come in to look at ergonomics. What are they really asking for... Do they even know what they're asking for? Are they saying we have a budget of you know, $20,000 and we want everyone to want to have nice ergonomic desks? Are they asking for one particular person you to come look at? What is that even? What is the referral per se? If we're going to use more OT terms? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, you know, I think you can look really different. And I'm not super privy to that specific company. But in general, I would say, it really, it can be kind of a one-off, or, oh, we've had a couple of injuries. And we're a little worried about this. So we want someone to kind of come and do a report and tell us, you know, what, we should change what equipment we should change, like, give us a list, here's our budget, and then we'll address it. So that could be one thing, I think there is gradually more and more knowledge about ergonomics on the company level, and so on. And sometimes it's seen as a perk, which fundamentally, I don't really believe it is, but it can feel like that, especially at these large tech companies. So I think that it's popular if you offer it, but also I do think that there's a sense that, you know, it will protect the employees and will hopefully save the company money. So I think sometimes you might be approached, or sometimes the consulting company might approach, you know, just companies and say, do you have anybody offering this service? Like this is how much money it might save? And then that might be how that relationship starts? Wow. So it can probably vary quite a bit. Jayson Davies Yeah, of course. I mean, and, you know, it's very different. Once you get out of the public sector of schools, you know, things are so much different once you get out of government-funded entities of any kind. I mean, they can really do anything they want. And so you've got Google wants one thing, Apple wants something completely different. And then any subsidiary of them on something else. So yeah, I can very definitely big time. Alright, so we're gonna kind of as much as I could probably ask you questions about the field of ergonomics outside of school-based OT. Obviously, most of the listeners that listen, to this podcast are school-based OTs, and they want to know, what they can do with their clients, how economics relates to school-based OT. And so I guess my first question is, is how do you feel like having that best knowledge and ergonomics has helped you as a school-based OT? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, so I mentioned posture a lot. So we all know that that's a piece of, you know, an overlapping piece, I would say, looking at grasp is also something that I feel that, you know, my background and ergonomics helps me to do is a little bit stating the obvious, but doing teletherapy I think computer usage, I like I'm very well equipped to look at, you know, what, what is my student using? What am I using that's working for me or not working for me? Specifically, how are my eyes doing? Am I straining them? You know, while I'm using all of these screens? Also, how is the furniture fitting, and you talked about using the trashcan, footrest, that type of thing, you know, like, is the chair too high? What can we do about that a lot of the furniture that we see in schools is just one size? And you know, that might, you know, we might not have, you know, kind of thought about what size that is, or it might obviously not fit every percentile of the student. Also looking at backpacks. I know AOTA has an annual Backpack Awareness Day that Karen Jacobs was very involved in the price. But I think as we come back to schools, especially, it's great to highlight because depending on what area you're in, and how much people are going back in my students, at least most of the year was virtual. And so we haven't thought about how much weight is in a backpack and how a backpack is fitting. And if we're using one from two years ago, it's probably not going to fit anymore. And then just movement, what the same kind of behavior modification, we were talking about what standing at the desk, I think, is a great thing to think about what students and we think about that. But we don't always realize that that's also ergonomic. So some of these things we're all doing. But I do think that having that background and doing it with adults for a long time, I do a lot of the same things with my students. Jayson Davies Yeah. And so over the past, we'll just say the last school year, what have been some very common things that you said to kids that two parents said to teachers, as a result of ergonomics, and kids learning from home, and obviously, people not being in the same room and learning. Kirsten Beshay Yeah, I mean, first off, it's been tough. You know, I think we all have kind of adapted our expectations a bit, you're not going to get like the cleanest, most straightforward therapy session all the time, you know, parents might or might not be able to be there. So, you know, we do the best we can. But I would say I mentioned computers, and that's such a crucial piece of ergonomics, both for us and for our students. And we've seen a huge increase in computer usage for school-aged students over the pandemic, not shocking to anyone, but we really don't know what the long term trends of that will be, especially as it relates to eye care, but also musculoskeletal disorders and posture and all of that. So I developed some handouts on computer usage. I know the human factors and ergonomics society has some too. We'll have some links in there, but you just kind of that basic knowledge of having a screen at eye level, if your students are on a laptop, maybe having a separate keyboard and mouse for them, that's more elbow height, and then fading the screen on some books just to have that basic, you know, looking straight ahead at the screen and also having your elbows kind of at 90 degrees while you're typing and mousing. If you can, I didn't always get there with my students, it's not, um, I know that a big push as some of my Schools has been to have everyone's faces on zoom, you know, to like be able to see the whole face and like actively participating. And for me, I absolutely cannot have my laptop screen angle that way over the course of the day. So personally, I would encourage students to angle it back a little bit more. So I can see the forehead, which is what all my junior highers love to do anyway, just show me the very top of their head, but to have it angled, so you're not looking down quite as hard at the screen, it's kind of coming to you a little bit more. And you know, I know this is diving a little bit into interoception. But also some of our students might not really be paying attention to is my neck aching from looking down all day. So we really have to, like walk them through How are you feeling with this position? So I would ask that a lot. Like, are you noticing your neck is sore? Are you noticing your wrists are sore? You know, do you feel like you're punching down? and usually, they say no, I feel fine. But you know, just kind of helping them walk through that. And that can help us catch any ergonomic risks that are there. I also would encourage having a dedicated space, although again, I definitely didn't have that with all my students. So you got to take what you can get. It's tough, but I think lots of parent collaboration and education, you know, sensory tips, a lot of self-feedback about the organization at home. And really just having a team effort was huge. I had a lot of teachers once I started giving handouts on ergonomics really coming to me with someone asked me specifically about eyestrain so that I made a handout on eyestrain to distribute. I ended up doing a little five-minute online video for the teachers on ergonomics so that they could protect themselves. So I think it really gave us some nice visibility into what OT can do. Apart from handwriting. Jayson Davies Exactly. Trying to get away from just being the handwriting teacher. No, I love that. I mean, I've got my setup here. And yeah, I had to, I've raised up my laptop a little bit. So it's not at eye level, but it's definitely a lot higher than what it would be if it's just sitting on the table. I've got my keyboard, my separate keyboard, and my separate mouse here. And my second monitor is on top of a textbook, will Willard inspections occupational therapy textbook. And so, no, I get that, you know, we're all trying to do that. With kids. It's been difficult. I mean, I've worked with a few sessions with kids. And it's like, they're at their dining room table learning. And I went as far with this student, I knew she was getting distracted, her teachers were telling me she's distracted all the time. And so I was like, Alright, well, no name, what is behind your computer screen. And oh my gosh, she turned around her computer screen, she was so nervous about doing it. And just the entire rest of the dining room table is just filled with toys. And luckily, the mom was kind of in the background listening. And so she was very open when I started because you know, mom has tried to do something. Let's go back to the conversation and think we had earlier about you know, dad tells you something, it means nothing, but someone else tells you something, right? And so the mom was very happy to hear me talk about, hey, we need to have separate areas for play and a separate area for learning. And I know that's not possible for everyone, especially learning at home. But when it is possible I that's huge, because she went from being super distracted in class to actually being able to get some work done. And all it was, was making sure that her toys stayed up in her room as opposed to down in her working area. So yeah, big aspect. Kirsten Beshay Absolutely. Jayson Davies Alright, so going back to your experience in a school-based OT, we have talked so much about ergonomics here. But obviously, you can't just be an ergonomic only occupational therapist in the schools, I like to say that we have to be, we have to know a little bit about everything. Because we could have a kid with autism one day kid with down syndrome the next minute, and we have to know a little bit about all of it. We can't specialize in one thing. And so, while I know you bring the ergonomic side to the table, I mean, I don't even know how to ask this question. I mean, you're not just an ergonomic therapist in the schools, you have to do everything, right. Kirsten Beshay Absolutely. Yes. So I have I do focus a lot on you know, kind of my individual students as I'm working with them one on one, but this is also a great tier one to think about it. I see that so that they make the point that it fits into what I'm doing with them, you know, so it's not I'm usually not doing justice ergonomics session. It's kind of integrated with other things that we're doing. I think also, you know, maybe plugging in self-feedback, if we're working on handwriting, and we're doing some self-feedback, or, you know, putting in a question about ergonomics there. There might be times where I spend the kind of a little bit more of one session, you know, checking in on how's your backpack weigh, you know, or how, you know, organization wise, you know, how many things are you putting in your backpack, and that might be more of like a monthly check-in or something like that. Or, you know, if we're working on typing, the first couple times of the year, we might focus on computer ergonomics, you know, talking through a little bit of that, because I do work with older students junior high in high school. And so talking through that, and then potentially, even if I have cell feedback for typing, maybe making get aware was the keyboard position, or it was I using the mouse or was using the trackpad or something like that. But most of the sessions I do integrate with other things. It's not exclusively ergonomics. I would also say that, if I'm doing an observation, I might spend a lot more time looking at ergonomics, then while I'm observing other things at the same time, yeah, especially you know, I mentioned backpack, so maybe looking at the fit of the backpack. Ideally, a backpack should have a maximum of up to 10% of a child's body weight. So I probably won't have a scale on hand, but I might get a good sense if I pick it up. And I'm like, this feels like 25 pounds, right? They're also observing, you know, if I'm observing, typing, or you know, like, anything like that in the classroom, I'm going to note the ergonomics of that. So are they reaching really far up the desk? Or the keyboard? Are they really are they on the laptop and their screen is just totally upright, and they're just cranking their neck down to look at it? Obviously, we all know to look for other feet dangling or they planted on the floor, is the chair way too big for them do we maybe need to throw a cushion on there is the desk height looking like it's you know, around their elbow height for typing or a little bit higher for writing, we'd look at playing board. So all that to say generally, it's not just an ergonomics day. But if I'm observing, I might spend a little more time thinking about that. Jayson Davies Yeah. And I've told this story many times too, as I've seen kids that are being scolded for moving in their seats. And I was literally watching the kid and the kid was trying to put their foot on the bottom of the table because that's all that they could reach like the, you know how they go down and they tee at the bottom, they were trying to put their feet on that tee because they couldn't reach the floor and got scolded because they were sitting at the edge of their desk because that's where they could actually reach the floor. And with that, this leads into the next question, because I know you do some training. And so in my experience, when I did that, you know, I wasn't gonna say anything to the teacher, right at the moment. I mean, first of all, I'm in there observing in the middle of the day, I'm not just going to go up to the teacher and say something, but I did leader, I sent an email and just then said, I didn't say any specific kid or anything, but just Hey, just so you know, some kids weren't able to reach the floor and went about it that way. How do you go about helping teachers when you see kids not necessarily, maybe not using the best posture not able to reach the seat? Or if you notice something in the classroom? How do you help the teachers? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, I love what you said about, you know, maybe sending an email out, especially if it's not for a specific student, that I think that's, you know, a pretty what's the word, I guess, non-aggressive, you know, it's not in the moment, it's later, so they have time to think about it. I think that's great. And, you know, offering to kind of maybe suggestions for Oh, it looks like a few kids have their feet dangling. You mentioned phone books, and how we never have those. But if there's like something similar that, you know, we can, we might think about having a few in the back of the rooms that you know, if anybody is noticing that, you know, kids can kind of pull same with like cushions and, and keyboards. And also I'd say the same in terms of breaks, which is something I think we do as OTs in schools think about a lot. But if I noticed that it looks like you're doing a little bit more of a stretch break, as opposed to kind of a break seated, doing something slightly different. You know, I might throw that in the email, too. If it's kind of a one-off, and I know that teacher well, I might say it in-person kind of right at the end. But I like to if there's something that I can offer as a resource at the same time, I like to do that. So I might wait until, you know, I have like a stretch handout or I can offer to you know, lead a stretch break, kind of see some of the different stretches. Yeah, that type of thing. Jayson Davies Yeah. And earlier, you mentioned a short, like five-minute training that you did was that for the teachers or for the kids, and how did that come about? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, you know, that's kind of a fun story. It was for the staff and not the students and people had kind of known when I joined this year that I had done ergonomics before. I think you know, it was just kind of the background that I shared when everybody's meeting each other on zoom because we did everything online at the beginning of the year. And so my team lead had asked me to do like a two minute or five minutes, ergo kind of working from home tips for our like staff meeting, you know, one of the first meetings of the year, so just a couple minutes. And then someone there said, Oh, can you maybe give us a handout? And so I made a handout. And then our Director of Special Ed was there. And she really liked it. And so then she said, Oh, wow, could you would you consider making a five to 10-minute video about working from home for everybody, and then our HR team could distribute it. So that's how I ended up doing a five-minute video of myself at my kitchen table with like sitting on a, you know, a couch pillow, and who has my laptop on a bunch of books, you haven't recorded that myself. And then that ended up being distributed to the entire regional team, which was very cool. Jayson Davies Wow, that is impressive. That's cool. And you're right, though, I just want to point out too, is that it is amazing. And I tell therapists in my course, I tell them all the time, one thing can turn into something much bigger. And like for you, it just started with the sound like it started with like a little one school just wanted a little bit, a few tips. And then it ended up and the whole district is now seeing your little video. And so start small, you don't need to change the world all at once. You can help one teacher, which may turn into two teachers, which may turn into an entire school, which may turn into an entire district. And you know, you don't have to start but you don't have to create a video for the entire district to start. Just start with one teacher. And you'll be surprised at how far that really can go. And it sounds like that's exactly what happened with you. Kirsten Beshay Definitely. That's Yeah, I mentioned one of the teachers later said, Oh, well, do you have anything for eye care? And I didn't. So I ended up, you know, a month later when I had some time making something. And then a couple of months later, that same teacher said, Oh, we've had a request from our school to have a presentation on executive function. Oh, what about the OT? And so I ended up co-presenting with the school psychologist. But I really think I probably wouldn't have been thought of first for that unless, you know, they had been like, Oh, well, she's done this. So that was a kind of cool visibility, an opportunity for me. Jayson Davies Yeah, yeah. And you know, the same exact thing happened to me, I presented for our three or four special education teachers at a school and the director of special education happened to be there. And then the next thing I knew she wanted us to present at a much larger meeting. And then you're presenting for paraprofessionals for teachers, for people that you would have never had the chance to introduce occupational therapy and what we can do unless you start with that, that first little thing, so very cool. All right, remind me again, you are now in the schools. Is it a public school, private school charter school? What is it? Kirsten Beshay Yes, thanks for asking. I didn't mention that earlier. So it's probably a little confusing. So I work for KIPP charter schools in Northern California. So it's, it's basically like, you know, a large district. So we have a few schools in San Jose, we have a few schools in Redwood City. Anyway, we're kind of distributed. I couldn't even tell you what the current number of schools is, they're always opening one or two more, but I do work for a charter school system, supporting junior high and high school students. And so I got five or six different schools and kind of do a variety of things. Jayson Davies And so in August, are you going to be returning in person for the most part? Kirsten Beshay As far as I know, right now, I think we're all kind of waiting to see with California what, what changes are happening? I think, for now, we're wearing masks. But you know, the school year hasn't really started. So I don't think I've heard too much official. Jayson Davies Yeah. Okay. And so do you think it's going to be fairly similar in your practice, when you obviously things are going to be in person when that happens, as opposed to online. But do you think your actual practice as an occupational therapist, other than just being on a computer is going to change very much? Or do you think is still going to be pretty similar? Kirsten Beshay You mean, in terms of like, what I'm doing... Jayson Davies Yeah, what you're actually doing? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, you know, when we did get to see some of our students in person, the second half of the school year, not everybody, but it was interesting, because some things I actually kept very much the same, some things I tried to change up. But of course, at that point, you know, some things run boxes, we didn't have all the equipment we would normally have. And so it was actually great because I really was a minimalist, you know, I was like, Okay, I got a piece, I got some printer paper, I've got some markers. This is what I know, I have today, I can do stuff with this. And I know some stretches. So I think it will be I'll have a lot more equipment. I mean, I had it available, but you know, I just really didn't want to have that much on my brain. So I wanted to start really simple, you know, do some, you know, bring in like one toy bring in, you know, one game. And so I think I'll probably be expanding a lot more the types of activities that I'm doing. But I do think that whether we end up having to do it virtually at some point in the future or not, you know, I think it's more there's more awareness about It now. And so having those, that ergonomic knowledge about computer skills, even if we're just working on typing with a student is going to be more and more of an important piece to have. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And you know, you're in a unique position, I didn't realize you're mostly with junior in high school, that's fairly unique. I feel like most of us occupational therapists, tend to at least have one elementary school. And typically, it's, you know, several elementary schools, maybe one junior and maybe one high school. But that's unique, that you're more in that upper grade. Have you had the chance to focus at all on working with kids and their actual cell phone devices? Because you're in that older? I know, a lot of kids now are using their cell phones to take pictures of notes or to even maybe use text to speech. Have you had that come up? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, you know, it's kind of funny, because I've been on campus less than I've been in school, it's possible that I'm not super up to date. But my understanding is that they don't allow cell phones, at least at the schools that were in person if I was there, during the day, unless, of course, there were a special need. So there have been instances where we've used an iPad or a laptop for some of those features, you know, like the PDF to print. I mean, I'm forgetting the names of all those apps where you can write on them. Yeah, but definitely, we definitely do a fair amount of focusing on that. And I know I spent a lot of time kind of talking about Grammarly. This year, we're talking about, you know, looking at reading and write and co-writer and like, which would be appropriate for which kid and word prediction and using the text to speech or sorry, the voice dictation feature on Google Docs and all of that. So I'm still definitely learning one of the other people on my team. It's kind of my go-to for assistive technology recommendations. But I think we do a fair amount of that with the older students for sure. Jayson Davies Gotcha. All right. Well, Kirsten, I want to say thank you so much for coming on the show sharing so much about ergonomics, both in the schools and outside of the schools really appreciate you coming on and just given us so much information about that. It's really awesome to see how things that you learn outside of the school-based world can kind of be brought into the school-based OT world and just make me an even better therapist through all that learning outside. Before I let you go. Are there any resources where people are, maybe not even resources, just where can people learn more about you? Do you have a website or Instagram or do you prefer to have people find you? Kirsten Beshay Yeah, so the best place is my website, which is kirstenbeshay.net/schoolergo, that's where I'm going to have information about my free one-hour webinar on ergonomics for schools, which should be out in the fall. So that's probably the best place to start. I'm also on LinkedIn. So all of that information will also I’m sure be up there at some point. So I'm sure this will be in the show notes. But I would say LinkedIn or that website are my best points of contact. Jayson Davies Sounds great. Well, thank you so much for coming to the show. Really appreciate you doing this. And I'm sure everyone out there listening has just learned so much from you today. So I really appreciate it. Kirsten Beshay Yeah, thank you. It's so much fun to be here. Jayson Davies Thank you. We'll have to catch up more once you got that course out. And I am looking forward. Looking forward to that webinar. That'll be a good one. So I will be checking out kirstenbeshay.net/schoolergo. And we will of course put the links to everything you just mentioned. And, and maybe even some of the resources you mentioned above in the show notes. With that, thank you. I really appreciate you being here. Kirsten Beshay Thanks for having me. Jayson Davies Take care. Bye. Kirsten Beshay Bye. Jayson Davies Thank you all again, so much for checking out the OT School House podcast. I really hope this episode with Kirsten really just opened your eyes to ergonomics and what OTs can do in the field of ergonomics. Even if you are working as a school-based occupational therapist, there is definitely something that you can look at in regards to ergonomics. And for some of you who might be looking to venture out of school-based OT know that there is something you can do out there with ergonomics. All right. With that take care. I really hope you enjoyed this episode and I will see you next time. Bye-bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now, head on over to otschoolhouse.com. Until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts , Google Podcast , Spotify , or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 82: Handwriting With At-Risk Kindergarteners (Journal Club)
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Have you ever wondered if that handwriting intervention you provide is helpful? Or how about what that intervention in the research article actually looked like? In this episode of the OT School House Podcast, we are going beyond the article with the authors of the 2016 AJOT article titled Effectiveness of a Handwriting Intervention With At-Risk Kindergarteners. Join me, along with Sheryl Zylstra, DOT, MS, OTR/L & Beth Pfeiffer, PhD, OTR/L, BCP, as we dive deeper into this journal article that shows how a handwriting intervention can impact at-risk kindergarteners. Links to Show References: Guest(s): Sheryl Zylstra, DOT, MS, OTR/L Beth Pfeiffer, PhD, OTR/L, BCP Article: Title: Effectiveness of a Handwriting Intervention With At-Risk Kindergarteners Journal: AJOT Date Published: April 1, 2016 Full Citation: Sheryl Eckberg Zylstra, Beth Pfeiffer; Effectiveness of a Handwriting Intervention With At-Risk Kindergarteners. Am J Occup Ther 2016;70(3):7003220020. https://doi.org/10.5014/ajot.2016.018820 Additional Resources Hoy, M. M. P., Egan, M. Y., & Feder, K. P. (2011). A systematic review of interventions to improve handwriting. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 78, 13–25. http://dx.doi.org/10.2182/cjot.2011.78.1.3 [Article] Size Matters Handwriting Program Episode Transcript Download or read a rough edit of this OT School House Podcast episode Amazing Narrator Hello and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school-based occupational therapy tips, interviews, and professional development. Now to get the conversation started, here is your host, Jayson Davies. Class is officially in session. Jayson Davies Hey there, everyone and welcome to another episode of the OT School House podcast. Thank you so much for joining me today. My name is Jayson Davies and I am a School-based Occupational Therapist down in Southern California. But I love interacting here on the podcast with all of you, no matter where you are. We have international listeners. We have listeners from the UK, from Australia, and of course the United States of America, Canada. And I just love. I love knowing that you're out there listening gaining from this experience. But I also love hearing back from you, whether it be on Instagram, Facebook, or even an email at jayson@otschoolhouse.com. I really love hearing from all of you. So please, if you love this episode, let me know. You can also leave a comment down in the comments if you're listening on Apple Podcasts. Really appreciate any review that can be a five-star review, I would love that. But I'd love any review just as much helps me to grow. So, let's get into today's content. Today we have on Dr. Sheryl Zylstra and Dr. Beth Pfeiffer. Sheryl Zylstra is a school-based OT by trade. And she is actually the primary researcher on an article that we're going to be discussing today. And we are so lucky to have her on because she's going to be here talking about her article. We also have on Dr. Beth Pfeiffer who was actually the researcher, the academic behind the article, she helped Sheryl with making sure that everything was going according to plan on this article. And she's going to give us insight as well as Sheryl, on kind of what this whole experience will look like, as well as what we lead to what the outcomes lead to. And so I'm super excited to have both of these amazing occupational therapists on the show today to really give you an idea of how this, this research came together, what the outcomes were, and even maybe what you could do if you would like to dive into research yourself. At the very end, we talk about some of the barriers and facilitators to research and so be sure to stick around for that, as well as everything about the article that is titled "Effectiveness of a Handwriting Intervention with at-risk Kindergartens". This article was published back in 2016, in the American Journal of Occupational Therapists, and the researchers were Dr. Sheryl Zylstra and Dr. Beth Pfeiffer. So enjoy this interview with them talking about their article "Effectiveness of a Handwriting Intervention with at-risk Kindergarteners". Good morning, Beth. Good morning. Sheryl. How are you doing today? You know what, let's go ahead and start with Sheryl, I'll give you a chance to speak first. Sheryl Zylstra Oh, good. Thank you. Thank you for having me. I'm excited to talk about one of my favorite subjects. Jayson Davies Awesome. Yeah. And I'm excited to have you...excited to let you share your research. You know, there are so many school-based OTs out there. And it's hard to find time to read the research. So I'm happy to have you on here to share a little bit about what you did. And over to Beth, how are you doing this morning? Beth Pfeiffer I'm doing well. I'm delighted to be here with both of you today. Jayson Davies Well, thank you. I'm really happy to have both of you on. And we're going to talk about so much today. But first, I want to actually give you both the chance to kind of share a little bit about your OT career, how you got to where you are today. So Sheryl, would you like to go ahead and start? Sheryl Zylstra sure I've been an OT for over 30 years kind of stopped counting at 30. But the majority of it and pediatric practice but not all of it. And then the last six years or so I've been teaching full-time at the University of Puget Sound. Jayson Davies Awesome. And what about you Beth? Beth Pfeiffer I've been in OT for about 25 years, mostly in pediatric practice as well. I'm an associate professor in the Department of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences in the College of Public Health at Temple University. I've been there for about 15 years, most of my time there was spent directing a research lab. So I'm very invested in research, but I also try to keep my hand in clinical practice as well. And that's mostly school-based practice. Jayson Davies Awesome. We are so happy to have you here today. And you mentioned Temple University, correct? And that's outside of Philadelphia? Beth Pfeiffer Yes, it is. Jayson Davies Awesome. Okay. Beth Pfeiffer What else? Jayson Davies Yeah, in Philadelphia. Sorry. You're outside of Philadelphia. But the university is in Philadelphia. Beth Pfeiffer Yeah. Jayson Davies And sure. What about you? Where are you joining us from? Sheryl Zylstra I'm in Washington State near Tacoma, Washington. And I did my doctoral work at Temple University, which is how I met Beth and she was my faculty mentor there. Jayson Davies That makes so much sense now. It's like how do people from two different areas of the country come together and University and Graduate School research that tends to be one keyway so that's awesome that you guys had that opportunity to, to come together in that way. All right. So let's go ahead and jump into the research. That you conducted. Sheryl, it sounds like you did a big part of this research. But how was Beth instrumental in this? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, great question. So this was my Doctoral Capstone, I wanted to do research. And I wanted to do something surrounding handwriting because that's an area that I'm very interested in. And when I got to Temple, I just started talking to Beth. And she gave me a lot of different ideas, and then really was integral in helping with the design of the project, I had a lot of lofty ideas about what I could do what we do in practice. And she would say, you know, that's great in practice, that sounds like a lot of fun, but we have to streamline it so that we can research it. So that's how that went. Jayson Davies Awesome. And so were you working in a school at that time when you started your doctorate? Sheryl Zylstra Yes, I was. I have almost 15 years of school-based practice. And so I was doing my Doctorate while I was working in the school, School District here in Washington. Jayson Davies Gotcha. All right, perfect. And so you said that you had an interest in handwriting? I mean, can you go a little bit further on that? Why handwriting? And then was there any particular part of handwriting that you're interested in? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah. So as an OT, I love working on handwriting. And I feel like it gets a little bit of a bad rap. And one thing that I've been reading about in recent years is really expanding our discussion of handwriting into talking about literacy. And when I work with children in handwriting, really, we're working on early literacy skills. And we're really promoting a variety of written language skills. And so I really encourage OTs to talk about handwriting in the broader sense of literacy. And one of the reasons I've really loved working in that area is because I see progress. I just see a lot of progress when I'm working with kids in that area. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And feel free to speak. And you know, you're right, we oftentimes are considered the handwriting therapist, the handwriting teacher, the handwriting something. And yes, we do want to have more roles at school-based OT, they really do think that OTs have so much more value to offer. But at the same time, I don't know. Did your research did you figure out what percentage of the day kids spent handwriting? I know that wasn't the whole point of your research, but it's got to be a large part, right? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, it is. And it is in the research. It needs to be redone. But the most recent numbers set about 25% of the day for young kids. Jayson Davies So 25%? Sheryl Zylstra 25% of the day spit specifically spent handwriting for kindergarten first grade age students. Jayson Davies Wow. So a quarter of our of the child's day is spent basically with a pencil in their hand. That is an occupation itself, right? I mean, that is such an important part of a child's school day. So there is a good reason that we do focus on that handwriting. Definitely Believe me there. All right, well, I have never done any research. But one of the things I always value in a good article is the background information and the research review of the literature that we have to look up. Before we even really get started with our project. As you decided to look into handwriting, what are some of the things you discovered through your literature review? And actually, along with that, how did Beth help you with a literature review? Sheryl Zylstra Great questions, I learned so much from the literature review, there were two to three articles that really stuck out for me. And they were really new at the time. And the first article is Hoy et all. So let me see, it's Hoy Fetter. And I've got it here. It'll come to me in just a second. And they really looked at they did a systematic review of the literature, and really helped determine what works, what's evidence-based, and what isn't really working to improve handwriting outcomes. So that was huge for me because that really taught me that some things that I was doing, weren't necessarily shown to be helpful. Jayson Davies Gotcha. And so Beth, I want to actually yeah, I want to go ahead. And as I know, you weren't the primary researcher on this, but you help a lot of primary researchers. And so what are some of the tips that you give researchers, specifically Sheryl when it comes to that lit review? Beth Pfeiffer Well, Sheryl came in with such incredible experiences, she had this clinical background, and she had a real insight into what kind of questions should we be asking what should we be doing? And then my job is to come in and really narrow that focus because as clinicians, we think big and we think broad and we think very functionally. And then with research, you have to bring that to a specific question and methodology to be able to do that and, and look at that. So. So when looking at the literature, it does go back to what is your question? What are you trying to answer and how can you justify that and I think one of the things that really came out of this and why I really value this article quite a bit in the area of handwriting is because it makes that connection to really functional outcomes, it's not just about getting words down on paper, which I think is really important. That's not to diminish how important that is. And being able to read, those words and then information and to be able to demonstrate that you know the answer and you know the information. So it can be evaluated in a school setting. But there's also this link that was made. And I think Sheryl did a great job of connecting that to the literacy component that she's talking about these pre-reading skills. Not a lot of people really understand that relationship and how substantial it is. So if you take 25% of the time looking at actually physically handwriting in the classroom, but how much more time is spent reading and learning how to read, and being able to obtain information through reading. So that's another big aspect of this. And I feel like that literature review really highlighted that and identified the importance of it. Jayson Davies Wow. And Sheryl, were you able to find actually a number that of the literacy component of the day? You said its 25% was spent in handwriting? Was there also a number for that? If not, no worries, I just wanted to throw it out there. Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, I don't have that number. But what I do know is that researchers are talking a lot about how handwriting itself is being de-emphasized. Because the Common Core is so focused on reading. And so students aren't being taught, specifically taught how to write the same way that they used to be taught. And but if we can go to our administrators and say, Look, there's this direct link between handwriting and early reading skills, then there'll be more likely to allow this time to be spent on handwriting instruction, and not just on what they consider to be reading. So it's all part of literacy. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And you know, handwriting without tears, as well as the size matters handwriting program, which I know we're going to talk about a little bit. I always mess up her last name. So I'm going to call her Dr. Bev, she has done so much. And she continues to emphasize handwriting in the schools. And I really think that is part of the reason not just because of the handwriting like you're saying, but also again like you're saying, you know, there's so much beyond the physical action of getting the letters on paper. There's so much more than that. So absolutely. Before we move on from the literature review part, I actually want to open up a question and you know, what, maybe there's an answer, maybe there's not, but when you were doing your literature review, was there anything shocking? Was there anything like oh, my gosh, I can't believe this exists? Or, on the flip side, wow, this, how come this doesn't exist? Was there anything really shocking to you? Sheryl Zylstra Well, thanks for getting back to that, because I wanted to mention this article, it's white Egan, and Fetter 2011. And the name of the article is a systematic review of interventions to improve handwriting. And that was hugely helpful for me, as I mentioned earlier because it taught me that some of the things I was doing weren't evidence-based in terms of improving outcomes. And another article that was hugely informative to me was the James and Engelhart, in 2012. And what they found, they looked at children were either copying letters, or they were punching the same letter on a keyboard, so they were copying a C, or they were keyboarding, a C. And what they found was when they were copying the letter when they were doing the physical act of handwriting, parts of the brain lit up that were directly related to reading, when they were keyboarding, that letter, those parts of the brain did not light up. And so again, it just showed from a neurological standpoint where the physical act of handwriting was impacting the parts of the brain that are specifically related to supporting reading. So those were huge articles to me. Jayson Davies Wow. Yeah. You know, we always it's funny, you hear something on the news, right? You hear just a quick 22nd clip on the news about something. And I remember, I don't know, maybe about five years ago, it was like handwriting helps you with memory more than keyboarding does, you're actually gonna remember something more, if you write it down versus type it, you know, and it's only like a one minute clip on the news. But you have no idea where that research comes from. They don't mention the author's or what journal it comes from, or anything. But I would imagine that maybe what you're talking about right there might have had an influence on that. And it's something we all hear but I don't think we often really hear how it was conducted and the research behind it. So thank you so much for sharing that. Sheryl Zylstra Yeah. Jayson Davies All right. I have to touch on this because RTI is one of my most favorite ideas within the schools, tiered intervention, MTSS, RTI, PB is all of it. I love it. And you mentioned RTI in your article. And so I just want to ask you, were you able to find RTI articles out there? And if so, what impact has that had on you? Because I know RTI in the grand scheme of things is actually relatively new. It's been probably around 20 years, but it's just now starting to really get embedded. So I just want to ask you, if there's any, what do you know about RTI? Was there any research in relation to occupational therapy, or in general? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, you know, there wasn't a lot of research, especially related to occupational therapy and RTI. But what happened to me as I worked in two different school districts at the same time, and one of the school districts I worked in was implementing RTI heavily, and the other district wasn't implementing it at all. And that's a choice school districts can make that choice. But what I was seeing in the school district that was implementing the RTI was amazing. And so I was, I became so interested in it, and I could see the impact it was having on the kids. And those are the kids we typically work with as occupational therapists, we don't typically work in general education settings, we're typically working with the at-risk kids or the kids that have already been selected for individualized education plans. Jayson Davies Yeah, yeah. Thank you so much for sharing that. Beth, do you want to add? Beth Pfeiffer Yeah, I think that's what really made this, um, this research study so important was it was really it was looking at a group of students that were receiving either RTI or that did have IEP interventions. And, and not much of the literature really look at that population, you would think that most of our Handwriting Outcome Research would look at that, but it's really with the general population. So this was really unique in that way, especially with the RTI and I think it also provides some real important justification for why OT should be involved in RTI more, I don't always think we're there. And I think we need to be. Jayson Davies Absolutely, and you know, there's so much more research going on even now than there was a few years ago with RTI and OT, we have Dr. Bazyk who's doing her every moments counts program, where they're really embedding OT into, into the curriculum into the everyday places and, and other OTs are doing similar things. So I think it's awesome. All right, I actually want to come back to you, Beth, for this next question. Because in my experiences, you really have to do that deep dive into the literature review, to find out what you know, and what you don't know. And then you kind of come up with a hypothesis. That's my experience. But I won't ask you Is that right? Or Is that wrong? Beth Pfeiffer Oh, absolutely. I think that when we're generating research questions, we get the information we need from different sources, and one of them is clinical experience. So someone like Sheryl, who comes in with a wealth of clinical experience in the school system really can identify where we need to target our research. So that's essential. And that's where that clinician and researcher pairing is so important. So I think that's one area and the other one is the literature. We don't want to be answering a question that's already been answered. Right. So that's something that we need to know is that already, do we already do this work? Do we already know that information? Do we have the evidence? So we need to go in there and find that out? And then we need to really find out what question we should be asking. And that tells us what is missing? What do we need to know? And so that's where that literature comes into play. Jayson Davies And that leads us right down to you Sheryl, what was the question that was missing? And what did you decide to tackle? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, so the question, in a nutshell, was that I wanted to answer was basically, is what I'm doing working, is what I'm doing every day when I go to work, which is a lot of handwriting groups, a lot of early literacy groups that make it different. And that's what I wanted to answer. So I have this specific question here. If you want to hear the long question. Jayson Davies Go for it. Sheryl Zylstra Will at-risk kindergarteners participating in the handwriting intervention group, utilizing the size matters, handwriting program, improve their handwriting legibility skills? And then in addition to that, we also wanted to look at, will this OT lead handwriting intervention, improve their pre-reading skills, as well? Jayson Davies So there are two parts to that. It sounds like yeah, the reading side, as well as the handwriting side. And I want to ask you because I think every time we read an article, we have to consider all factors involved. And you specifically, were looking at the size matters handwriting program. Was there a reason behind that? And if so, was it because you had experienced with it because you and Dr. Beth, were close, and you kind of knew about it? Or was the research behind it? What kind of drove that decision? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, I will tell you briefly, and then I will let Beth take over this question. I actually had was working in a school that was using D'nealian handwriting. And I had some concerns about that because there wasn't any research that I had found to support D'nealian and D'nealian is when you add the little monkey tails to the letters, it was sort of supposed to promote that transition to cursive handwriting. And right as I was getting ready to work on designing the research project with Beth, the school dropped the D'nealian and said, we're not going to use it anymore, which I thought was great, but it left me a little bit stranded. And so I talked to Beth and she said, Well, I have this great new program that we're starting to do some research on, let me tell you about it. And so I'll let her tell you about that connection. Jayson Davies Oh, go for it. Beth Pfeiffer So, um, Dr. Moskowitz was actually I'm also a doctoral student, and she started the development and besides matters, handwriting program in Temple's Doctoral Program, so I had worked with her quite extensively on that. And then we continue to work together, she was very, very committed to having evidence for the program and evidence-based practice across the board. So that's something she did when she was developing this and conceptualizing it, that was something that she really integrated into the development process, as well as her long-term plan after she left the program, so we had done some work. And we had just finished a study, looking at the effectiveness of the size matters handwriting program in the general school population. And we had really incredible outcomes, very strong outcomes that suggest that this improves legibility, this improves your handwriting. And so that's always helpful when you're starting to go beyond the initial question of is this effective, you know, does this have efficacy. And Sheryl was in a place where she was looking at it with a very unique population and one that we needed to know more information about. So we knew that this had evidence that it is an intervention that can work and improve handwriting legibility. So that's a really good place to start. And now we need to take it to this next level. And this was a really nice transition into Okay, now let's look at it with a different population. Let's look at it in we did look at it within the natural context of the schools before, but within the natural service provision that was happening in terms of RTI and IEP services. So it really seemed to be a good fit and next step. Jayson Davies Okay. So just to kind of rehash what I heard was that the size matters program, there was already some research out there. And the population for that was mostly just general education, maybe middle elementary age. Beth Pfeiffer Yes, exactly. We had mostly elementary students in the initial study, and it was just with the general population. Jayson Davies Gotcha. And that leads us into our next question for Sheryl, then you were going to a more specific targeted audience. And I'll let you explain that. Sheryl Zylstra Right. Well, I know as an occupational therapist in the schools, I wasn't working with the general education population, I was working with kids that had IEPs, or that were at risk of potentially having IEPs as they got older, that were struggling with their handwriting skills. And those are the kids that I wanted to look at because those were the children that I see. Jayson Davies Gotcha. So again, you went with kindergarten kids, right? Sheryl Zylstra Yes. Jayson Davies And then it was with at-risk, what turns them as at risk? Or what made them at risk? How are they identified? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, good question. So I typically work in what they called at the time and probably still call a resource room, where kids who are struggling to gain the kindergarten level skills are put to get extra time to learn those skills, basically. And so those children were a combination of children that already had IEPs, or that were being given extra intervention to potentially avoid having an IEP put into place. Jayson Davies Gotcha. So again, just to kind of reiterate, or not reiterate, but just kind of express what I'm hearing is that those kids either had an IEP, or they are already in tier two, maybe even tier three of the RTI process, meaning that they're getting small group or maybe even more of an individual type of service through the resource room, correct? Sheryl Zylstra Yes, exactly. It was a true tier two, because especially when I went in, I was seeing them in a group, and not individually. Jayson Davies Gotcha. All right, perfect. So let's go with that. Then explain what that looked like. What did it look like when you were working with these students? Sheryl Zylstra So it was really fun. Doing groups is one of my favorite things. So I would go into the classroom. And this is where, you know, again, as a clinician, I have these ideas, but Beth, as the clinician slash reach researcher, was really able to help me fine-tune what I was already doing, and make it sort of study able. So we would go in half an hour, twice a week. And I would lead a group using the size matters handwriting program, and we would just have a lot of fun. And we would use the principles, we had the workbooks, we would do a variety of activities that incorporated handwriting, one of the primary things that we did that is important to the size matters handwriting program is that we taught handwriting. So as an OT, I've been into many, many, many classrooms where teachers who are doing the best that they can and don't have a lot of knowledge about handwriting instruction, are printing out worksheets from the computer and giving the students worksheets to work on their own. But sometimes they're lacking structured handwriting instruction. This is how you make an H you start at the top you make a line down. That's really important. The actual there, there are some kids they say about 30% who are gonna pick it up. But there's this other group of children who aren't going to pick it up on their own. They need explicit instruction in order to learn handwriting. Jayson Davies Gotcha. And so you were doing this in the resource room. So were kids coming from their main classroom to the resource room, and then you were meeting with them in the resource room. Is that correct? Sheryl Zylstra Exactly. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Okay, perfect. Just so everyone has a chance to hear that. Awesome. So you're doing this in the group? You're doing it in the resource room? And did you have a chance to actually work with the teachers at all? Or was this strictly with the students? Sheryl Zylstra No, that's a really great point, it was really required that the teachers be an active part of the group. So the teachers were always in the room, I went in the COTA, the excellent COTA that I worked with also went in with me, the teacher was always in the classroom. And the teacher's assistant was always in the classroom. And the reason that was so important is that the teacher was learning the program as well. And she was incorporating the principles on a daily basis. So that was hugely important. That's one of the concepts that the Hoy et all article really pointed out to me is that practice, practice practice. You've got to repeat what you're doing in OT, outside of OT to make it work. Jayson Davies Yeah, absolutely. I like to tell therapists as well as other practitioners that work with students that, you know, sometimes we can spend a half-hour with one student and impact that one student's life. Other times, we can spend that same half-hour with a teacher, and we can impact 30 students lives with that half-hour with a teacher, and then the 30 students that the teacher has next year, and the year after that, and the year after that, just by training them a little bit. And so sometimes, you know, you can have more of an impact by stepping away from the student and working with the teacher a little bit. So absolutely. Alright. So when it comes to research, whenever you're going to look at the effectiveness of something, typically, you have to compare it to something. And so now, what were you comparing the size matters handwriting program to? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, so Beth may be able to answer this question better than I, but I'll attempt it first. We were comparing it to the standard handwriting practice. So teachers often come up with their own handwriting curriculum. And so whatever that teacher in that classroom was using was what we implemented in the control group. So we said, we're going to come into this classroom, and we're going to do the OT lead size matters, handwriting program, you are going to do whatever you've been doing, and what's been working for you. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Beth, did you want to add to that, or Beth Pfeiffer It's exactly what I would just say, as well. It's really when we're trying to do research that's in the natural context. And I think for school-based practice, it's very important for us to be implementing our interventions and looking at their effectiveness in those environments. You know, oftentimes, you're comparing the situation to the standard practice. So and that's essentially what it is, was what they as his services or as his interventions. So in this case, it was what the teacher was doing to teach handwriting within that context for those groups of kindergarteners. And we know in kindergarten handwriting is something that they are starting to learn. And it's part of the curriculum just naturally. So that was really what it was compared to. Jayson Davies So we don't we don't technically know the specifics of that handwriting program, if you want to call it that, is we just know that in kindergarten teachers teach handwriting, and therefore this was compared to that. Alright, that makes sense to me. I hope everyone understands that. So then basically, you then compared students who came to work with you and compared them to students who didn't come to work with you. Is that right? Beth Pfeiffer Yes. Jayson Davies Okay, perfect. at all, it's all coming together to make sense now. Beth Pfeiffer In a lot of ways that we're actually comparing somewhat two curriculums, it's just that we don't have the one standard curriculum defined, because that can look differently, especially with handwriting. I don't think their standard curriculums in all the districts are in all the classrooms that are being used. Sometimes teachers make determinations on how they're going to teach that. So we're really comparing almost two different curriculums in some ways in the school setting, you know, a very, yes, this matters, handwriting curriculum, and program, you knew to what the standard curriculum was. Jayson Davies Yeah. And so just, again, just to kind of wrap this up, Sheryl, did you actually speak to the kindergarten teachers at all? And like, ask them, Hey, are you using the handwriting program or find out anything about that? Or do we know what they were using at all? Were they just using a made-up curriculum? Or did they have a specific curriculum that the district might want them to follow? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, you know, again, it's often teacher specific. And I think what we're finding more and more is that I just read an article yesterday that talked about how using a specific handwriting program is important. We don't necessarily, it doesn't necessarily matter which handwriting program as long as it's presented in a very specific, repetitious, and consistent way. And so I do know that this particular teacher in the control group was a teacher with a wealth of experience many, many, many years of experience, and had taught handwriting in her kindergarten classroom for 20 plus years, and was using that same curriculum that she had developed over time. Jayson Davies Perfect. No, that's fine. Yeah, as long as we kind of know what they're doing, I feel like I know that they're actually doing it, I'd hate to, to measure our something versus something that isn't happening at all. And so that's great, we at least know that this teacher has some experience, they knew what they're doing, they had been doing it for a long time. And, you know, a school-based OTs, we've all walked into a kindergarten classroom, we've all seen what they're doing. We've all seen the letters up on the wall, we've seen them using the long stick to trace the letters and kind of show the kids how to how they do it. And so that's just wanted to see what that teacher might have been doing. So thank you. Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, I do. I do just want to add that I think this is where OTs can have a huge impact in the schools as well. Because after talking to a lot of teachers, you do learn that in their education programs, handwriting curriculum, or handwriting is not one thing they're very well trained in. And so they're asking us often what they should be doing, and they're doing their best, but often they are pulling things together. And it might be better to introduce them to a researched a well-researched program so that they can be more consistent in their approach. Jayson Davies Absolutely. And I actually had any experience doing this, I kind of did something similar to what you're talking about, except I went into a first-grade classroom. And I helped that first-grade teacher, the entire classroom, it wasn't a specific program, it was kind of a combination of all the knowledge I had a little bit from size matters, training a little bit from the handwriting, without tears training, I kind of put together my own 10-week curriculum. And I went into the first-grade classroom, I did it. And then low and behold, 12 weeks later, the administrator was much more open to listening to me about implementing some sort of program. And the next year, there was money available. And so the entire kindergarten, first grade, second-grade classroom all had the handwriting without tears program, which was awesome. And they sent several the teachers through the training. So you don't have to start big, you don't have to just go to your admin and demand something. Start small start with one classroom or one teacher and, and work up from there. Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, that's great. I love that story. Jayson Davies Thank you. So before we get into the results, let's talk about how you measured the success of the students. What tools did you use to determine if the size matters handwriting program was working or not working? Sheryl Zylstra So we started with the test of handwriting skills revised because it's really important if you're going to be assessing handwriting that you're using a handwriting assessment. So we use the test of handwriting skills. And then we used it because we were really interested in finding out whether this intervention would also potentially impact pre-reading skills. We used a screening tool that looked at letter sound-letter recognition and letter-sound recognition. So basically, there was a template with the alphabet on it. The letters were all mixed up. And I would point to a letter and I would say, What letter is this? What letter is this? And then the next time through, I would say, What sound does this letter make? What sound does this letter make? To assess if they knew the alphabet, and they knew the sounds of the alphabet? Jayson Davies Great. And Beth, do you want to add anything when it comes to figuring out what tools to use and kind of how you go about doing that? Beth Pfeiffer I think it's really important. It's an area that I'm particularly invested in this idea of outcome measures, we need to make sure that the tools we choose can actually measure change a lot of the tools, not a lot. But some of the tools that we use in practice, really are to help us guide our interventions. But they're not always sensitive enough to pick up the change. So it's very, very important to have a well-developed tool that you know, has been used either in the past or that you know, that can demonstrate that there'll be changes made. And we actually did a study specifically with handwriting, another study where we looked at the outcomes of handwriting, and it was with the size matters program again, but and we used a visual-motor integration tool, I think we use the berry and we used the test of handwriting skills revised. And what we found was that after the intervention, that there were substantial changes, significant statistical changes in the test of handwriting skills, revise, but not in the visual motor measure. So you can really, this is an area where you may be having an impact. But if you don't choose the right tool, or you don't measure the construct that you're targeting, that you might not see that change remaining. Don't be able to document it and research so it's really, really important. And when we were looking at the tools, the test of handwriting skills revised was a well-developed tool that had been used in handwriting studies in the past It also went down to a lower age range. That's one of the areas that was a real challenge and choosing a tool. This one only went down to six. And we were looking at kindergartens. Nurse. So we had some five-year-olds that we had to have had adjusted work, but it did go within the age ranges for the most part that we needed. So that was another factor as well. And then Sheryl actually had experience with the other assessment that really looked at kind of letter recognition and sounds. And so she had experienced that one before, and we were able to integrate that one as well. Jayson Davies Absolutely. I'm really familiar with the THSR, the tester handwriting skills, revise, it can be cumbersome to grade, you got to give every letter needs a one, two or three. And then you got the timing that you got to do. Yeah, but it is very sensitive, I would, I would say because it really details out a letter that has a gap is automatically scored at two, if I remember right, or no, I can't remember off the top of my head. But yeah, you got to look at that chart. And if it's crossing over, then it's a different number. So yeah, I'm glad you were able to find something that really helped fit the age of the kids and was also sensitive. So that leads us to our results. Obviously, the school-based OTs that are listening, we are not researchers, we are not good with T scores and P scores and all those other values that we often see in research. But what were some of the significant outcomes that you found? Sheryl Zylstra We had some really great results, and I'm gonna let Beth take this one. Beth Pfeiffer None of us would take this one. So as a researcher, I need to know a little bit about statistics. But I do think that we make statistics very scary for people. So I'm going to make this very non-statistic based and just summarize and say that there were significant changes in handwriting, legibility, and performance in the group that had the intervention, not the standard group in the group that had the intervention, there were some real substantial, significant changes there. And significance. Essentially, you always hear these terms like a P, that's, you know, .05. And essentially, what that means is that we are just 95% confident that that change was impacted by the intervention we provided. So that's, that's the interpretation of it, there's always this little chance that it wasn't this 5% chance, but 95% is pretty good. So and that's essentially what that means. And additionally, we also saw the same types of changes in letter recognition as well. So letters and the letter recognition as well. So there were significant changes in both those areas for the group that had the intervention, compared to the group that had the standard handwriting curriculum. Jayson Davies Was it just a letter recognition or both recognition and sounds? Was one of the other? Beth Pfeiffer It was on that test that assesses both letter sounds and letter recognition. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Beth Pfeiffer Watching the discourse. Jayson Davies Gotcha. And Sheryl, do you want to add? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, sorry, I was gonna just point out that it's important to note that both groups made changes because we're talking about kindergarteners and a big chunk of their year. And there's maturation, and there's a lot of learning going on, and all the teachers were excellent teachers. So it's not that the control group didn't make progress. They just didn't make nearly as much progress as the intervention group made. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Perfect. And thanks for explaining that. For anyone who might have skipped past the first 20 minutes of this podcast, and maybe me who kind of we've already gone 20 minutes later, remind me again, really quickly, how long this was the program? How long did you do the program over? And were you very strictly adhering to the size matters? handwriting program? Sheryl Zylstra Yes, good questions. I'm going to I believe it was 16 weeks, twice a week for 16 weeks. And yes, we were This is one thing I really learned from Beth, is that I wanted to do a lot of fun little activities, in addition, and do some cutting and some coloring and this and that. And she really taught me about the concept of fidelity, and how I really did need to have a strong fidelity measure and be really true to the size matters handwriting program for this project. Jayson Davies Great. Thank you for sharing that. Because I know again, Dr. Moskowitz, I know she has so much fun in her training that the size matters handwriting program. It has a lot of fun components to it. You got the dice game, and you got star letters and whatnot. But you're right, you really have to adhere to it. Otherwise, what are you measuring? And so you got to make sure that what you're saying you're measuring is actually what you're measuring. So thank you for sharing a little bit more about that. And that is going to bring us to the all-important question of how can school-based OTs use this information. You did this research a few years back where a few years later, what can someone listening to this podcast take back to their school, their district, and use tomorrow. Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, several things. I think one of the biggest things is this idea of practice, practice, practice. And one thing I think we really need to ask ourselves is if we're still using sort of a pullout once a week model, is that the best model? Is that a model that's going to allow us to have this repetition and practice that the research is telling us we need to have? So that's really important. And then the other idea is this, really teaching the concepts using a cognitive approach to teach the concepts. There are those few students that will pick up learning how to write from a worksheet, but there's a large group of children that will not pick that up. And we really need to teach it in a consistent, constructive way. Jayson Davies I absolutely love what you just said, because I have never read an article that says school-based OT kids need once-a-week therapy services. But I have read articles like what you're talking about, I mean, your article, other articles, the size matters, other articles with other programs. They tell you how many times typically, they met with a student or with a kid over how many weeks? And that's awesome. That's something that more OTs, I think myself, we need to look on to that part of the article. A lot of times we just look at the article, did it? Did it work? Did it help did the program work? But we forget to take into account how much they actually saw the students. And you know, there are some articles out there that we have to almost dismiss school-based OTs because the program's four hours a day, we're never gonna have four hours a day with a student. But like what you're saying 16 weeks, 30 minutes twice a week is right, is that correct? Sheryl Zylstra Right. Jayson Davies That is something an IEP team can handle probably. Sheryl Zylstra Yes. And this leads me back to the Hoy article again, which I keep referring to. And even though it's becoming a little bit older, I highly encourage everyone to read it, because it really just talks about what works. But it also talks about what doesn't work. And one of the things that do not work is sensory-motor activities. And I will admit that as an OT with 30 years of experience, I've spent a lot of time doing fine motor dexterity activities with kids, thinking that it was going to help improve handwriting skills. And again, it doesn't mean that doing fine motor dexterity activities is bad if that child has fine motor dexterity concerns. But if my goal is handwriting, I need to work on handwriting. Jayson Davies Yeah, absolutely. So great. Now, obviously, school-based OTs can take this information tomorrow, they can implement it, they know that they need to potentially up their services for some kids who that might be beneficial for or potentially reduce services or work with the teacher because they can do that more frequently than we can in some instances. Now, I know like almost the last line in every single article is famous, there needs to be more research. And so if you were handing this off to a new doctoral student, someone who wants to go ahead and get back into research, what would you say the next piece of research to be when it comes to handwriting in schools? Sheryl Zylstra Well, I'll tell you what I'm thinking about right now. And COVID really played into this is because so many classes went online and schools were online. What is the effectiveness of our OT interventions when they're online? or via telehealth? So we're I'm looking at the friend right now about if we were to do a similar handwriting literacy intervention via telehealth, what would the outcomes be? How would that look, would we have similar successes? Jayson Davies That sounds amazing. So you would take the same program, basically the same research, it would just be over more than likely Zoom or Google? Sheryl Zylstra Exactly, exactly, to see if our results would be similar? Jayson Davies So does that mean you're working on that? Sheryl Zylstra We're, we're talking about working on it. Jayson Davies Awesome, awesome. Well, I can't wait. I'll give you about three years and looking at the AOTA journal and I'm sure I'll see something. So I could not be more appreciative to both of you, Sheryl, that because of the research that you do, I mean, I really appreciate you being here today sharing this a little bit. But even more so both of you and all the other therapists that do research that give us something to stand on. You know, this is something that an OT could, I always recommend that OTs have like a book of articles, and you know, taking that book, this is an article that you could put in that book. And when you need to refer to something in an IEP or if you need to go talk to your admin about something that's important to the kids that you work with. This is an article that you can take with you and share with your admin. You know This is why I'm justifying twice a week for this student because this is the program and it worked. And it was twice a week. That's why I'm recommending twice and not once a week, per se. And so again, I really appreciate you both for all the information that you have researched. And, of course, so much for coming on here today. So thank you. And the last question I have to ask is, are there anywhere? Or are there any websites or any other resources that you both would like to share? Where OTs would like to learn more? I know, you've already mentioned a lot about the Hoy article, and I will be sure to put that in the show notes so that people can find that. But are there any other websites or any other resources you'd like to make known? Sheryl Zylstra Yeah, so I would like to add the Jameson Engelhart article to that 2012, Lenin Grotto and Goodman have been doing a lot of work on promoting literacy. So again, taking that handwriting and making it bigger, are really talking about literacy. And then I also want to really quickly add that the minute to chime in here, that clinicians can do research. So if you're a clinician, and you're interested in doing research, by all means, collect the data. And then if you don't understand how to statistically analyze it, that's where you call someone like Beth, or you hook up with your local university and you say, I've got all this great data that I'm collecting in the clinic, can you help me make something of it. Beth Pfeiffer You actually said exactly what I wanted, Sheryl, that was perfect was that don't be afraid teller shy away from doing the research or thinking that you can't be the person that does it. Because there's a lot and lots of ways to collect that information. This study was a pre and post-test study. And we used what they call a convenient sample. So that means that we didn't separate people out randomly into groups, we looked at them in their natural context and their natural classroom environment. And that's really important information. And you can do that. And as long as you're using measures that target what you want to know changes, you can collect that very easily, just as part of your progress monitoring. So we need to do that in school-based practice, we need to monitor our progress. And we can incorporate collecting some of this information during those times. And we can really use that to one demonstrate that either need for services, and the value of occupational therapy, and advocate for what we think is the best approach in that situation, then also get that information out there to the profession to show that what we're doing and how we do it works. Jayson Davies Alright, I have a follow-up to that, Beth, what is the one? What's the one barrier that clinicians come to you most with? That is it just an absolute myth? What is something that therapists come to you and say, you know, what I can't do? I can't do the research because of a blank and why is it a myth? Or what is your response? Beth Pfeiffer I think, and I don't think it's a myth. I think it's a reality. But time is the factor, time and resources are always the factors that come up. And I think that it's not a myth because we all were also stretched for time, we have large caseloads in school-based practice. And we have limited resources in schools. We're under-resourced, to begin with, I think the thing we can do to overcome those barriers is to be innovative in our thinking. And also to realize it doesn't have to be this huge project outside of what we're already doing. So we can be collecting information as part of the natural process of providing services in the schools that we can look at some of the before and after. As I said before, we need to document our progress anyway. And that's part of the school-based practice. And so we can use targeted measures to be able to do that, and then collect that information. And it can be pretty easy to then have a small research study going over time. So I think there are ways and ways that we can overcome some of those barriers. The other thing I would encourage I know, Sheryl said this as well, working with your local institutions, there are a lot of graduate students in OT that would be delighted to help you in those settings and get that experience and they have research requirements. So using those resources, and accessing those, I think is a really important step as well. Jayson Davies Definitely. Well, thank you so much, Beth, thank you, Sheryl. Really appreciate you coming on sharing, not just about handwriting and literacy a little bit, but also a little bit about how you can get into some research if that's something you might want to do. So thank you both so much, really appreciate you taking the time to be here. And also really appreciate you being willing to go to the next step and do some research. Really appreciate that that supports all of us out here. So one last time. Thank you so much. I really appreciate you both being here. Sheryl Zylstra Thank you. Take care. Jayson Davies All right, one more time, please give it up for Dr. Zylstra and Dr. Beth Pfeiffer really appreciate having them on here. Like I just got done mentioning at the end of that interview, I really do appreciate them going a little bit further going beyond the clinician role and doing that research so that we have something to take back to our administrators to show them. Now with that said, I want to ensure that you actually go beyond that. So be sure to click over to the show notes and read this article, we covered a lot, but it is definitely worth a quick read over to make sure you didn't miss anything. Some things that you always need to read when you're looking at articles are those limitations and biases. And right after I hung up the phone with them, I realized I forgot to ask them. Now there isn't anything too big in there. But that's something that you should always look at with any article you read okay? So, head on over there, read the article, check out the other articles. And my favorite thing to do actually is when I'm done looking at an article is look at the citations. You don't have to go and click on every single one and read every single article that's in those citations. But you might be surprised by what you find. And you might find a really good article that again, will help you support yourself, support the students and support the teachers you serve as a school-based OT. So one more time. Thank you so much to Dr. Zylstra. Thank you so much to Dr. Pfeiffer. Really appreciate having you on and of course, thank you one last time to you, the OT practitioner listening to this podcast right now. I am so happy so excited. so thrilled to know that you want to make yourself a better occupational therapy practitioner, especially in the schools. Take care. Have a great rest of your day, and I'll see you next time on the podcast. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now, head on over to otschoolhouse.com. Until the next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- OTSH 81: School-Based OT Workloads with Alexa Corley, OTD
Press play below to listen to the podcast Or click on your preferred podcast player link! Welcome to the show notes for Episode 81 of the OT School House Podcast. In this episode of the OT School House Podcast, we are talking to recent graduate, Alexa Corley, about her OTD capstone where she surveyed and interviewed therapists, teachers, and administrators about the idea and use of a workload model. Listen in to hear her findings and a discussion about the positive effects of using a workload model. Links to Show References: Visit Alexa's website at Alexancorley.com Episode Transcript Download or read a rough edit of this OT School House Podcast episode Amazing Narrator Hello and welcome to the OT School House podcast, your source for school based occupational therapy, tips, interviews and professional development. Now to get the conversation started, here is your host, Jayson Davies. Class is officially in session. Jayson Davies Hello there and welcome back for another episode of the OT School House podcast. My name is Jayson Davies, occupational therapist down here in Southern California. And I'm just super excited to be with you, wherever you're listening today, I am just happy to have you here listening and trying to improve yourself as an occupational therapist, learning what you can learn to better serve your students as well as the teachers that you work with. So again, super happy to have you joining us here today. So today, we are actually diving into the topic of workload and caseload just a little bit. And we're going to do that by looking at a capstone from Alexa Corley that she completed as part of her doctoral program at the University of Central Arkansas. So we're going to have an interview and discussion with Alexa. And she's going to tell us all about the research that she did leading up to, and the actual work that she did herself to determine what OTs, administrators, and teachers perceive about a workload and a caseload model when it comes to school-based occupational therapy. This is something that's very important to all of us a school based OTs, I believe, I really think that under a workload model, we could serve more students potentially in less time and have better outcomes. And well, let's just... I don't want to get too far in I just want to let Alexa share with you all the details that she came across, the research that she found, and then what her survey results showed. So without any further ado, here is Alexa Corley talking about her research on workload versus caseload. Hey, Alexa, welcome to the OT School House podcast. How are you doing today? Alexa Corley, OTD I'm doing great. Thanks for having me. How are you? Jayson Davies I am wonderful. Thank you so much for joining us. It's we haven't had an occupational therapist working on their doctorate on the podcast, at least in a while. I think we've had him before. But it's been a while. So I'm excited to hear a little bit about all the work that you've been doing in OT school, especially as it relates to school based OT. With that said, I actually want to give you a little bit of a moment here to kind of share a little bit about yourself and where you are in your OT journey. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so I am currently in my final year, well, final weeks really of OT school. So I'm working on my doctoral capstone project. So this is the last thing we do in our OT curriculum that we follow. And so I've already finished my courses and my fieldwork. So I'm just working on my doctoral capstone project right now. And that is around a school based practice, which I know is what we're going to talk about today. So I'm excited to share about it. Jayson Davies Awesome. And you know what, we're gonna kind of get into more about your project. But let's just talk about OT and OT School first, what made you decide to sign up for Occupational Therapy school? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so kind of an interesting journey. For me pretty much my entire life, I thought I wanted to be a teacher. So I went to college, and majored in elementary education. But during college, I also worked at a preschool just for extra money, you know, during college, so my boss, there was actually the first one who kind of told me, you know, you should really look into doing some sort of therapy, and you know, instead of teaching, and so she bugged me a lot about it. But I finally did look into it. And I found out that actually, a couple of my friends were interested in doing occupational therapy as well, and kind of got plugged in with somebody and was able to observe and OT at a pediatric clinic. And I immediately loved it, and decided that that is what I wanted to do. So as little as I knew about just observing at once, I still just thought that it was more suited for me then teaching kind of the one on one versus like one on 30 in the classroom. I kind of thought that that would be better suited for me, like I said, and so in my mind, it was still it's still teaching, it's still working with kids. And so just in a little bit of a different way and more personalized, which I think suits me better. So yeah, I continued on with my education major, finish that out, but I had to add some extra classes to get into OT school and ended up at the University of Central Arkansas and the OTD program. Jayson Davies Awesome. And so I have to ask you this while you were, what were you doing? Were you had a boss that you were doing, like teaching fieldwork or not a field work, but you were working in early elementary? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, I was working in a preschool and it was just like an after afternoon job. Just, you know, no field work or anything. It was just kind of at my church. I got plugged in got a job there. So... Jayson Davies Oh, cool. And so your boss, what was she by trade? Alexa Corley, OTD While she was the director of the preschool, I'm not quite sure of her entire background, but she had a daughter who was a speech therapist. So she kind of knew a little bit about the realm and didn't necessarily push the speech therapy, she just knew of the therapy world in general, and I guess saw something in me that would be good for that. So... Jayson Davies That's awesome. It's not always the case that we run into someone that knows about OT speech therapy and is able to give us that little bit of forethought to think about going into OT. So that's great that you had someone to kind of just even make you aware of the profession. That's pretty cool. Alexa Corley, OTD For sure. Jayson Davies So now, you made it to Central Arkansas University, and how has that been? What's your experience been like in OT school? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, it's been great and challenging. But in a good way. I, you know, I observed that OT once and then got into OT school and realized I really didn't even know what I was getting into. I didn't really even know quite what OT is. But it's been great. I've learned a lot and luckily still loved it. And you know, it was the right choice. It's been good, though, part and fun. Of course, COVID has, you know, it impacted our classes, we have a lot of online stuff, planning our fieldwork and getting that worked out was kind of crazy. But we got it and all my placements were wonderful. And so now I'm on the tail end with Capstone. And it's just been really great all around. Jayson Davies Awesome. And correct me if I'm wrong, but you are just about ready to graduate. Right? Alexa Corley, OTD Yes, August 7, just a few weeks away. Jayson Davies Well, I'm going to preemptively congratulate you by time this actually airs, you will probably be an OT graduate. So congratulations, and best of luck on the NBC OT. Alexa Corley, OTD Thank you so much. Jayson Davies Yeah. And so one more question before we move on to really diving into your Capstone. And that is we do actually have quite a few occupational therapy students that listen to this podcast. And what one piece of advice would you give to them, in their endeavor, working through OT school? Is there one thing that you learned that you could really provide some, some insight to? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, I love this question. I would definitely say maintaining that school life balance, especially in the beginning, you know, you kind of want to be perfect and studying all the time. And at least for our curriculum, the beginning semesters were the hardest, and just kind of figuring everything out. And so you kind of get caught up in all of that, but just maintaining that balance. And we're learning about occupations and helping others engage in their occupations. But then we kind of get stuck just only doing our schoolwork, so engaging your own occupations, whatever those are, and just kind of maintain that balance. Jayson Davies Yeah. And did you have one specific hobby, routine, occupation that helps you throughout OT school? Alexa Corley, OTD Anytime I could just get with my classmates outside of class, that was a big one, just anytime we could just go to lunch or anything, even if it was just in between classes. That was big for me. Jayson Davies That's nice. And you mentioned actually having a few friends that ended up being interested in OT when you were kind of finding out about it, did you all end up in the same program together? Alexa Corley, OTD One of them did. So we actually both were in the education program at my undergraduate college. And then we both are now about to graduate together from at a tea school. So that's been really fun. Jayson Davies That's nice to know someone throughout the entire experience and always have them to kind of have those those tough conversations with and then like you said, see each other outside of school, that's really sure. Alright, so let's talk a little bit about your Capstone. It is about school based. So the first question is, why did you pick a capstone based on school based OT? Obviously, you have some early intervention background? Is that it or Why? What else? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so like you said, kind of that background in education, I've pretty much been interested in school based OT the whole time, I'd love to just kind of mesh those together, my education, mind and my OT brain, put those together in my practice. So I knew I wanted to gear my capstone towards school based practice, just learn a little bit more about it myself. And, you know, have that as kind of a resume builder as well, even. So, definitely wanted to do that. And when we started the process of just kind of submitting our capstone ideas, I had just briefly talked with a professor and honestly come up with a completely different idea from where I ended up. I think it was just I can't even remember exactly, it was maybe more preschool and parent involvement. So that was like my idea I pitched and then afterwards, my faculty mentor, when we were working on solidifying our ideas and all of that, he said, just go to the literature, see what's out there and then find the gap find the need. And so that's what I did. It was perfect advice. So I went to just a jot any articles I could find about school based practice and found my need for sure. So just kind of saw in that literature, all of the best practices per se or evidence based practice out there in the art goals and what LTA was recommending for school based practitioners, but then also just all these recent surveys that there's still some misunderstanding, still, you know, those practices aren't necessarily being implemented. And also found this idea of caseload workload, which is kind of where I ended up gearing my research towards, as we'll talk about. And that was what I found to be the biggest need just how do we transition to that, because we've already seen that the workload model is more beneficial for those best practices. And so where can we fill in that gap of actually making that transition happen? So that's where I kind of landed on my capstone. Jayson Davies That's awesome. Yeah, and I don't even know if I shared this with you when we were kind of talking a few weeks ago, but I actually advise some students in their master's thesis at a university around here. And what your mentor gave you was exactly right. I mean, a lot of people go in with an idea, like they want to solve world peace, but they haven't gone and looked at the literature behind real beast to see what is actually going to take. And so I really love that advice that your mentor gave you, because that's exactly what I tell my students as well as like, you know, yeah, we want to do something related to school based OT, I want you to get that experience of school based OT. But you obviously have never worked at a school based OT, you're still in college. So you need to start with that literature review, and find out what is the missing piece. I'm sure you ran into articles such as articles by Surya and Garfinkel, they're two really big names in this whole caseload workload world. Yeah, I mean, so let's, I guess let's dive into what did you kind of go from there what you did your lit review? Well, that wasn't even your full lit review that was just kind of giving them a piece of what might be out there. So where did you go from there? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so I agree with the world peace example, you said before I answer your question, we especially I think my class, which it's great that we want to do all these world changing things. But with our capstone, we have 14 weeks. So my mentor also kind of had to bring us down a little bit and be like, you know, you only have 14 weeks to this, what's feasible. So yeah, I just wanted to throw that in there. But after that kind of initial just looking at some articles finding the need, I did do you know, some deeper literature review, especially with caseload workload, I wanted to mention, I found several things that AOTA does provide. And those authors that you mentioned, I read everything they have in their website, they're fantastic. So I looked more into that. And AOTA, there's a document from 2006, that I found, talking about the transition from caseload to workload. And then 15 years later, here we are, and they're still not really like I had never heard of it until I got into the literature. And that has that document has been updated in in 2014. But anyway, so I just saw that gap. And that kind of like blew my mind. Because the wet my personality, I'm like, why are we not? Don't we always want to be better, you know. And so the fact that it's taking so long is that just kind of blew my mind. But I saw that as a need that I could, you know, kind of try to address with my, my capstone project. And so I knew I would need a research component. So I kind of came up with what was needed based on some of the articles I read, kind of what questions have already been asked, What do we need more of to support. And I wrote the proposal for my project to include an online survey to kind of be that research component. And then also kind of included just some goals within my project to create some resources or something like that to aid school based OTs, just in the misunderstandings and the lack of education that are continually being reported just by other school staff and OTs, and just anyone in the education world kind of filling that research to practice implementation gap that's out there. Jayson Davies Absolutely. Yeah. And, you know, one of the therapists to I have had the pleasure of talking to on the podcast, and she's going to be presenting at the back to school conference that we're hosting in August, Dr. Susan Bazyk, and, you know, she has some research about how it takes, I want to say it's like, she found research, I don't think she conducted the research, maybe it was her but 14 years for research to make its way to practice. And that just kind of talks about or goes to show what you're talking about, you know, even though AOTA was talking about the transition of workload 14,15 years ago, we're just getting to the point where people are taking it seriously and really thinking about it. So it's unfortunate that it takes that long, hopefully through that. That's one of my goals, actually, through this podcast is to get research out there quicker. And so I hope we're doing that. And I'm so glad to have you on to talk a little bit about your research. So, going forward, did you have a hypothesis before you started to send out we're going to get into your questions a little bit deeper, but Before we do that, did you have a hypothesis that you were expecting to hear back from therapist? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so just based on what was already out there, I hypothesized that the workload model group, so any any practitioners taking the survey that said they're under a workload model, that they would be either more likely or just more often to engage in those practices that are out there stated as best practice? So multi tiered systems of support or collaboration, anything like that, so that they would be more likely than those under that caseload model. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Okay. And then so how did you develop your questions that you were going to send out to OTs, based upon that hypothesis and your literature review? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so I looked at, there's been a few surveys done, and either on caseload workload or just kind of perceptions of various educational staff and their perceptions of OT so I just kind of looked at all of those, and took some similar components, and also some different components more geared toward the caseload workload, I also have several mentors that helped me kind of fit that know a little bit more about the school based practice, since I'm obviously not working in it yet. And they kind of know what's going on in our State of Arkansas. And so they kind of helped me fine tune those questions and kind of what, what we were trying to get at with that hypothesis. Jayson Davies So would you mind sharing a few of those questions that you actually were able to include in in the questionnaire? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so I the ones related to the caseload workload? Well, first, I did have a few demographical type questions, you know, where do you practice? And then the model of employment? Because I think that can kind of play into it. So are you contracted? Or are you directly employed? And then obviously, do you feel like you're under a caseload approach or workload approach? So then kind of looking at that caseload or workload approach? I asked about their, the effect of that on their practice. Do they feel like they're able to meet all of their demands in their workplace? And then have they ever advocated to their administration for that model? So kind of thinking, like if they're in that workload model, was it because they advocated or not. And then they're just also they're competent in what they felt like their competence was in advocating, as well as the level of support they feel they have from their administration. And then also looking at those best practices I just asked either some form of have you, do you? Or how often do you do these certain practices? So that was like collaborative goal writing, collaborating with teachers providing professional development. Are you involved in school wide support, so not just like the direct intervention with your IEP kids, but multi tiered systems of support, things like that, and then also contextually based practices. And one of the really good questions that kind of will show up in my results, when we talk about that I asked the practitioners to quantify with the percent their time spent weekly in several different practices that I listed out. So they put percentages of how much time they felt like during their week was split up among direct intervention, evaluations, screenings, collaboration, and a few others. So that was one that was ended up being very helpful question. And there were some other other questions, but those were kind of the main ones regarding the caseload workload differences. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Okay. And so let's talk a little bit about the population. Of course, that's always a part of the capstone or any sort of research, you got to talk about the population. So who ended up taking your surveys? How many responses? did you get back? What did that look like? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so there were 92 responses started, and I ended up with 61, completed and submitted. So that's kind of how it goes with your online surveys, but it was still good. And being from Arkansas, and just the way I was able to kind of send out my survey, most of the responses were from Arkansas, it was about 55%. And then the other less than half was from around like 15 other states, but just kind of like anywhere from one to three respondents from those states. So the majority of our were from Arkansas, and then the majority were also caseload and less so of saying that they were under that workload model Jayson Davies And that was just a like a self identified I work caseload or I work workload, right. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah. So I kind of I defined it in the question. So I asked the question if they felt like they were under caseload or workload and then I said caseload refers to workload refers to and actually also had an unsure option in case they still... that wasn't enough for them to really identify themselves. And I only had six that said, unsure, so those were not included in all of data analysis. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Okay. Can I ask you actually how you defined caseload versus workload on there? You don't need to give me the exact terminology. But in general, how did you kind of word that? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, I believe it was something like caseload refers to only looking at the number of direct treatment sessions, or I may not have said direct treatment sessions, but kids on your caseload, the number of kids on your caseload, whereas workload encompasses all of the demands that you do on a weekly basis, something along those lines, Jayson Davies Absolutely. No, that's exactly what most of the resources that's kind of how they define it as well. So yeah, that's right. Alexa Corley, OTD Yes. Jayson Davies Cool. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah. Jayson Davies And you said most of them were from Arkansas, fewer, or less than half are from outside? Did you have a majority OT, majority OTA, a mixture? Or was that not even a question asked? Alexa Corley, OTD I actually didn't ask that. Specifically. I, I included it and if they wanted to take the survey, it was open to either, but I didn't define it. Jayson Davies Okay. And then you said, Yeah, like you said, most of them were Arkansas, did you have? Did you ask for other demographics, such as age or anything like that? Alexa Corley, OTD I did ask for not age, but years of practice. And I kind of divvied that up with like 1 to 5, 6 to 10 and 15 and up or something like that. And I believe I don't want to lie, but I can I can. This will be on my research, as we talk about later, but I believe most of them were that 15 and up. Jayson Davies Oh, wow. You actually had quite a few experience therapists? Alexa Corley, OTD I believe so yes. Jayson Davies Awesome. You know what, one thing that you actually mentioned earlier, too, is that you ask people whether or not they were a district employee contractor, did that skew in one way? or the other or any shockers there. Alexa Corley, OTD There were actually more people directly employed than I would have thought especially considering more people also said they were caseload approach. I guess in my brain, I was thinking, if you're directly employed, hopefully you've kind of are trying to move to that workload model approach. But that didn't necessarily correlate yet. So that was a little bit surprising, but still good that there were more directly employed than I would have thought. Jayson Davies Gotcha. Well, that's nice. I mean, I know being directly employed or being a contractor is very regional based, it really depends on where you are. I know talking from some therapists in New York, that like almost everyone is a contracted therapist, versus I'm in California. And a lot of districts are starting to hire now, their own OTs, I think, a few years ago is a lot of contractors. But now districts are really trying to hire their own therapist. And I think there's so many factors related to that. I mean, what the district considers a caseload or workload, obviously factors into that, what the pay scale is for an occupational therapist, and that general area also contributes to whether or not a district decides to hire their own or, or outside. Unfortunately, I think districts also take into account whether or not that person will be a part of a union or not, or things like that. It's HR and hiring practices are way beyond my scope of understanding. But there's so many variables that that are considered considered with that. And so it's kind of nice to hear that it sounds like you're saying in Arkansas, that more OTs are employed directly by a district or a county of education or something like that. Is that what it seemed like? Alexa Corley, OTD It seems like maybe with my survey, now, I'm not sure you know, depending on who took it, maybe they were just the ones that happen to be more likely, because also in Arkansas, we just have a lot of small rural districts too. And so that's kind of a conversation I've had with my mentor, and just some other, you know, educational staff that we probably will never not have the need. And like you said, by region, it really just depends on never not have the need for that contract model just with the smaller schools and the needs. So it's just interesting, I guess, maybe just with my survey, they just happen to be more of them than if it were directly employed. So I'm not really sure about the state of Arkansas, cuz like I said, we do have a lot of smaller districts. So it's interesting. Jayson Davies Yeah, in the smaller districts, they don't have a need for 40 hours a week. And so right, you might have a therapist split between five different districts and then oh, bless, then you have to drive like an hour in between school districts every day is it's crazy. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah. Jayson Davies All right. So let's get into some of your results then. What was your overarching finding those kind of the biggest thing for you? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, so I got to To run all of the fun statistical analysis, and there were some, you know, statistically significant differences between the caseload workload groups, and some of those variables, you know, from the questions I asked. So one of the things which I didn't mention this as a question I asked earlier, but this was something my mentor and I talked about, I asked them if they were members of professional learning communities, or PLCs. And the results of that showed that in a workload model, they were more likely to be members of that PLC than in the caseload model. And that just said to me, you know, they're more they're more a part of the school community, that they're being engaged in more of those collaborative processes with other educators. And like I said, Yeah, just seen as part of the school community. So that was just kind of an additional question I asked that gave a little bit of insight about the collaborative process. And then as far as those best practices I mentioned earlier, and how much time is spent in those activities? Like in that one question. practitioners in the workload model, spent more time engaging in collaboration with teachers. So that was one of those variables, providing behavioral supports, and consulting with family. So those three variables from the percentage question that I mentioned earlier, workload model lends itself better to those. And then they also spent more of their treatment hours with those contextually based services. They reported more time with that, which is one of those evidence based practices, there's continuing education articles about that. And also just the way that IDEA spells out the least restrictive environment, you know, being supportive of that. So that was a good finding there. And then workload model practitioners also reported spending less time in just the direct intervention category, compared to the workload or the excuse me the caseload model. So on that percentage question, I asked how much time they thought they spent in direct intervention. And the caseload model practitioners, that mean reported there was higher for for those caseload practitioners than the workload practitioners. Does that make sense there? Jayson Davies Yeah. So they were spending more time with direct therapy, potentially one to one or small group, as opposed to the workload therapists who reported using a workload model. Were getting into the classrooms more and helping the teachers collaborate a little bit more, it sounds like, Alexa Corley, OTD exactly, yeah. So that's kind of what that was telling me too, that was an important because they're not just spending time, you know, there's always going to be the kids that you do need that direct intervention services, but IDEA and ESA, and all of those things also tell us we can be a part of prevention services and school wide supports, and educating staff and all of that. And so the way that the workload model practitioners, their time was split up was more distributed to all of those things, rather than caseload being mostly distributed to that direct intervention. Jayson Davies Awesome. Love that you found that. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, yeah. So the open responses, I also had just some open response questions that I didn't, you know, specifically analyze in, I just kind of looked at myself and kind of coded myself. So they, the workload model practitioners also just describe, they use a lot of words talking about flexibility and being... having an easier time with scheduling and adjusting their staff. And then the caseload model practitioners reported a lot of things like, not enough time scheduling is too hard. We can't they don't understand pushin services, we can't do this, and this and this. And so it was a lot more negative terms, kind of with those open responses. Whereas the workload, people kind of talked more about flexibility and being able to maybe easier, more meet those demands that we've been talking about all those different practices. Jayson Davies That's awesome. I think I see. I mean, I've never done research on it. But just in my clinical practice, I've seen similar type of attitudes. I feel like, you know, a lot of people feel like they're restricted by case loads. I mean, I've had conversations with a lot of administrators and it's more like, well, this is why everything needs to be an individual pullout, or even small group is because it comes from a model where the schools get reimbursed for that. And, you know, we are told that we are not supposed to base our treatment recommendations based upon insurance or any type of reimbursement. And there's a huge disconnect there because we're being told one thing by our district, potentially And then doing another thing, and or we're doing what our district is, is telling us to do simply because of that, that one payment reason. And a lot of times administrators don't know that another way can happen. And that's a barrier to because there are OTs, they want to make the switch. But obviously, it's difficult for them. I actually want to dive into this next part, because you haven't mentioned this yet. But I know you have like a whole other aspect. I know, it's a small aspect. But you actually went beyond just talking to OTs, right? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, I did. So kind of while my survey was, you know, just out getting responses, I had some meetings with different school staff. So I was able to meet with some special education directors and some school based OTs, and just kind of go a little bit deeper, just for my personal learning about what school OT looks like. And various districts in Arkansas, I kind of tried to meet with different districts, you know, in various areas of the state, because like, we've talked about regions, it can be different. I just know, in Arkansas, we've got several places where things are kind of changing. And other, you know, smaller districts, like we talked about, where they still kind of need some education there. And so I was able to meet with those people over just over some zoom meetings. And I met with the sped directors and OTs, from two different districts that are already kind of using that workload model approach to services, and they're doing some great things. And so at each of those schools, I was able to talk to the sped director and the OT from from each of them. So I got both perspectives. And so those two districts kind of talked about their transition process to the workload model. And for both of them, it came from a bit higher up in the chain. So for one of them, she talked about the sped director talked about their superintendents being the ones who gained some sort of information, I'm not sure specifically what that information was or where it came from, but some information from the state level, and brought that change brought that information into their school district of hiring their OT directly, and implementing them into more school wide supports, and like social emotional learning programs, kind of allowing them to head that up. So that's really awesome for them, and they're still, you know, their culture is just kind of always what can they do to be better to be better for the kids. And so they're, they're still doing some great things. And then the other district, I also talked to the sped director, and it wasn't this particular director that had spearheaded the change, but he knew about it and kind of came in in the middle of it. And he told me that for their district, it was the sped director who kind of did the same thing, he came across some information from his higher ups, I guess, and realized that they needed to do some things differently. So they hired their OTs directly, and began transitioning to that more school based workload approach. Now in that conversation, what I found interesting was that he knew that it would take a few years, and he told his staff and his OTs, like, this is gonna take three years, give it three years to get this, you know, more fully implemented, where the teachers know what's going on. And everyone's kind of educated more about what OT can do. And now they have this past year, they implemented some RTI groups. And we're even, you know, taking data on that, which is awesome. That's kind of, you know, another piece, I think that we need to be doing, keeping that data and following up to show the improvements. And you know, really what OT the benefits of OT and being a part of those processes. So those were kind of the workload districts now the other, I think it was two or three districts I talked with, we're not even really familiar with those terms, caseload and workload, which is a bit more of what I expected. So especially with OT and RTI, like I mentioned that a few times, and they were like, no, that's not really a thing here, and, and then I kind of gave some examples of what that would actually look like. And I remember one of them being like, Oh, yeah, I guess that would work. So you mean, like more schoolwide and like education? And I was like, yeah, we can do that. And so the, you know, it's kind of some discussion and education, you know, I wasn't stepping on any toes, but I was just trying to kind of get some thoughts rolling and was able to do that with those districts that weren't as familiar with it. So just from those overall, just kind of the education and advocacy piece that kind of needs to be get going to kind of get everyone on the same page, if that makes sense. Jayson Davies Yeah. And at those districts, were you still talking to a director of special education or was a principal or what? Who were you talking to those ones? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, those were still the special education directors, I tried to get in touch with principals and superintendents at some of the schools and just it wasn't able to kind of plan those out with them. They're a little busier, I guess. So that didn't get to work out. But the other conversations are great. Jayson Davies Whenyou were talking to the special ed directors, how familiar with even occupational therapy did they seem? Alexa Corley, OTD So they actually did seem pretty familiar with OT, and what they were doing, and even complimented their OTs and some of the things they did. And so I think they were trying to do, you know, do some of the, you know, quote, best practices, and they were doing good things, for sure. But I think just not quite understanding the full school based model. And I think if you don't really even understand that fully, then it's kind of hard to go to the caseload to workload transition, if you're not even sure about what OTs role is in the school, you know. Jayson Davies Absolutely. But that's awesome that you at least got a general idea that they understood OT, I think by time you get to a special ed, Director type of position, you've been a special education teacher, likely, you've might have been an RSP teacher, or maybe a teacher in a more severe needs. And you might have even been a coordinator something in special education, and you probably have had to work with some occupational therapists over the years. So that's nice that they at least seemed like they understood OT because I've talked to people and their boss, who might be a coordinator, the director of OT of the occupational therapist, they really don't understand their job. And it's unfortunate when you hear that, so I'm glad that these people kind of seemed like they knew what what occupational therapy was. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, for sure. Jayson Davies What would you say are kind of, we'll get to the point where we're starting to wrap up a little bit. But what do you think are your overall key takeaways? You know, you're about to head into your career as an occupational therapist, potentially, in the schools. What were some of your key takeaways from this? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, I would say the main thing is that just the need for the wider education on a piece roll in school, like school wide, like those teachers, perceptions, and even across the state. So I also asked an open response question in my survey about the barriers and challenges to school based OT, which I had seen in previous surveys, but just kind of wanted to know, just kind of wanted to ask it again, and about half of the responses mentioned that the people in their school don't know what OT does. So that's just still like the main kind of thing that matches the previous study. So I think if there was just some guidance, or education kind of from that top down level, that will be helpful, especially like those two districts. As an example, you know, they started that change with the superintendents, or the sped directors, and so kind of that top down, change. But then also, I think, you know, OTs themselves needing some resources on how to explain the transition, and practically applying their advocacy skills and, and describing, you know, what they can do in the schools. And so, you know, at that district that said, it takes three years to fully implement with both encouraging and discouraging, you know, that it would have to take so long, but also, maybe there are more people trying to transition to that, and it just takes a while. So you know, change, good change, all that takes time. So I think just those education and advocacy pieces, and also just, you know, we talked a lot about my literature review, just the importance of doing and reading research, I think is important too. And that's something I've definitely taken away from this Capstone. Jayson Davies That's amazing. And that is a lifelong skill, right? There's understanding that you need to read the research, you need to stay up to date with AOTA or sorry, well, AOTA gets you a job. So if you stay up to date to AOTA you get access to Asia, and you also get access to other research as well, the Canadian Journal of OT and yeah, there's so many good journals out there. I know you created some resources. But first, I want to ask you go back to those interviews that you had with occupational therapists. How did they describe the transition? I know, it was long, three years, potentially. But what did they think about the transition? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, they were pretty much they were mostly positive about it. I mean, they've, they were on board with it, too. You know, I think I also talked to some contract based OTs that, you know, they liked that model, and they which like we said, you know, it's needed that they kind of liked their being able to just go in for the day and leave when they you know, got to leave and not not that that's a bad thing. But the ones that were kind of transitioning with that workload model, you know, they kind of they wanted that change and they put the work in for it and helps to educate the teachers and you know, we're all positive about how that has helped their school. You know, kind of talking about the results of their RTI groups they implemented or the social emotional learning programs when I talked to did like some yoga things in the classrooms and just all the positive results from that. So they definitely said that it was worth the three year wait or, you know, however long it took for that to fully implement. Jayson Davies Yeah, and you know, I'm sure you know, you're one, maybe they did a little bit of push in for one or two classes. And then the next year, those two classes turned into four classes. And then by year three, you're surprised by how quickly you can go from pulling students out every 30 minutes to instead of pulling them out, you know, you can see, maybe three of your kids are all in one classroom. And instead of pulling them out 30 minutes each, which adds up to 90 minutes. You just went into that classroom for an hour instead. And you were able to help them all, despite not pulling them out individually. So there's so much you can do. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah. Jayson Davies All right. So based upon all of this, I know what the capstone, yes, you do some research, but typically, there's another side to it something that you're actually acting on doing based upon your research. So what is it that you're doing, obviously, an awesome podcast, but that's not even part of your your Capstone, by the way, everyone listening out there, but what are you actually what what is the back end of this project? What are you doing to further that caseload workload, gap or momentum that we have? Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah. So like you said, there is that other aspect of the capstone. So one of my goals was to create some sort of resource tool, based on my findings, and just all the information I've been looking through for the past four months, I don't even know how long. So just all the things I found during this experience that were helpful for me, and I will say a lot of that was from AOTA like, they really do have a lot for school based OT and just a job. So I definitely encourage people to be AOTA members, we've had to be through school. And I definitely think it's helpful. So I... back to my resource. So I created that this kind of resource tool just to be kind of just a culmination of, like I said, all the things I've found. So it's pretty simple. It's really just kind of my study findings. There's links to some fliers that I've created, there's links to my research manuscript. And just any kind of links, or any kind of programs I've found helpful, or looked through that are school based OT related. So I've just kind of included all that in one place, and then kind of put, you know, links in there to those different resources. And then I've also had the chance to create a presentation for OTs role in RTI processes, Response to Intervention processes. And so that's been fun to just dive in and learn more about that. And just kind of provide that as a tool for school based OTs. And hopefully, that will be kind of published soon, I'm working with my mentor to put that she works at Easter Seals and kind of put that out there for people to have. And that will be linked in my resource tool, too. So yeah, that's kind of what I have done to culminate all of this. Jayson Davies Awesome. And so I have to ask you, obviously, is that available that people can access your your resources? Alexa Corley, OTD Yes. So I went ahead and made a website. So every thing and everything I've done related to this can kind of be found in that one spot. And so some of it's still being finalized and the final touches, but as soon as it's ready, it'll be on there. And it's just my name. It's alexancorley.com. I'll spell that out. A-L-E-X-A, the letter N Corley C-O-R-L-E-Y.com. Jayson Davies Awesome. And we of course, will be sure to add that link in the show notes so that anyone can find it for the future. Awesome, perfect. Well, I am excited to also check that out, I gotta be sure to get on there and find what you got on there. For anyone listening, Alexa obviously already knows this, because I'm gonna tell the story about how Alexa and myself came to actually doing this podcast. Alexa, I gotta thank you, because you found out I am in the process of creating a course for school based OTs that just kind of that how to transition from a caseload to a workload model. And you just decided to send me a blind email basically, and say, Hey, I'm doing my capstone on this. And I would love to kind of just share what I have and help in any way. And so I really want to just say thank you so much. I really appreciate you reaching out and just being open to talk about this because this is something that's so important for school based OTs, and I don't know that everyone realizes yet how important it is. I think it is. It's going to be so beneficial, not only for us as a profession, but also helpful for the students that we serve the teachers that we serve and the districts that we serve. I really think that we have more to provide than a pullout model caseload every 30 minute sessions, and I really do think that it's important that we make that transition to a workload where we can get out of those pullout model sessions and really get embedded into the classrooms. And, and helping teachers because if you pull out a kid, you can only see that kid for 30 minutes, maybe once a week. But if you are able to use that same 30 minutes to teach a teacher, something new, that teacher is going to teach 30 kids this year, 30 Kids next year, 30 kids the year after that, and touch so many more lives, that you would ever be able to help if you don't teach that teacher that one lesson. So I think that is so valuable. And yeah, I just really appreciate you coming on here. And I really appreciate the the research that you that you did. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, absolutely. Thank you for being so responsive. And just excuse me, all that you do with your podcast and the school based OT resources, I think I've listened to like half of them just in doing my just kind of learning and doing my capstone. And so yeah, I agree with all of that you said and I know how it worked in school based OT yet, but I had so much fun learning and doing this research, and so I can't wait to hopefully be in the schools in the future. Jayson Davies Yeah, definitely. And you know, whatever school district whatever contractor you end up working with straight out of school, they will be very lucky to have you just having someone that understands what school based OT is, even before jumping into it. I mean, just knowing that you know what IEP stands for Ida those things, you know, that's so that's so valuable as a school based OT one final question, I guess for you is, is that the route? Do you think you're going to end up trying to find a job in school based OT after school? Or what are you thinking? Alexa Corley, OTD So honestly, at this point, I'm not super Sure, just with the timing of you know, graduation is in August, and then have to study for NBC OT, and just kind of what I've seen that's available right now in our console. I don't know if that'll be the immediate route. But definitely in the future. That's, that's where I'm headed. Even if I have to get some experience somewhere else at first. Yeah, I'm definitely headed for the schools in the future. Jayson Davies Yeah, definitely. And you know, I add a school out of occupational therapy school, I got lucky, I found a contract gig. And I got very lucky, it was a contract gig. But like you were talking about, I was really, I clocked in and clocked out. I didn't have to build every single session for that we were really basically a part of that school. And so we felt as though we were employed by the school, even though we weren't it felt that way, and very lucky to have that. But a lot of times, it may be easier to get a job with a contractor, get that experience and then move into a district. And so of course, I want to I want to wish you the best of luck with that. And the last thing that I have to ask is research never happens in a bubble and never happens all on your own. So is there anyone that you'd like to shout out for their support or for helping you out? Alexa Corley, OTD Absolutely. I had three mentors for this project. My faculty mentor at UCA was Dr. Chris Ryan, and then my expert mentors just kind of in the field were Jessica Cruz, and then Dr. Amanda Britt. So Dr. Ryan is like I said faculty at UCA, he just kind of made sure I was on track doing what I needed to do. Jessica is she was a school based OT now she's a school based OT consultant. So she had tons of expertise to offer me. And then Amanda has previous experience as a superintendent. So I got her perspective on that area and her, you know, perspective on OTs in schools and making that transition, she had experience with that as well. So I got all of their perspectives and feedback throughout this process. And just definitely want to say thank you to all of them for their help. Jayson Davies Definitely. Well, Alexa, it has been so nice to have you on. Thank you for sharing everything that you did for the school based OT community with us. Alexa Corley, OTD Yeah, thank you for having me. It's so fun. Jayson Davies All right, well, we will have to stay in touch because I'm sure you have more great things coming up in your future with school based OT. So please feel free to reach out anytime, if you ever need anything. All right. Alexa Corley, OTD Awesome. Thank you so much. Jayson Davies Alright, I hope you all really enjoyed that discussion with Alexa Corley. Everything that she's doing is just for the betterment of school based OT In my opinion, I really think that we do need to move from that caseload to a more workload approach. And I'm so glad that she took in the perspective from people outside the role of OT from the administrators or whatnot. That is just awesome. Be sure to check out the show notes so you can find her website and get those resources she was talking about. And yeah, one more time. Thank you so much to Alexa for coming on sharing everything that she did. And thank you, to you for listening to this episode. Really appreciate it. I could not do this if no one listened to the podcast. So I love that you're here. I love that you are continuing to learn. And I love that you want to learn so that you can better serve your students and the teachers you work with. Take care and I'll see you next time. on the podcast. Bye. Amazing Narrator Thank you for listening to the OT School House podcast. For more ways to help you and your students succeed right now, head on over to OT School House.com. Until next time, class is dismissed. Freebies! Be sure to subscribe to the OT School House email list & get access to our free downloads of Gray-Space paper and the Occupational Profile for school-based OTs. Have any questions or comments about the podcast? Email Jayson at Jayson@otschoolhouse.com Well, Thanks for visiting the podcast show notes! If you enjoyed this episode be sure to subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts Click here to view more episodes of the OT School House Podcast
- A Back To School List From a School-based Occupational Therapist (PDF included)
This past week my wife and I were browsing through our local Target. I am a school-based occupational therapist and my wife is a now a 4th-grade teacher. Neither of us work in the school district we, or this target, reside in. So given the fact that we both work in education, you can imagine our excitement when we found this setup at Target (pictured) and realized that each teacher at the nearby schools had a handout for needed school materials. Literally, each teacher, from each school had a handout in those little slots noting what students in their class would need. And while yes, I know, schools should be providing all the materials (hence, a FREE and appropriate public education) the reality is that teachers (and OTs) need help sometimes. So yeah, I thought that was super cool. But it also got me thinking... What if OTs got to make a back to school list for parents to have? What would I put on my list of supplies Target puts out as Mr. Davies' list of occupational therapy supplies for your child. So, I posted this picture to Instagram and asked @Target if I could put a list of OT supplies together for them including many items children could use to succeed in schools. I can assure you, @Target did not respond... But some of you did! A few of you raised your hands, using emojis of course. So then I started making a list and here it is. Keep in mind, this is not for any 1 age group... Mr. Davies' List of OT materials to help kids succeed in school Three different types of pencils Small or broken crayons A fidget (not a toy) Accordion file folder Something appropriate to chew Stickers Stylus Earplugs Words of encouragement Box Wiggle cushion See our curated Amazon shopping list with these items Click Here (Amazon Affiliate link that supports the OT School House) Get the list in a PDF handout form below! Some of these, of course, seem obvious to you who are OTs and special education teachers, but others may not. So I'm going to do two things below. First, I'm going to explain why each made the list. And then at the bottom of the post, you can download a cheat sheet of this list to do with as you will. So let's get started. #1 Three Different Types of Pencils Why 3 different types of pencils? Because you never know which one is going to work for a kid. Some kids do great with a small pencil, others prefer fat pencils. Who am I to judge. As adults we all have our preference, so why shouldn't our students. I am a believer in the idea that we all gravitate to what works for us. Hence, let your student have options and see what works for them. Here are 3 pencils you may want to try out. (Click on the picture to view on Amazon) #2 Small or Broken Crayons Now, I love the look and smell of a brand new box of crayons as much as the next person. But sometimes we just have to break 'em. Crayons that are broken into small pieces, or just small in general, help children on the verge of developing in-hand manipulation skills and functional a pencil grasp. So the next time you see broken crayons about to be thrown out, grab those suckers and let the kids go crazy with them. Break some regular crayons or check out these tiny crayons. #3 A Fidget (not a toy) A toy is something a child actively engages with. It not only entices their hands but also their mind. A fidget, on the other hand, keeps the hand or hands busy with minimal exertion from the mind. Sometimes a fidget can even soothe the mind without even consciously trying to do so. Think of that coin in your pocket that you sometimes mindlessly flip in your pocket or the pen you click aimlessly at your morning meeting. If your student may need a fidget, check out these "fidgets" on Amazon. #4 Accordion File Folder This is one for the kids who have some difficulty organizing their papers and homework. If you know a student who's binder really does look like the dog chewed it up, this may be something worth trying out. Find one that fits into the student's backpack and can be opened without having to take it out. Then, work with your student to label each section in a way that makes sense to the child. Here's one from Amazon: #5 Something Appropriate To Chew On Many kids are soothed by chewing. Chewing can work like a fidget, except it occurs in the mouth as opposed to the child's hand. Some kids wear chewable necklaces while others prefer to chew on straws. I have frequently advocated for students to be able to chew gum at school. Sometimes, just providing the student with a crunchy snack can help. Either the teacher or the parent can provide these snacks. Here are a few things on Amazon you might try with your students: #6 Stickers! Stickers have so many uses! They with with everything from assisting preschoolers in refining their pincer grasps and bilateral hand skills to helping first graders with spacing between words. You can check out the entire post I wrote for more ideas on why stickers are so amazing and how you can use them to help your student(s). Check out these Emoji stickers! #7 Tablet Stylus Every time a child uses a tablet, we have the opportunity to reinforce their use of a pencil by using a stylus. So many schools are putting iPads into the classroom, but they are are not looking at the fine motor side effects of using a tablet. I'm seeing too many kids using their middle finger when using a tablet as opposed to their index finger. Then when they go to pick up a coin, they use their middle finger for that as well. That makes it more difficult for them to manipulate that coin or other small items. By using a stylus, you prevent children from developing poor habits through tablet use. Check out these styluses: Here are some apps you may want to try out as well! #8 Earplugs Let's be honest, there are a lot of loud noises at school. Be it the teacher, the proctor, or the bell installed back in the 80's, these things can hurt little ears. Even if it doesn't damage the physical structure of the inner ear, the noises can be very disruptive to a child's focus. They are simple and discrete; for the right student, they can make a world of a difference. Some teachers and schools will even allow students to listen to music during independent work time. #9 Words of Encouragement The best thing about this one, it's free. Or at least it can be. I saw this idea years ago and I think it's too simple for any parent not to do it. Just write down a few words of encouragement on a colorful paper and stick it in your child's lunch pail. You can even "batch process" several of these weeks in advance. Make it more interesting by making a game out of it. While it may not help a student focus more in class the moment they read it, feeling loved has never hurt a child's ability to succeed. Here's some from Amazon if you'd like to save some time of need some for the days you are in a rush. #10 Box or Stool Have you ever gone into your student's classroom and noticed that they cannot reach the floor with their feet when seated properly in their chair. You likely take quick note of this without diving any deeper into the effects of this. From my years of experience, students who cannot touch the floor are more often wiggling in or rocking their chair, half sitting-half standing in their chairs, out of their seat completely. While a correctly sized chair an desk is the best fix for this problem, it is often hard to come by in public schools. A quick fix can be a small step stool or solid box of some kind that the student can rest their feet on to feel stable in their chair. When in a jam, you can even use this box: Or you can purchase a small foot stool like this one: #11 Wiggle Cushion If your child still likes to move around a lot even with his/her feet stable on the ground or a box, you may want to try a Disc'O'Sit air cushion or wiggle cushion as I often call them. This air-filled disc is easy to fill with a pump and can withstand most kids playful attempt to pop it. More importantly, it allows students to get their movement in while staying in their seat. It is ideal for the student that appears to be lost in space, but can then answer any question when called on. Plus, it's easy to move to the floor during circle time. Just be sure that once you put it on the chair the child can still reach the floor. And of course, you can find it on Amazon! Just click on the picture. Sum It Up! Alright, that's my 11 item list that I would suggest every parent look into for their student, even if they don't receive special education services. Nothing is crazy expensive and most teachers would be okay with them in the class so long as the student does not misuse them. You can see every item Here on our Amazon list. Interested in having this list on a one-page handout? Download it just below this text! If you'd like more freebies that we have to offer, sign up here! When you sign up, you'll receive 3 more free resources and receive periodic emails from us about more free stuff when it becomes available. Thank you all for checking out this post. If you feel I missed something on my list, comment below. I'd love to hear your thoughts. Take care and I hope you have a great start to the school year! -Jayson Learn more about Jayson on our About Page












